Super Rugby Rnd 3: Rebels vs Waratahs
- Thread starter Mr Wobbly
- Start date
Brumby Runner
David Wilson (68)
He was disappointing because I expected more from him. At the beginning of the season, I thought Harrison was the most likely of the young No 10s to succeed and expected him to show a good set of skills from the get go. As I said, he has a strong kicking game, but so far, and especially last night against the Rebels, he has shown little in the way of threatening the defense either by running himself (see Lucas for example) or by putting players into gaps (see Lolesio/Simone as a combination). I am starting to think he might not have the ability to organise and manage an attacking structure at Super level. Of course, he might be being hamstrung a bit by having Beale doing his selfish, ineffective thing outside.
No, I won't write him off just yet, but I really do think something has to be done about raising the standard of the Tahs' backline.
Blackadder
Desmond Connor (43)
He really isn't having the best season, poor passes, dropping the ball, slow to the breakdown and this was meant to be his season to shine.
Blackadder
Desmond Connor (43)
I tried to fast forward to the best bits for the Tahs but I went to far and it was already 2021
shanky
Darby Loudon (17)
As has been pointed out here, some baffling behaviour by the Tahs
Not least (for me) the decision not to compete on the Rebels lineout.
After they had completed their third metre-eating rolling maul, we didn't think we should try and disrupt them or do something different?
Cottrell was made to look like Victor Matfield for a while there, while Dempsey was asked to stay on the ground and then was completely ineffectual at sacking the maul.
I was wondering if the Rebels we're possibly even confident enough to take the piss with the lineout calls, "Highway 1, Highway 1!"
Who makes a decision like that and then perseveres with it in the face of glaring counter-evidence? After the game, Simmons looked baffled as to what has caused their loss. 'Well, err, start with looking at your area of expertise Rob - the lineout!'
Not least (for me) the decision not to compete on the Rebels lineout.
After they had completed their third metre-eating rolling maul, we didn't think we should try and disrupt them or do something different?
Cottrell was made to look like Victor Matfield for a while there, while Dempsey was asked to stay on the ground and then was completely ineffectual at sacking the maul.
I was wondering if the Rebels we're possibly even confident enough to take the piss with the lineout calls, "Highway 1, Highway 1!"
Who makes a decision like that and then perseveres with it in the face of glaring counter-evidence? After the game, Simmons looked baffled as to what has caused their loss. 'Well, err, start with looking at your area of expertise Rob - the lineout!'
one bow to his apron is an incorrect statement. Perhaps that's all you saw in this match, but if you've seen anything more of his game you'd realise that is complete hyperbole. As for well and truly bested by MT, well that should be what we'd expect shouldn't we? An experienced test player and likely Wallaby 10 gets the better of a 3 game rookie barely teenager?
Silverado
Dick Tooth (41)
Agree. After 3 defeats I think we need to concentrate on a rebuilding year and put faith in our youngsters. It's a huge step up from 20s and there have been flaws. Harrison needs to work on his decision making, Nawaqanitawase on his defense and Bell on his scrummaging but they all have strengths that give me hope
All these things can be improved with experience at Super Rugby level and all of them have a bright future and should be supported. Besides, what's the option, Beale at 10?
Silverado
Dick Tooth (41)
It looked pretty wet at times. I thought the Tahs played dumb in the first half playing expansive and forcing passes when conditions weren't conducive
TSR
Mark Ella (57)
It bucketed down.
It wasn’t Cairns in a monsoon type rain, but it was clearly pretty heavy at times.
Highlander35
Andrew Slack (58)
The rain was light but consistent. Handling still way below professional standard.
eastman
Arch Winning (36)
Our worst player was the one who posed the biggest threat with his running game?
Dismal Pillock
Simon Poidevin (60)
Of course Gregan disagrees it was obstruction, he was right there at ground zero when the Bumbreeze wheeled out their
wamberal
Phil Kearns (64)
I must have fast forwarded through those "highlights". But being the biggest attacking threat in a side with no attack is not exactly a great compliment. He looked ponderous and slow to me.
Brumby Runner
David Wilson (68)
I have been a fan of Harrison since last year's U20s. I had high expectations for him this year, thinking he would be the best of the young No 10s because of his U20s and NRC form. I would expect he has more skills than just kicking the ball, but very few have been on show so far this year. As for a "3 game barely teenager" matching it with MT, did you watch Noah Lolesio last week Reg.
molman
Peter Johnson (47)
I thought the call was right. It's becoming a little bit on an issue the dummy runners "accidently" making contact with the defensive line. Normally they don't imped the tacklers but it still really shouldn't be allowed as even if they're not impacting that phase you disrupt the flow.
On the flipside, I have no idea where the back of the ruck is anymore. The offside is really a bit of a joke. I thought Well's was well offside a number of times and the line in general just seems to form up whereever.
Brumby Runner
David Wilson (68)
Couldn't agree more about the three players having bright futures and persevering with them. But the option that just might work in WH's favour is if Beale is out of the side altogether. I think his consistent waywardness is having a detrimental effect on the rest of the team.