Dwyer’s View: The Grand Slam for England – Not a Chance

Bob Dwyer March 21, 2011 21

No GravatarMy dreams of late (or were they nightmares?) have been filled with visions of an England Grand Slam leading into a World Cup. “Not again”, I thought. I need not have worried. I should have asked my old friends Allan Gaffney and Les Kiss. They could have set my mind at rest. As members of Ireland’s coaching team, I’m sure they had it completely under control all of the time.

That’s certainly the way it looked at Lansdowne Road yesterday, as Ireland made a mockery of England’s favourites’ tag to convincingly win the match 24–8. Indeed, the Ireland team were so dominant that by the half-time break, it looked as though England would need a miracle to pull back from the hosts’ 17–3 lead.

Perhaps the most important ingredient of success is enthusiasm: it makes most things possible. Ireland had it in bucketloads! It gave them their positive attitude, which was clearly evident from the kick-off. In the first minute, Ireland drove the England scrum backwards and got the penalty. Sexton took the tap and put the visitors immediately on the defensive.

England, on the other hand, were strangely negative, and when Sexton found space in behind the England line — this was to be the first of many such explorations — they were off-side from the lineout. When Nick Easter enquired of the referee which of his backs was adjudged off-side, he was informed by Bryce Lawrence “All of them!” Following Sexton’s successful penalty conversion, they were well off-side at the restart. There was no focus on a quality performance here.

This negativity pervaded England’s total performance, until pride finally drew a rear-guard last ten minutes from them. By then, of course, the game had been lost and the pressure of a beckoning Grand Slam had been lifted from their shoulders. Even the youthful Ben Youngs, usually a bundle of positive action, was guilty of negativity. The first was when he cynically knocked the ball from the hands of his opposite number, when Reddin was shaping to feed the scrum! What’s that all about? In the 35th minute, he was at it again and was yellow carded for preventing a possible Ireland quick throw by tossing the ball away — into the grandstand. Youngs is a much better player than such actions would suggest, but pressure can have strange effects.

There were high tackles, off-sides in front of the kick, not releasing the ball-carrier, lying over the tackle… you name the offence and England were guilty of it, and these infringements kept them on the back foot. Especially so when Johnny Sexton, exuding enthusiasm, was ready to snatch the slightest opportunity. He took the quick tap again when England were off-side and took play well in behind their defensive line. From the quick recycle, it was Tommy Bowe who found space with England short of numbers and neatly stepped inside Ben Foden to confirm Ireland’s superiority. The toll could have been much more as Ireland crossed twice more before the break, only to be recalled (correctly) for forward passes.

I’ve said it before — a couple of hundred times or more, and I’m getting sick of having to say it — that for a quality rugby performance you need two things. First, you need to apply committed pressure with numbers at the tackle contest, both in attack and defence; and second,  you need to realign, with urgency, both the attacking line and the defensive line. (In fact, realignment of the attacking line has all but disappeared from the game, except when New Zealand teams are playing.) Ireland recognised the importance of these simple principles and gave both the England attack and defence a torrid time. Add some reasonable set plays and you can put together a pretty good game of rugby. Ireland certainly managed it.

The words that came to my mind in an assessment of the Ireland performance were “fierce” and “relentless”, and all of the Ireland players played their part. This was surely the best team that Ireland have fielded in this year’s Internationals. Earls gave loads more than Fitzgerald ever offered at full back; the injuries to Kearney and Murphy proved significant for this international season. Trimble was all pace and power and complemented the outstanding Tommy Bowe to give threats on both sides of the pitch.

Sexton offers much more than O’Gara, for all of O’Gara’s control, and he was adjudged the Man of the Match. There were a couple of others who could easily have won that accolade — the ageless Brian O’Driscoll for one. His attack is there for all to see, but his defence is outstanding. His speed helps, and fearlessness does the rest. I would have nearly given him the award, and David Wallace was outstanding also.

England were totally outplayed. Their one try, an intercept by Steve Thompson of the scrum-half’s clearing pass from the lineout, must have had the officials pondering a possible off-side, and this was the only time they looked seriously dangerous for the entire match.

I had thought that they have made great strides in the last nine months, but last autumn, South Africa successfully bludgeoned them into submission; despite a second-half recovery they were headed all the way by New Zealand; and now Ireland have completely outplayed them. England simply may not have enough ways to win matches.

After the ridiculous injustice of the previous weekend in Cardiff, Ireland finished the championship in real style. They proved that they will threaten any side come September and they all wore the satisfied smiles of men who know they have given of their best. I even saw Ronan O’Gara smile!

