From the Republic: The Desperate Duo

JW September 4, 2012 19

No GravatarTwo teams looking to right wrongs, polish the nameplate and repair their dented reputations. The Wallabies were held to a duck by the Blackness (for the first time in over 40 years) and the Bok forward pack lay on their collective backs, wagged their tails and invited the Pumas to sniff their bums in an inept display harkening back to the dark era of Dolf Straeuli.

This should set the scene for this weekend’s clash to be a humdinger, with the Boks trying to steamroll the Wallaby pack and the Wallaby backs looking to bamboozle the Bok defence by passing the ball further out than the first channel from the ruck.

Both teams are missing key players in the likes of Bismarck du Plessis, JP Pietersen, James O’Connor and Wycliff Palu. As much as decent replacements have been called up they are not in the same class as these outstanding players. They also have fly-halves who have been seriously misfiring recently.

Both coaches are tweaking their selections and strategy, which should be read as some serious head-scratching, vigorous shouting and pointing at Xs and 0s on sheets of paper. Whether this can translate into form on the field is the million buck question. Will the Boks be able to turn in a dominant forwards display with an accurate kicking game and will the Wallaby backs catch the ball and not run into each other?

In this article we look at the Wallabies team and what we make of their chances.

Deans would love to start Tatafro for this Test as he brings a big-tackling, hard-running game, which you need in order to nullify the simple Bok strategy of running through you. He’ll have to make do with Squeaky Moore, a better technical hooker and great player around the fringes. Should Moore falter, Saia Fainga’a will be munched as he is not an international-class hooker.

Who, me?

On the side we should see Alexander and Robinson with Slipper on the bench. I would expect to see Jannie du P. targeted come scrum time with hooker and prop boring in on him to pop him out and milk the penalty.

The second row of Sharpie and Timani will be hard-pressed to compete legally at lineout time but will make up for it by putting in sterling hard-working performances in the tight and decent support in the scrum. There is a serious question of whether Sharpie still has the puff, but whom else could Deans throw to the Terminator?

The loose trio is a huge headache for Deans without Pocock there. I definitely expect to see Hooper start with perhaps Gill and then Higginbotham, but that gives an average age about 21 from three players who also give up five inches in the lineout. I expect to Samo start, but he’s lucky to get to 50 minutes without needing a quick cup of tea and a snooze.

Perhaps Deans gives hard-grafting Dennis another go? I think Dennis is a very good player; he is just part of an unbalanced loose trio.

Genia and Cooper are a given and I expect to see a lot of plays starting way behind the gain line. In fact I suspect that they will be working on them on the practice field. Plays called things like ‘run hard at the nearest prop/lock’. Cooper really misses having O’Connor outside him. JOC seems to break the first tackle and give the Wallabies backline more momentum than it has had recently.

Genia and Cooper will be looking to snipe around the fringes, but they will find less success than they used to with the replacement of the aging Bok forwards. Funnily enough I expect Cooper to have a blinder – he seems to relish the Bok encounters.

In the centres Barnes and AAC are a good call. Barnes brings steel to the midfield channels to stop Steyn running hard at Cooper and AAC is relishing his reclaimed position as outside centre.

The outside-backs complement of Beale, Shipperly and Ioane have blistering pace and if Kirchner starts I expect him to be shown up by these speed merchants. The key to the Wallabies gameplan will be to manufacture space for these guys. I expect to see these guys field poor Bok kicks and to run the ball hard back at the Bok forwards en masse. Slow down as you approach the forward pack and then pop the ball to the supporting player coming through at full pace. See the bewildered Bok forward grasp at thin air….

Score prediction? Wallabies by 5, unless Goosen and Lambie get more than 10 minutes each.

