Haha, maybe I'm looking back at it with rose-tinted glasses (pun intended). Thoughts on Matt Smith/Karen Gillian?
Matt Smith is a very personal dislike for no rational reason. He has a number of excellent stories, mostly with those with Kingston, and he portrays, "The Doctor" more faithfully than Tennant, (in that, the Troughton through Davidson Doctors shine through 11 more than 10, who was very much his own Doctor, being a Hero, reckless for the sake of reckless, "selfish" in an uninteresting way, as compared to that of McCoy).
But I just don't like him. Happy to be absolutely blasted by people.
Clara is a weak companion who does disservice to both the show and Jenna Coleman's acting ability. In spite of this, Season 9 was easily the second best Season of NuWho, behind 4, which, bar cheesey last story was the highpoint of the current iteration. Every season has its garbage though.
Season 2 has the triple header of The Idiot's Lantern, Love and Monsters and Fear Her though. When you add very middling episodes like New Earth, Tooth and Claw and the Cyberman 2 parter, even the The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit and The Girl in the Fireplace can't save it, as amazing as hey are.
(addendum: WATCH Torchwood: Children of Earth. Top 5 individual work in the NuWho Universe)
Heaven Sent is what turned Capaldi from about 4 on the list to number 1. Up there with Genesis of the Daleks IMO.