Discussion »

  • Joe

    Hi Bob,

    I rank both yourself and Brian Moore (I know he’s a pom, but he’s the exception etc) as without doubt the two most honest critics about.
    Always a pleasure – I had a dream (two actually)
    1. you would coach Leinster one day.
    2. you would coach Ireland one day.

    Happy St’ Patricks day to you.

  • http://yellowmagpie.com Joseph Condron

    Succinctly summed up.

    England were shown up to be a very average team and Ireland finally started to realise their potential although that was mainly due to selecting form players.

    Hopefully, Ireland will push on in the World Cup and we will banish the memories of a very poor Six Nations.

  • Bullrush

    What?!?! Not a word on the standard of the reffing???

  • http://yellowmagpie.com Joseph Condron

    Too true, the referee had a fine game – distinguished by his ability to differentiate mauls from rucks – something others had failed previously to do.

  • rugby smartarse

    so how much to come back to the tahs, and do you think you could coach the above into the current players? can draw very direct parralells to their game v the cheetahs this weekend, and they could probably do with a dose of re-education

  • rolandw

    Im more worried about Ireland. Losing to France in the dying seconds of the game, and only losing to Wales becuase Kaplan (The worst ref in ther world) completely robbed them, that wold have been an undefeated 6 nations and a gland slam.

    I hope we dont play Ireland if they play like this. We will get punished.
    Great to see the English props bet throttled back over their second rowers.
    Ahh..reminds me of 2009

    • Jay

      They can’t pin the blame on Kaplan, solely. They had half an hour to take the lead back against a pretty ordinary Welsh team.

      If the AB’s aren’t allowed to blame Wayne Barnes’ missed forward pass, Ireland aren’t allowed to blame Kaplan’s call either.

      • rolandw

        I was meerly referring to one of about 30 wrong calls in that game.
        If it wasn’t Kaplans fault, why has he been suspended for three weeks. They wouldnt suspend him for one indiscretion. It was the entire game.

        Best you not comment untill you have actually watched the game

        • Jay

          I have watched the match, Kaplan was awful though he was generally awful for both sides – did all 30 of those wrong calls go against Ireland?

          He’s not the reason the Irish lost, they played terribly. Just as they did against Italy.

          Also, refs/asst refs do get stood down for major errors – http://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/rugby/news/3991006/South-African-assistant-referee-stood-down – an assistant ref stood down for one call, essentially.

  • rolandw

    Tommy Bowe is the best winger in world rugby at the moment by a country mile. No mention of Heaslip? He’s about the best number 8 rolling around now too.

    My hat goes off to the Irish front row. Big boys with plenty of mongrel in them.

    We have to play these guys in the pool stages. If we dont win our pool, were up against England in the quarters and NZ/SA in the semi’s. If we win our pool, no NZ or S.A till the GF.

    The match against Ireland in the pool stages will determine how far we go in this WC.

  • Bob Dwyer

    I’m sick of talking about refereeing (lack of) standards, although I did get in a subtle dig at Jonathan’s fiasco in Ireland v Wales. There is a conspiracy between IRB and various nations to ensure support for those nations’ refs – come RWC & key international appointments. Does anyone else think that Paddy’s closeness to the New Zealand coaching staff is a worry?
    Re similarity of my comment to the Tahs horror show in Sydney, the comments apply to ALL games. I refuse to use the word ‘structure’ any more, because what we get is a predetermined, total over-read of every attacking situation, destroying totally any opportunity which may present itself. Rugby is NOT a choreographed activity. There are certain basic, fundamental principles which, when followed accurately and with urgency, make ALL things possible.
    How difficult can this be – to follow basic principles?

    • Gnostic

      Firstly a good write up Bob. Now all Ireland need to do is get some consistancy. Yes they were robbed against Wales but with the application we saw against the Poms the Welsh would never have been in the game for Kaplan et al to have the significant bearing they did.