Discussion »

  • johnny-boy

    Saia Faianga’s value is underestimated. He may not be schwarzenegger buff or bolt athletic but he’s completely fearless and busts his gut for his country and state. He may also not be quite as accomplished as Moore or TPN and probably on a par with Hansen but his committment is infectious. A great guy to have in your team. It’s hard to fathom how the Boks could choose a coach who doesnt seem much smarter that PDV. I wouldn’t have thought that was possible. Perhaps he is just finding his feet.

    • Pedro

      He’s a great worker and I agree he is fearless, he’s just a bit small to do any damage in the tight. Plus that yellow card for spearing one of the boks when he’d only been on the field a minute shows that enthusiasm can cut both ways.

    • bludge

      always seemed over-rated and with the IQ of orange peel to boot.

  • Gus

    I hope this actually is the backline for Saturday.

  • Thierry dusautoir

    Has James o’connor actually ever played outside cooper at 12 at test level?

    I would also say TPN is more of a fringes player than Moore

    • Davo

      Maybe not but O’Connor is Cooper’s favourite ‘ill throw it in your general direction, good luck!’ guy. This often works because JOC is so fast and powerful he can get out of many sticky situations.

      The in goal flick pass and passes where JOC is still retreating back on side and Cooper still throws it at him come to mind.

  • PD

    Wycliff Palu. A player in the medical room more than on the field and yet everyone still rates him. When did he last play any extended time on the actual field?

    • Serious?

      Amen to that.

      What is the average Joe rugby public’s fascination with Palu? Really. Can anyone tell me why he is consistently rated so highly? I cannot recall a game against another top tier nation in which he has dominated his opposite and genuinely stood out. His work rate is abysmal and for a big man his defence is shit. I’d be happy if anyone can point me toward an international game in which he has been dominant. Anyone?

      • @sackdeansnow

        I totally agree – have been mystified for years y ppl rate him at all – he has same problem as rocky elsom – he can’t run whatsoever – the selections over the years have been an absolute joke and Palu was one of them – u can’t build a team around physique stats – its pathetic I can’t even type about this sh…t anymore – it does my head in

      • adc

        I agree, Palu is a flat track bully who smashes it against the ‘lesser’ teams and then goes missing against the Boks and Blacks when it really matters.

    • Mart

      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UoSn2dW_yaQ

      Nah your right. Why have Palu there when you could have the likes of Mcalman!?!

      • @sackdeansnow

        No one would argue that wasn’t a decent hit – we all know that it was and he occasionally made similar ones but that doesn’t make him a great no 8 – Kieren reed doesn’t stand out in my mind as a enforcer yet he is top shelf player – how come ?

        • Mart

          The point is he does the job and does this stuff.

          No doubt he’s the most dominant 8 in Australia?

          And Keiren Read is just a farkin good player. Unfortunately no one in Australia compares to him at the moment.

          And yes he does do this stuff.

          See the shot he put on Pocock the other night

  • BloodRed

    If we could just get Tapuai into 12 and Barnes to the bench we would pretty much have our best available backline.
    Higgers to 6 instead of Dennis who tries hard but is just too pedestrian at international level and a fit Schatz to 8 (gone for the rest of the season?) and the only glaring issue is THP.

  • Mart

    “and the Wallaby backs looking to bamboozle the Bok defense by passing the ball further out than the first channel from the ruck.”

    Ha love it!

    I hope that’s the backline too. Has anyone seen a team sheet yet.

    What are the chances Horne is out of starting team?

  • Pedro

    Is Aleuia (or whatever) injured? Surely if samo is considered a wallaby at his age, surely we could gamble on a younger, faster version.

    That’s why people bang on about palu, you just look at him and think “if he runs at me, I’ll get out of the way”. You need guys like that.

    • Mart

      Exactly. After his form at the start of the season, (crunching hits etc) this guy looked like a perfect Palu substitute. But Deans would’ve picked Mcalman in a heartbeat if he was fit

  • Jimbo81

    NO ROB HORNE!!!

    Way too late but so happy!

  • Skyblue

    I think the boks are going to hammer our foward pack back into they’re hole.leaving our backline as spectators again.

Close