• Welcome to the Green and Gold Rugby forums. As you can see we've upgraded the forums to new software. Your old logon details should work, just click the 'Login' button in the top right.

RWC 2019 1/4 Final Wales vs France

Dctarget

John Eales (66)
That ending really leaves a bad taste in your mouth. Poor form by the TMO and Peyper there. Congratulations to Wales for winning, they know how to play to the rules. But what an awful way to go about it.
 

AngrySeahorse

Peter Sullivan (51)
French deserve to lose for the red, frankly. Beyond comprehension.

Bit harsh to say the whole team deserved the loss due to one players actions but the player who got sent off can be rest assured he rooted his team.

The french got screwed with the welsh forward pass. And i dont understand why they'd be trying to collapse a scrum when wales got the penalty.

Needless to say i cant see wales beating saffas or even japans speed game based on that performance.
 

notapatrioticboneinme

Sydney Middleton (9)
Begs the question... how did losing $200 on your first-ever bet lead to a lifelong habit of throwing roughly $17 over the balcony every single goddamn day for the last 46 years?

300 000 thousand conservatively > familial history, dad compulsive, both grandfathers were SP bookies at one stage, have no self-control except i have only played a pokie once, lost 20cents and realised it was pure luck and have never entered a casino
best thing, by far, is that none of my five offspring gamble (4 sons, 1 daughter), all the best DP and yep have taken match odds SA over japan
 

Brumby Runner

David Wilson (68)
Disgraceful no call. Thats clearly floated forward. I dont understand how they havent seen it.

My impression was that the TMO said to Jaco, " I have a decision". Jaco then immediately said "So its a try". I really had the impression that the TMO was going to say the ball went forward but wasn't prepared to over-rule Jaco.

In any case, I do believe the French could have won the game had they continued to keep the ball in the Welsh half, as they did for a long period towards the end. Then, at about 72 minutes I think, a stupid play at a ruck near half way gifted the Welsh a penalty and brought the game inside the French 22m area. That's when the decisive try was scored. All teams do it, but I get frustrated by players who don't use their noggins and consequently give away stupid penalties. We have a couple of them in the Wallabies RWC squad.
 

SteveWA

Charlie Fox (21)
My impression was that the TMO said to Jaco, " I have a decision". Jaco then immediately said "So its a try". I really had the impression that the TMO was going to say the ball went forward but wasn't prepared to over-rule Jaco.

I’m pretty sure I heard the TMO initially say to his offsider “clearly forward” but either Jaco or the commentators talked over him.
 

zer0

Jim Lenehan (48)
While I think it was clear that France were the better team, even when without a full compliment of players, I do take solace in the delicious irony that France are bundled out of a RWC quarterfinal off a forward pass.
 

KOB1987

Rod McCall (65)
While I think it was clear that France were the better team, even when without a full compliment of players, I do take solace in the delicious irony that France are bundled out of a RWC quarterfinal off a forward pass.
I could handle it if it was against you guys, or us, or Japan, or Namibia. But not wales.
 

cyclopath

George Smith (75)
Staff member
The moment Jaco realised he had shat his pants.
Jaco.gif
 

Tex

John Thornett (49)
Dumb French lock just writes the rugby stereotypes for the lazy journos. That's what a red card should look like, not a mistimed tackle.

Was it the strip immediately prior to the winning try that Jaco fucked properly?
 

Derpus

George Gregan (70)
Dumb French lock just writes the rugby stereotypes for the lazy journos. That's what a red card should look like, not a mistimed tackle.

Was it the strip immediately prior to the winning try that Jaco fucked properly?
Correct
 

Tex

John Thornett (49)
Look from the overhead angle it was so marginal I would have been disappointed if it was called on that. However! I believe there was a second view that showed it going forward, and if that was available and not used by Jaco/TMO, that's a real bed shitter of a moment.
 
Top