• Welcome to the Green and Gold Rugby forums. As you can see we've upgraded the forums to new software. Your old logon details should work, just click the 'Login' button in the top right.

Rugby - not set pieces

Status
Not open for further replies.

Rob42

John Solomon (38)
League's latest round of changes have cut down their set pieces and will speed up their game and continuity. The NRC will need some radical rule changes to make any impression.


Perhaps rugby should just stick with the line "It's Not Rugby League". Perhaps we should just embrace the fact that rugby has more facets, more interest than 5-tackle-kick. League will always have the advantage on simplicity - that's why it was invented.
 
T

tranquility

Guest
This is my non set-piece for the day. From a carlton draught I had the other day
C3swg96.jpg

Jesus, Mary & David.
 

Lee Grant

John Eales (66)
Staff member
From a few weeks ago:

Toulon v Grenoble Round 16

This was a cracking game which was supposed to be a walkover but wasn't.

Toulon is now a rugby powerhouse under its eccentric owner Mourad Boudjellal, and was in the Top 14 final last year.

In this home game they started ex-Super players Bakkies Botha, Juan Smith, David Smith and Drew Mitchell. On the bench arguably the best player in the Top 14 at the minute, Matt Giteau, was given a rest against a team that finished in eleventh place last year, as were other Super men Carl Hayman, Rudi Wulf and Michael Claassens.

Grenoble is the hardy mountain team that plays above it's weight and would have to be one of the best-coached sides in the competition.

It had ex-Super players also, but not quite in the same class collectively: Ben Hand and Peter Kimlin starting, and Dayna Edwards and Henry Vanderglass on the bench.

There was another Ausse ex-Super player involved also: Richard Kingi, who was in the commentary box with Robbie Nock—or more exactly: in the Eurosport studio in Paris.

Grenoble played out of their skins and pushed the envelope on defence. They were three points ahead at oranges, but Toulon played better in the second half and with 17 minutes to go the home team was ahead 21-15. Not a try had been scored.

Then with a couple of minutes left Toulon are on attack and wanting to get another score to deny the pesky mountain men a bonus point loss. A Toulon advantage has just expired when Johnny Wilkinson throws a long pass right on the money to …… Grenoble winger Ratu Ratini who intercepts it and scores under the posts,

The conversion gives the win to Grenoble 22-21.

Toulon owner Boudjellal, who was banned two years ago for four months, when he said that referees were sodomising his team, gave his side a bit of a shaft himself.

He said they were "Kings of the idiots".

Nice cheque book, but not a nice guy.
.
 

#1 Tah

Chilla Wilson (44)
Or, depending on your point of view, Simon Cowell's cash cow trying to form an opinion that wasn't dictated to him by his record company.
 

Hugh Jarse

Rocky Elsom (76)
Staff member
^^ Good advice. It's full strength p!ss in the Members section as well, not the watered down stuff on sale for the masses in the Plebes section.
 

Lee Grant

John Eales (66)
Staff member
Sharks v. Hurricanes

After Beauden Barrett kicked a penalty goal for the Canes to make the score 10-3 to the Sharks, he parks himself near touch to receive the restart kick if it heads his way.

Sure enough, he finds the ball coming towards him and he tries to catch it with his foot in touch.

The ball does not pass the plane of touch and……he drops the ball infield, not forward. Then, with his foot still in touch, he picks the ball up.

What should have happened next?

The ball was not in touch when he dropped the ball, not forward, because it is "play-on" (the ball did not pass the plane). If you are standing outside the field of play you can tap the ball backwards, or kick the ball, providing you don't hold it and the ball has not passed the plane. You can even ground the ball without holding it to score a try. Play on.

Since it was "play-on" Barrrett, with his foot still in touch, effectively put the ball into touch when he picked up the ball dropped backwards infield.

Lineout to the Sharks? Should have been, but Andrew Lees awarded a scrum back on the halfway line to the Canes because he thought that the Sharks kicked the restart directly into touch. He probably did so on the advice of the AR Marius Jonker.

But wait a minute—did not Mvovo of the Sharks knock the ball on chasing the restart kick, before Barrett dropped the ball?

He may have, but in that case it should have been a scrum to the Canes where the knock-on occurred.
.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top