      Secondly I like your comment regarding enthusiasm, commitment at the tackle and realignment of the attack (and defence I might add). Contrast this with the Tahs (and other Oz sides) who are have a flat single line of attack with individual players looping or cutting back on angled runs. How many times do we see it fail. Then against a team which slows the ball or heaven forbid competes at the ruck the ball is at best slow and we go through the whole mind numbing performance again. The Irish game was a highlight of the Rugby over the weekend for me, the Tahs were that lazy, and unethusiastic you have to wonder about their commitment to the game, they should be lucky Lievremont is their coach because he wouldn’t have even bothered to call them cowards, they would have been shot for desertion as they didn’t even turn-up to the battlefield.
      Lastly regarding your point about Refereeing “conspiracy”. To some your comment may be sensationalist, but a calm assessment of the facts should show that it is indeed the case with an inordinate amount of influence from some National Unions getting their sub-standard referees international appointments. On the matter of O’Brien the key points for me is the easily observable fact that he has not instituted systems to mentor and develop the Refs to a sufficient degree so that the Laws are interpreted and enforced with any degree of consistancy or even accuracy. In this, his key function, he has totally failed International Rugby including the players and the fans. Add to that the fact that he compromises his integrity through his own actions his position is untenable and he should be removed. Obrien should have been aware of the implications of his visit to the ABs post Italy test on his standing as it is the sort of situation he would have confronted in his previous profession. The FACT of the situation is that his integrity is now tainted because of HIS actions alone and it allows anybody to rightly question his relationship with not only the ABs but anybody who appears to receive favourable comment/action.

  • Alan

    Excellent write up Bob

    Certainly the best Irish performance for years. They reminded me {dare i say it} of the AB’s with their intensity at the breakdown and then of the Wallabies with the speed at which the backs spread/offloaded the ball. As a reared munster man and pom hater i went to bed smiling ear to ear early sunday morning.

    Highlight had to have been the seeing Chris Ashton taken down a peg. He, like the English team, are overrated.

    Ireland have a superstar in Sean O’Brien. He is a colossus and we will have to watch him closely at the WC and again on the lions tour

  • MattyP

    Fair play Ireland, but I for one am not overly impressed. Every time I read through the Ireland team sheet in recent years, judging the quality of players going onto the paddock, I expect this type of performance. But it just doesn’t happen on a consistent basis. They are the new France – all the talent, and the occasional good performance. Where was this team against Wales? Playing this way, the would have won by 20 points and taken the refs out of the game. When Ireland can find the extra gears each time they need it – no just a one off at home against England – then they will have a team that will be truly dangerous.

    • Scotty in Devon

      Well I suppose Matty they often find those extra gears against the current RWC champs – at least at home right enough. Ireland are the one NH team that has thier number from time to time.

      For me it was the most complete performance of the 6N by far, however its a points compettion and England got the most wins so fair play to them.

      Bob, I really liked your comment about rugby not being a game of pre-worked moves from the training pitch. In fact in about 1982 or so I turned on the TV one afternoon to Auntie ABC and saw Randwick play a spellbinding free-form style of game that had me transfixed. That one game made me a fan of Randwick, the Ellas, and rugby and I wish there was more of that kind of stuff these days. I just hope RL style defences have not killed it all off.

      all the best,

      Scotty

  • Nevan

    Good article Bob…..as a proud Irishman I’m interested to see what you Aussies are thinking bout us before we meet in the RWC.
    Some of the comments are quite correct….we have been inconsistent these past 12 months and did’nt deserve to win the 6 Nations, let alone the Grand Slam. But this Irish team is building nicely. The 09 Slam team has been positively added to by the arrival of Sexton, Ross, Reddan, Earls and more importantly O’Brien. With Kearney, Murphy, Flannery and Ferris to come back into the mix after injury. The Italian game was always a banana skin….first outing of the season and away from home with history favouring the Italians all fired up first day out (Aus take note: they are capable of making life difficult in the RWC Pool). We should have beaten France pretty comfortably….the right signs were there. Misfired against Scotland and Wales but again the right signs were there. If we clicked someone was going to get hammered….and thankfully it all came together against the Poms. We need to use this positive energy and push on from here….if we get consistent performances in the warm up games in Sept. then who knows….but if I was an Aussie I would be afraid….be very afraid……this is a seriously good team….especially if they can mentally picture every opponent wearing white !

  • daz

    In an article concerning England Ireland and The Grand Slam you couldn’t resist your customary dig at the Kiwis in your comment. Leave it out just for once Bob please, it’s becoming really boring.

    • Jay

      I’m not seeing a dig in the article – the only time they were mentioned is saying that they beat England handily and a statement that they are good at realigning their offense.

    • Gnostic

      How do you get him having a dig? Have you missed you paranoia meds again?

      All I can see is the massive compliment that it is only NZ team that realign the attack, something Bob has been death riding all Oz teams about for years, unfortunately without any result.

  • Ben

    Does anyone know where I can find the image featured on the link to this thread on the main page of the england and ireland lineout centred in front of the stadium? It doesn’t come up on this page…

  • http://dvdvhstransfer.com/archives/category/category/uncategorized/ Marcos Boling

    You would probably be surprised to know how much I was looking forward to reading this blog. Your beliefs are what I needed to be inspired today! You’ll never know how much I appreciate you right now! Best Regards.

Close