INFOGRAPHIC: Wallabies kick themselves lame

Matt Rowley September 10, 2012 15

No GravatarIf there was an ironic sight on Saturday, it was Berrick Barnes pulling up lame after what must have been his 40th kick of the night. In the end the Wallabies managed to out-kick South Africa by an astonishing 45 to 38 kicks in play. 

To give you a perspective on just how many kicks that is, the average number of kicks per team per game in all of the June internationals (including bore machines England and South Africa) was less than 25. Yes, you got it, the Wallabies almost DOUBLED that on Saturday night.

Barnes – went ROGUE

Kicking in itself isn’t bad — it won the Saffas a world cup. But what was even more spectacular than its frequency on Saturday was the appalling result of that kicking. Against a team with renowned goal-kickers with the last name Steyn, despite hoofing the leather off the ball the Wallabies managed to end up with only 36% territory. No team averaged less than 42% in the June and in only one game did a team has less territory — Wales in the second Test with 31%.

Of course not all of Australia’s kicking was designed to gain territory (although even in those duels we came off second best) — notably the default chip/grubber option  that has become rife. However, it doesn’t take a genius to calculate that grubber kicks from your own 22 are unlikely to leave you with a territorial advantage, or in fact, any advantage.

The general consensus on Twitter during the match was that this was clearly a defined team tactic from the Wallabies — even if it was misguided or poorly executed. However, in his half-time interview, Robbie Deans’ position was that these weren’t team tactics at all, but poor decisions by individuals – surely one B. Barnes. If only Robbie had some sort of influence over Berrick….

The numbers may not all be pretty, but here’s a couple of stunning infographics of the stats from the weekend care of our arch-nemesis from across the ditch, Ruggerblogger.

Thanks to Ruckingoodstats for the other stats in the article.

Click to embiggen.

 

Discussion »

  • rossco

    sounds like Deans may be throwing Barnes under the bus

    • The Rant

      no way! And here’s why. GOALKICKING
      For everyone with short memories this year is the first since the Burke and Flatley days that we’ve kicked in the 80-90 percent range. Barnes boot has ensured all 4 wins this year. How many fucking games over the last 7 years have we drifted out of or just lost due to inferior kicking!? I agree his game kicking has been shit- but if deans can stamp that out then I’ll pick him every time.

      • BloodRed

        Mike Harris

    • old weary

      yeah agree – I didn’t hear that interview, but the question has to be asked, if that was not a tatic, why did they all continue to kick grubbers and chip kicks?

      Either Dean’s is telling porky pies, or he has lost control of the backline and they are doing what they want. Either way not good.

  • Knackers

    Let’s hope the wallaby camp are reading sites like this….

  • Tangawizi

    That field view of all the Saffas ball in our half makes you wonder why they didn’t revert to type and just knock over drop goals all night.

    Wouldn’t have been pretty but geez they were in position to do it.

    Perhaps Wallabies fans are not alone in questioning the intelligence of a few players in their national side.

  • Westo

    Rosco, how is he going to do that when he has no influence?

    [best line of the article Rowy]

  • bludge

    never seen that ruggerblogger site till now, the cheeky buggers have some funny clips to give credit tho.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_XRGJpMJDUk&feature=player_embedded#!

  • RedsHappy

    Serious point: when calibrated with recent history through 2011, the best attribute of Wallaby play/players on September 8 was the relative non-fade physically in the final 15-20 mins of play. This is the period when the Wallabies would often noticeably drift off task and optimum speed, and their mistake rate would increase, whilst their forwards’ intensity would also markedly decrease. (This was of course partly due to Deans’ historically poor use of the bench, now improving fortunately after 4 years of reckless obstinacy on that front.)

    I could see little evidence of the classic fade on Saturday, in fact both Argentina and SA looked markedly less fit in the final quarter than did the Wallabies and ABs.

    My prayer in this regard may have been marginally answered in that I’ve been desperate to see material evidence of some contribution by the new 2012-brand Wallaby assistant coaches and it may be the case that Ashley Jones, the new highly-rated S&C coach from Canterbury NZ, is making a positive (though long overdue) mark on Wallaby conditioning programs, general fitness and strength-related outcomes.

    We are ever vigilant for small mercies after 4.5 years of our national coach’s odd stratagems.

  • Drop kick

    It wasn’t just Barnes that was kicking. Cooper, Beale, Genia, AAC even Shipperly had a go and all were poor.

    Any body got any stats on who kicked/how often.

    • Drop Kick

      I’ll answer my own question.

      Cooper kicked 15 times for a gain of 521m (average 34m)
      Barnes 8 times for 328m (av 41m)
      Beale 7 times for 222m (av 31m)
      Genia 5 for 165m (av 33m)
      AAC 1 for 28m
      Shipperly 1 for 26m

  • Johnny-boy

    The question re kicks is why ? Is Deans just trying to cover his backside saying it wasn’t strategy or are players just willfully ignoring his instructions. If they feel they are following the game plan they would be peeved to hear Deans say at half time it wasnt the game plan and if it wasn’t the game plan they obviously have no interest in following Deans instructions. I think after so many head knocks Barnes has a real decision making problem but his goal kicking is getting Deans off the hook so Deans will ride him in to the ground.

  • Drop Kick

    “If there was an ironic sight on Saturday, it was Berrick Barnes pulling up lame after what must have been his 40th kick of the night.”

    There is a bit of a myth being created by some posters that most/all of the kicking was Barnes fault and that he should have been hooked for disobeying Deans instructions.

    The stats put a bit of perspective on that. If anyone should have been hooked it was Cooper or Beale.

    As I detailed in a post above Cooper kicked twice as much as Barnes and gained far less territory per kick.

    Cooper kicked 15 times for a gain of 521m (average 34m)
    Barnes 8 times for 328m (av 41m)
    Beale 7 times for 222m (av 31m)
    Genia 5 for 165m (av 33m)
    AAC 1 for 28m
    Shipperly 1 for 26m

    Stats are from: http://www.rugbystats.com.au

  • Who Needs Melon

    Jeez I love infographics. And these are crackers. Well done.

  • Who Needs Melon

    And the scrum bit is interesting from the Pumas All Blacks game. Looks like they really gave it to the All Blacks, is that true? If so, we’re in for a torrid time.

Close