stillmissit
Chilla Wilson (44)
We have had three coaches and still no alternate kickers to show for it, were they all stupid or are there no other players who can kick? It is a skill not some magic.
Wallabies 2024
- Thread starter rugbyAU
- Start date
stillmissit
Chilla Wilson (44)
Don't think so, too light and not tough enough for international but his time may come.
stillmissit
Chilla Wilson (44)
Maybe the only one!
stillmissit
Chilla Wilson (44)
You must have watched a different game against the Reds than I did.
Slim 293
Stirling Mortlock (74)
Apparently, we all did…
Australian Super Rugby Team of the Week 2024
Faessler started, Nasser came on at the 34 minute mark Then Faessler in the TOTW.
www.greenandgoldrugby.com
Super Rugby Pacific Team of the Week: Resurgent Crusaders lead the way
After the sixth round of Super Rugby Pacific action, Planet Rugby breaks down the star performers from a thrilling weekend of rugby.
www.planetrugby.com
Brumbies playmakers thrive, while things could still get worse for Waratahs
The Brumbies and Reds put on a quality display on Saturday, but it’s still a step below Test rugby and that complicates matters for the Wallabies’ coach.
Five things we learnt: Why Cheika could be the man to resurrect Tahs, Thor is the new Quade, value of sevens
The anguish on Darren Coleman’s face said it all. His time as Waratahs coach is coming to an end. Had the Waratahs got up…
www.theroar.com.au
Derpus
George Gregan (70)
Feels a bit aggressive
LevitatingSocks
Ward Prentice (10)
Donaldson isn't that egregious of a pick given the competition.
White would be great on a slow-paced team that runs off the 9, has a forward pack that dominates set pieces, and tall backs that are comfortable in the air. The Wallabies in their current form are not that team. Tate Mcdermott or someone else that reliably delivers a quick ball is a better fit.
Mr Pilfer
Bob Loudon (25)
Go and check the ladder again. Being shit has not stopped waratahs players getting picked for the wallabies the past few years
KOB1987
John Eales (66)
I'm certainly not advocating for too many Waratahs to be in the 23 this year, and I doubt there will be any uncapped players selected. However, their position on the ladder this season needs to be kept into perspective given the horror run of 11 front row injuries, as many have said no team is going to perform well under those circumstances. Assuming they are fit I wouldn't be surprised to see the majority of their capped Wallabies to be in the initial squad so that Schmidt can get a look at them in that environment:
Bell
Hanigan
Swinton
Holloway
Gordon
Foketi
Perese
Nawaqanatawase
Joey Walton probably the only one outside those who might get a call up due to the lack of depth in the current fit & eligible centres options. I think maybe 3 of those in total will end up in the 23.
Last edited:
Tomikin
Simon Poidevin (60)
Doesn't play for the Brumbies anymore
makes it much more palatable for Tah's and Reds fans to select him (joking all)
Tomikin
Simon Poidevin (60)
Bell's probably the only player in Oz, I'd select who's coming straight back from injury.
I think Hanigan / Swinton / Holloway might battle for one or 2 positions
Gordon, not sure he'll get there, probably battling Lonergan as 3rd SH
Foketi, probably as 12 is short.
Perese, to be honest, would be behind Lenny, Flook and Walton
Nawaqanatawase - I'm not sure what to do with him since he's leaving, but if his form stays good, he'll be in, I think.
The Ghost of Raelene
Andrew Slack (58)
Perese also leaving and I don't think he's good enough to be considered for future overseas picks. If Mark gets in form then I pick him in the squad to even maintain good relationships if he wants to come back. Don't burn the bloke like League want to for about 5mins when someone leaves.
Between Ikitau, Paisami, Foketi, Flook and even Kellaway we do have Centres for this season. Daugunu has looked good in spurts at 13 but I think he becomes a target for good sides in Defence.
Between Ikitau, Paisami, Foketi, Flook and even Kellaway we do have Centres for this season. Daugunu has looked good in spurts at 13 but I think he becomes a target for good sides in Defence.
Wilson
Michael Lynagh (62)
I think Daugunu is a solid chance to feature in the 23 jersey, seen as a wing first covering 13. Either way I think he's looking pretty good for a place in the squad. There have been a few wing injuries recently reducing the options and I'm not convinced by Nawaqanitawase's form enough to pick him when he's leaving the game. He still has room to turn that around, but not much. It'd be a different story if he was either killing it or just heading to Europe, but he's not playing well enough to bother with right now.
There's every chance another injury or two changes the picture significantly in the final rounds though.
Do you really think that someone who has had little or no professional goal kicking experience can become a test level goal kicker with a little bit of coaching and practice?
I am quite confident White's box kicking was within the game plan and a box kick will be within the new coaches game plan as well
Hopefully with a better focus on the chase and contestability
stillmissit
Chilla Wilson (44)
NO! but many should have been put on kicking training if they showed some history or potential. We are in a tough position with kickers and nothing appears to have been done to give us some options. Several thousand kicks at goal from all over the pitch and most with talent will improve.
Even Shute Shield has some decent kickers - NO not suggesting dragging one out of there. The talent must be within 23 players so that we can build alternate kickers.
Ignoto
Greg Davis (50)
Well, Leigh Halfpenney and Carter Gordon both shanked sitters on the weekend, so one could argue that Gordon is kicking as well as a test level goal kicker!
We have a goal kicking problem with Carter Gordon. All the other 10 options are fine.
For pretty much every other player their time can be better spent training something else that will have a greater impact on their play as a rugby player.
upthereds#!
Peter Johnson (47)
Schmidt very much expressed how he values player to player coaching, using Johnny Sexton as an example. Bringing in the young guys behind the experienced. C.Gordon expressed how much value he got from Quade in camp.
Schmidt IMO is likely to start with a broad squad and will lean towards bringing in experienced operators in key areas to ensure good player to player coaching, even if that experienced player is 'lower' in the form ranks. Beale clearly offers great value as a foil/support for Donaldson, and I'm sure this is just as visible, if not more so, off the field and on the training paddock, as it is on matchday.
Therefore I do see Beale being selected into camp, potentially even JOC (James O'Connor) in lieu of foreign based players, also guys strong in the set piece, like Holloway, Neville, Talakai, Hanigan etc. What IP can be squeezed out before they retire/depart and what value can they contribute towards the overall development of younger players doing well at Super Rugby, but may not have the nous to make the right decisions at International level.
Schmidt IMO is likely to start with a broad squad and will lean towards bringing in experienced operators in key areas to ensure good player to player coaching, even if that experienced player is 'lower' in the form ranks. Beale clearly offers great value as a foil/support for Donaldson, and I'm sure this is just as visible, if not more so, off the field and on the training paddock, as it is on matchday.
Therefore I do see Beale being selected into camp, potentially even JOC (James O'Connor) in lieu of foreign based players, also guys strong in the set piece, like Holloway, Neville, Talakai, Hanigan etc. What IP can be squeezed out before they retire/depart and what value can they contribute towards the overall development of younger players doing well at Super Rugby, but may not have the nous to make the right decisions at International level.