1. Welcome to the Green and Gold Rugby forums. As you can see we've upgraded the forums to new software. Your old logon details should work, just click the 'Login' button in the top right.

NSW Schools Debating 2018

Discussion in 'Everything Else' started by Shortrep, Feb 2, 2018.

  1. Shortrep Peter Burge (5)

    Likes Received:
    Assuming the results posted above are correct. Of the 7 GPS teams in ISDA, 1 was an Octo Finalist, 3 were Quarter Finalists and 3 are now Semi Finalists. This is panning out as a good year for the GPS. Doesn't give us much of a clue as to who will win though. Perhaps, finally, a breakup of the High, Grammar Duopoly with some other strong teams in the GPS?
  2. MDB1800 Bob McCowan (2)

    Likes Received:

    It certainly was an interesting result, Grammar had the easier side, and Barker wasn't strong in the rounds, but the adj. was the chief adj. for the comp.

    The results are all legit. It certainly is looking like a strong GPS year. Grammar seemingly isn't in great form (loss to Barker + Scots), but I can't speak for High.

    In terms of potential winners (excluding High) Scots or View perhaps? Maybe Joeys or Kings?
    bigmac likes this.
  3. MDB1800 Bob McCowan (2)

    Likes Received:
    In ISDA news:

    Riverview beat Joeys in a 2-1 Split on the aff of the topic that “Progressive Individuals and Organisations should not support or provide advice to Trump” (paraphrased).

    Barker beat Kings (no news re split or topic).

    Should be an interesting final, certainly one that no one predicted. Riverview has already beaten Barker if anyone is looking for an indication of potential victors.
  4. BringHomeTheBacon Bob McCowan (2)

    Likes Received:
    A hearty congratulations to Riverview and Barker!

    Does anyone know the deal for the Australian team schedule this year, ie how many weeks will Grammar be without Yim? That may be quite significant for their GPS season if the other schools replicate their ISDA performance. Luckily it tends to be earlier in the season, as their last two debates are against Riverview and Sydney Boys.
  5. MDB1800 Bob McCowan (2)

    Likes Received:
    Apparently only the first week, against Joeys.
  6. MDB1800 Bob McCowan (2)

    Likes Received:
    Riverview beat Barker unanimously on the topic that “We should ban all occupational licenses” (Doctor, Lawyer, Plumber, Electrician, consists of exams and or training), taking home the senior A ISDA premiership.

    Knox beat Kambala in Year 9.

    Barker won in Year 10, beating MLC.

    Senior B, MLC beat shore.
  7. rowerforlife Peter Burge (5)

    Likes Received:
    Greetings all,
    The GPS Debating season is upon already, with the first round debates this Friday. The topic area is sport, so expect some interesting topics.

    Interestingly, some rules have been changed with the following being the most significant:
    Change to Adjudication 2018
    • Panel adjudications for Firsts and Seconds have been discontinued.
    • To balance the number of adjudicators employed for the junior and senior timeslot, the competition will only provide non-aligned adjudicators for the following debates: 7A, 8A, 8B, 9A, 9B, 10A, 10B, thirds, seconds and firsts. "
    This could mean some very controversial adjudications in 1sts and 2nds.
    The draw this Friday is (with a prediction):
    Scots vs Newington - Scots to win
    Joeys vs Grammar - Grammar to win
    Kings vs High - High to win
    Riverview vs Shore - Riverview to win
    Any other predictions for these debates or for the competition?
    BringHomeTheBacon likes this.
  8. BringHomeTheBacon Bob McCowan (2)

    Likes Received:
    These predictions look spot on, but I too am interested in how the competition runs without panels. Especially given the GPS systems lack of finals, and how close the teams look to be, a single rogue loss could derail a team.

    But adjudicator situation aside, I wonder how the GPS would cope with a finals system like ISDA. Would certainly make for more spectacle in the final debates as opposed to just being more normal matches, and would give teams a chance for redemption after a loss. It’s not like adding two weeks to a seven week competition would hurt anybody either.
  9. MedStudent Frank Row (1)

    Likes Received:
    High will win this year, Daniel Yim or not. Their team is ridiculously all rounded and work together extremely well.
    Seldrax likes this.
  10. Seldrax Bob McCowan (2)

    Likes Received:
    High indeed looks strong this year.

    The CHS Squad is out:

    Alex De Araujo (SBHS 12)
    John Bivell (Fort Street 12)
    Laura Charlton (Smith's Hill 11)
    Ashna Hedge (SGHS 12)
    Sophia Mendes (NSG 12)
    Sophie Shead (HGHS 12)
    Guy Suttner (SBHS 12
    Anna Sophia Zahar (SGHS 11)

    Seems pretty standard from the same old schools, I do wonder how Indigo Crossweller didn't trial in.
    MedStudent likes this.
  11. MiscDebater Frank Row (1)

    Likes Received:
    Hume Barbour State Final is next Friday between Sydney Boys and Smith's Hill. Semi-finalists were SBHS, SHHS, Hornsby Girls and Sefton HS.
  12. MDB1800 Bob McCowan (2)

    Likes Received:
    Any results from GPS?
  13. rowerforlife Peter Burge (5)

    Likes Received:

    This page will normally have results for all teams updated by around Wednesday each week.

    Last week High, Grammar, Scots and Riverview all won, although I'm not aware of the topics or how well those teams actually did. Any further information would be much appreciated.

    This week in Round 2 on Education (predicted winner in bold):
    Riverview vs Newington
    Grammar vs Scots
    Joeys vs High
    Shore vs Kings

  14. BringHomeTheBacon Bob McCowan (2)

    Likes Received:
    High have taken out the Hume Barbour trophy. Topic was “That we should stop commemorating wars” - Smiths Hill affirmative, Sydney Boys negative. Congratulations to both teams on what I’m sure was an excellent debate!
  15. rowerforlife Peter Burge (5)

    Likes Received:
    This thread has been largely inactive all this time, but there are still plenty of exciting debates in the upcoming weeks.
    Reps (GPS, CHS, ART, CAS) start this Wednesday. I'm not too sure about the draws, location, times or team members, so any information would be greatly appreciated!

    This Friday is also the final round of GPS. Once again, the High vs Grammar clash remains the decider for Firsts/Seconds/Thirds this year. High goes into the Firsts and Thirds undefeated and have already secured at least a co-premiership. The winner of the Seconds debate wins the competition outright. Clearly three very exciting debates with high calibre debaters from Grammar and High.

    Predictions: High - Firsts, Thirds; Grammar - Seconds

    I look forward to the results of this Friday!
  16. ThatWasTheJoke Peter Burge (5)

    Likes Received:
    High defeat Grammar on the somewhat dubious topic that doctors should have there pay determined by patient surveys.

Share This Page