A Tale of Two Seasons: Brumbies Edge Tahs in Tight One

Hugh Cavill July 7, 2012 19

No GravatarTonight the Brumbies downed the Waratahs in a tight fixture at ANZ Stadium in front of a pretty poor crowd of 22,844. The Waratahs had the weight of possession but couldn’t break the spirited Brumbies defence, while the visitors took almost every chance they were offered.

In the end I thought the game (and the season more broadly) boiled down to one word: enthusiasm. The Brumbies hit every ball at pace, ran wide with gusto and tackled their hearts out. The Tahs were slow, ponderous and narrow. As usual. They had plenty of ball but lacked the creativity or attitude to really make it count. Despite their scoring a couple of nice tries it is definitely a case of back to the drawing board yet again. The Brumbies will be rightly flying high after breaking their Sydney hoodoo. Yet again it was a solid team effort with few real standouts.

The Waratahs dominated possession and territory for much of the first half, but walked away 5–9 down on the scoreboard thanks to the accurate boots of Zack Holmes and Jesse Mogg. The game began with the Tahs holding the ball in midfield, struggling to breach the Brumbies’ defences. This was to be a common theme for the half. Occasional Brumbies forays into the Tahs’ half yielded points almost every time, thanks to indiscipline at the ruck from the home side. Wycliff Palu was off early after copping a knock to the shoulder, which the Tahs don’t think was too serious. The solitary try for the half came in the 32nd minute, with TPN diving over after a period of prolonged NSW possession that saw Benn Robinson turn down kickable shots at goal on three occasions.

The second half started in a similar manner to the first, with the Tahs dominating possession and territory but not quite cracking the Brumbies’ defence. Berrick Barnes opened the scoring with a penalty goal after yet another passage of multiple phases on the Brumbies line. The Tahs would chalk up their second try soon after thanks to some nice work from Barnes close to the line. He added the extras and the Tahs were out to a 15-9 lead. But this would not last too long, with the Brumbies revelling in their first passage of prolonged possession for the half. Stephen Moore and Peter Kimlin made good ground in tight, then Holmes threw yet another beautiful cutout to give Henry Speight yet another five-pointer. Mogg added a penalty goal and the Brumbies were up 19-15 with a quarter of an hour left to play. The scoreboard attendant was not troubled from that moment on, with the Brumbies holding out well in the final minutes.

If I had to pick a Man of the Match from the Brumbies’ solid ensemble it would be Nic White. He controlled the game beautifully, and combined well with Zack Holmes, who also had a belter. Ben Mowen and Steve Moore also stood out in tight. Coming through injury-free was a definite plus, as it now seems they have locked in their place in the final six. And rightfully so.

For the home side, I was impressed with Dave Dennis, TPN and AAC. The experiment of playing Hart and Foley in the 9 and 10 slots largely failed, I thought. Foley played like Barnes-lite, and made little impact on the game. Same goes for Hart, who didn’t do much of note.

Where to now for the Tahs? I think they will just want to get next week over with, frankly. This season has been a disaster and I wouldn’t blame them if they spend the week flicking through brochures for the end-of-season trip. Actually I would, that would be fairly unprofessional. But you get what I’m saying.

Discussion »

  • Hannibal

    In the end it comes down to committment and enthusiasm. The Brumbies came out and were willing to put more of themselves on the line than the Tahs. It’s a familiar story. The Waratahs don’t stand for anything anymore. There’s no culture left there for the players to believe in. It’s just a job.

    For the Brumbies you can see its a crusade.

    • murph

      They also know that they’ll get selected for the Wallabies no matter how poorly they perform at provincial level

      • murph

        BTW, Horne missed 4 of his 10 tackle attempts. Yep! Keep picking him Robbie.

  • Brumby Jack

    I’m still trying to work out who won the post match presser contest. What a pearler cryptjc answer from Jake White!

    Thanks to Barbarian for arranging some top food in the nedia box tonight

  • Scarfman

    My kids’ highlight was TahMan dancing to “Don’t Stop ’til you Get Enough.” Actually, that might have been my highlight, too.

  • Cantab

    Hats off to the 22,843 brumbies fans who put in the effort to mission it to Sydney for the game.

  • Morsie

    The highlight of the game for me was watching Paddy Ryan’s complete domination of Ben Alexander at scrum time. I trust Deans also noted it. He destroyed him.

    Its clear the Waratah’s have the cattle but the coach just has to go. There is no alternative. I think Foley is a GREAT forwards and scrum coach, the best in the country in fact but clearly some kind of inspirational spark is just not there. They look a dispirited and uninspired bunch under him and the basic mistakes are just too common, and those basic mistakes too often happen when they’re hard on attack.

