Aussie S14 finish predictions

Matt Rowley February 10, 2010 17

No Gravatar

super14You’ve seen (or at least read about) the trials, the coaches, the players. So where do you reckon the Aussie S14 teams will net out by the end of the season?

To give you something to chew on (or laugh at), a few of the G&GR pundits have put their rocks on the block and the table below is what we came up with. Interestingly, while it was all done independently of one another, the results look remarkably similar. Seems that being north of the border only put you out by 1 place, but retains a deathwish for the Force. Well, it’s understandable to not want to be last….

Team Noddy Juan Cote Gagger Sean Maloney
Brumbies 1st. The George factor kicks it over for me. Add to it the impact of Gits and Rocky and it’s their year. 3rd – With Alexander returning from injury early, the planets seem to be aligning 2nd: Many big names congregating in Canberra this year, question is, can they all gel in a season? I reckon they’ll go damn close 2nd – Mix one part Elsom and one part Giteau with a pending George Smith fairytale and you’ve got yourself a top two finish.
Waratahs 5th. I worry about their depth in some positions. Out centre, and lock, namely. 5th – I still think the lack of a decent no.13 will disrupt their backline. Why have NSW never had a decent no.13? 4th: There or there-abouts because of the pack alone, there are still some big question marks through the backs 4th – Hickey’s more settled, Phil Waugh’s pumped knowing Smith’s packing his bags at the end of the season and Berrick’s on track to become the S.F.S’s new favourite son.
Reds 9th. That’s optimism my friend. It’s up to the pack big time, and that’s where Link comes into play. 8th – Improvements will be made but it won’t be good enough. Absence of a bench player who can cover lock & six a big problem 10th: Link’s already making inroads, but you can only go so far without an engine. Just too much youth to compete 10th – Seemingly always one injury away from disaster. If they have a winning season Link should be given a tickertape parade through ‘The Valley’.
Force 11th. Pretorius is a massive blow. That can’t rely on Barto the whole year. No hooker is also an issue. 9th – Pek at hooker, Sheehan at 9, no 5/8 with JO’C to shoulder too much of the burden. Starting XV looks OK but it drops away quickly after that. 9th: On trials showing they’re up for it, but are one injury away from oblivion. 7th – Can cause plenty of headaches – rock solid front row, Wallaby backrow – the baby faced assassin at 10/11/12/13/14/15 and possibly on the side of the scrum at some stage

Discussion »

  • GC

    Reds 1st (or, if somehow cursed, 12th)
    Force 9th
    Tahs 14th (or maybe 3rd)
    Brumbies 4th

  • Jay

    Really dont know why people are so caught up with “Real Brumby”. Doesn’t seem to do the wobblies much good.

    Reds- 6th or 7th (injuries permitting)
    Force 10th
    Tahs – Brides mais yet again
    Brumbies – 9th

  • Ballboy

    Brumbies – 2nd
    Tahs – 4th
    Reds – 8th
    Force – 11th

  • Robson

    Brumbies and Tahs in the semis, but won’t progress. Force 9th or 10 and Reds 10th or 9th.

    And I have real doubts about the semis hopes of the Tahs and Geegees. My opinion is that any Saffa or Kiwi side that goes back to good old fashioned knitting in the forwards is going to seriously trouble all the Oz franchises except the Force.

    But of course will they do that – go back to their knitting that is.

    The Brumbies look the goods on paper, but they have got to put cohesive form on the paddock and, in my mind, there is still a question mark over whether Andy Friend can get them to do that.

    However, I won’t mind being wrong about all of this. Four Oz sides in the semi finals would make for a tsunami of vommiting in NZ and South Africa.

    • beeza

      a tsunami of vomiting – that sounds fantastic!

  • Groucho

    There’s a lot of talk about the Brumbies players, but in my opinion the Waratahs have the strongest team on paper. They certainly have the strongest scrum, who are also decent in the loose. And their first-choice backline is very classy indeed. They also have a good bench with players like Fitzpatrick and Holmes. I think if they get their gameplan right then they can win the competition.

  • reds fan

    Ponies 3rd
    Tahs 5th
    Force 9th
    Reds… um… err… 1st

  • Seb V

    Brumbies 1st
    Reds 2nd
    Force 3rd
    Tahs 14th

    :) :) :)

  • Tangawizi

    If the Reds are to finally crack it – and by crack it I mean finish better than 3rd last – what teams do people think they will actually beat this year?

    • Noddy

      the Tahs for one.

      • Hawko

        Possible. They’ve got home advantage and Craig Joubert to ref the Tah’s scrum off the park. But still, the Tah’s pack will have to play badly if the Reds are to win.

        • Noddy

          the Tah’s pack will have to play badly if the Reds are to win.

          have you seen the team? It’s undoubtable.

  • Hawko

    Realistically the Crusaders will nail down one spot, and probably first. Although Richie is on holidays they only have one tough game while he’s away (and I don’t mean the Reds). After that its business as usual.
    Waratahs have a very hard first four rounds and conceivably could be 0 for 4. Their easiest game is the Reds away and that’s always tough. After those four it gets a bit easier but given when we meet the other good teams – Brumbies, Crusaders, Force, Chiefs and Hurricanes its NOT an easy draw. I am picking them to just scrape in to the top 4 with a win in the last round.
    Brumbies should end up second or third, but if they don’t fix the scrum and lineout quickly then they are in BIG trouble.
    I think the Force will surprise and make sixth or thereabouts. They have been massively under-respected, they now have good props and lineout and a fearsome backrow. JOC at inside and CS at fullback will be a real threat. Just a bit short of depth in a couple of positions.
    The Reds are bottom four material, their forwards are not up to it.
    That leaves one top four spot for the Sharks, Stormers, Hurricanes and Chiefs to contest (two spots if the Brumbies don’t muscle up in the tight five). I like the Stormers.
    I think the Tahs can win it from 4th because you don’t have to get bonus points in finals, providing they don’t have to fly to SA for the semi’s and back again for the final. So I’m full of hope but it ain’t gunna be easy!

  • Rocky Elboa

    Brumbies 2nd (F-ing Crusader to win in final)
    Tahs 4th (F-ing Brumbies will beat them at home in the semi)
    Reds 9th (Better but not good enough)
    Force 11th (only because Highlander, Cheetahs and Lions will be worse)

    • Hawko

      Hate to be pedantic but if Brumbies are 2nd they will play whoever is 3rd. If Tah’s are 4th they will play Crusaders away.

      • Noddy

        its not being pedantic. Its being wrong.

        Brumbies finish 1st, Waratahs 4th. Brumbies beat Tahs in semi.

        Brumbies then lose to Crusaders in Canberra in the final, thus coming runners up, ipso facto, 2nd.

        The defense rests.

  • Gallagher

    Tahs – 2/3rd
    Brumbies – 4/5th
    Reds – 8/9th
    Force – 9/10th

Close