^ the current lot are a vast improvement over those from the Chris Cairns/ Lou Vincent/ Adam Parore era but my favorite remains the Crowe-lead team of CWC 1992, not least because me & my mate got shit-faced with half of them the night before they played Zimbabwe in Napier (TBF pretty much no-one expected there to be a match given the weather was so shit).
EDIT: this is the ICC T'sOTY judging panel:
AJIT AGARKAR
Former India bowler; commentator
RUSSEL ARNOLD
Former Sri Lanka allrounder; commentator
SAMBIT BAL
Editor-in-chief, ESPNcricinfo
DANIEL BRETTIG
Assistant editor, ESPNcricinfo
MARK BUTCHER
Former England batsman,commentator
IAN CHAPPELL
Former Australia captain, commentator
DARYLL CULLINAN
Former South Africa batsman; commentator
ANDREW FERNANDO
Sri Lanka correspondent, ESPNcricinfo
MOHAMMAD ISAM
Bangladesh correspondent, ESPNcricinfo
ANDREW MILLER
UK editor, ESPNcricinfo
SIDHARTH MONGA
Assistant editor, ESPNcricinfo
FIRDOSE MOONDA
South Africa correspondent, ESPNcricinfo
SHAHRIAR NAFEES
Former Bangladesh batsman
MARK NICHOLAS
Former Hampshire captain; TV presenter and commentator
RAMIZ RAJA
Former Pakistan captain, commentator
OSMAN SAMIUDDIN
Senior editor, ESPNcricinfo
PHIL SIMMONS
Former Zimbabwe and Ireland coach; current Afghanistan coach
SIMON TAUFEL
Former International Elite Panel umpire
COURTNEY WALSH
Former West Indies captain, Bangladesh bowling coach
Bit harsh to label Simmons as just a coach, did he not briefly captain WI & was he not at that time regarded as a leading all-rounder?
Anyhoo, here's the Award nominations they came up with:
http://www.espncricinfo.com/awards2018/content/site/index.html