    Perhaps a new captain would help as well, Fat Cat is a fine player but like the coach doesn’t seem at all inspirational.

  • Stats?

    Jake White dropped an interesting stat into his post match press conference, saying the Brumbies haven’t conceded a point in the last 20 minutes in nine games. At least, it would be interesting if it wasn’t entirely false. Toby Lynn scored against them in the 68th minute just LAST WEEK.

    • murph

      Not surprising. A few weeks back during the ACT v QLD game, Greg Martin noted that the Brumbies were the best conditioned team in the Aus conference and that the Reds used to be but no longer were – citing bigheaded attitudes among some Reds players as the reason.

      It’s hard not to agree with him

    • Ulrich

      I believe he meant for 9 of the games they have played, not “the last 9 games”.

  • typo26

    Just go’s to show that the “no names” could still play terrible rugby but beat the star studded wallaby waratahs, something has to be wrong within the fundamentals at the waratahs

    • Brumby Jack

      Typo,

      Are the Fun da Mentals the Waratah equivalent of the ‘Fun der Merwes’?

  • http://BigFella Big Fella

    The Waratahs need to get back to enjoying their rugby.

    Sure rugby is now a profession, BUT if you’re not enjoying it, do something else.

    When is the last time you saw the Waratahs players having fun, celebrating, laughing, or passionate on the field?
    Compare this to the Reds, Brumbies, Crusaders etc.

    They need a massive change in attitude, and it starts with each individual player getting back to the reason why they started playing rugby……to have fun and enjoy themselves.

  • Nutta

    I thought the Donkeys played well with what they had. They took ther chances, challenged the referees limits and came away with it. Grand. The Tahs were huge. Some of those blokes look likem condoms full of walnuts! But they were ponderous and predictable. Thus they lost.

    What I will say though was that Paddy Ryan munched BennyA time & time again which was why NSW kept calling those scrums on the Donkeys line. Tahs very unlucky to not get penalty try I thought. Also noticed Robbie Deans in the crowd – wonder if he also noticed BennyA getting munched by a bloke who has spent more time on the sideline then on the park of late?

  • http://ttpi.org Shaun

    I’d Hart made a fair stab of things, forcing the runners to actually *gasp* run onto the ball for once

  • chasmac

    I haven’t seen the game yet, but reading various comments it seems the waratahs problem is a lack of accuracy rather than a lack of commitment. The are hapless in attack. Appears to me that it is a coaching issue, as the same people – Barnes, AAC and Horne were able to hold their own against Wales last month. The waratahs backs coach is where I think we have a problem. Hopefully mamagement can rectify this but they sound inept as well. Bring on 2013.

  • NTA

    Putting it out there with the uncanny accuracy that only I can summon:

    1) Hart gave our backline the best service it has received all year, and they had no idea what to do with it. He was left waiting too many times for a receiver and that is in no way his fault. Perhaps the only thing he could have done differently was to snipe a little more but I imagine his instructions were to avoid doing so in such puissant company.

    2) Time to flick Cliffy Palu – he’s too worried about getting injured, which just makes him more prone to injury when he does stutter-step into contact.

    3) Ben Alexander is now officially a crap loosehead, as well as a crap tighthead. Should not get near another Wallaby squad.

    4) Homebush DOES NOT WORK when your team is that bad at drawing a crowd. It is a poor venue at the best of times, and the elbow-patch wearing crowds who don’t know how to cheer around their glass of Chardonnay make it even worse. Renegotiate it to a finals-only venue and save us all the agony. Travelling to the SFS is a complete shitfight for me compared to the Olympic precinct, but the ground is better for the kind of crowds the Tahs are capable of drawing.

    5) The backline coach needs to go.

    6) Dean Mumm won’t be missed – the guy does not seem to know or understand any of the Laws of rugby, and wallowing in rucks like he does is perfectly suited to the English style of rugby.

    7) The Tahs need to stop picking injured players and start picking merit players. Only then will the rot stop.

    8) Dissolve the NSWRU Board and start again. No expense accounts either – get in people who actually give a damn and want to see the whole province succeed ahead of their political agendas.

  • NTA

    Fire the Waratahs’ conditioning coach (or whatever they’re using). Not fit enough to execute when required.

  • john allyne

    Warathas backs have no understanding of whats required to play flat line attack, Their leader Barnes is the most selfish player why did the Broncos , Reds get rid of him, he wants to play what position suits him and as for Mitchell he is over weight like his /

Close