Instareview: Wallabies down Boks in Perthfontein

TBH September 8, 2012 72

No GravatarThe Wallabies have beaten the Springboks at Subiaco Oval to open their account in The Rugby Championship for 2012. It was far from a vintage performance, but it was a massive step up from the ignominy of being blanked in Auckland.

Both teams came into the game under a cloud with a couple of fairly poor performances. The early exchanges in the game didn’t really improve things a great deal, it has to be said. The Wallabies seemed to adopt a tactic of kicking at nearly every opportunity. They grubber-kicked in behind the line. They kicked for the corner to give the Boks a lineout and they kicked down Zane Kirchner’s throat. The Boks were content to hang back and receive the ball, then return it with interest. A more pointless (not in the scoring sense) half of footy you’d be hard pressed to see. It’s fair to say that there was considerable unrest in the crowd by half-time!

In a sense it was understandable that the Wallabies were kicking as much as they did. They had next to no field position for almost all of the first half. The Boks were winning their lineout ball easily and putting the ball in the Wallaby 22 constantly. There are really only two ways to respond to that tactic: run the ball back or kick it to the opposition. The Wallabies elected to kick nearly every time.

The Boks were able to keep the score board ticking through pressuring at the breakdown and even scored a try by smashing the ball up around the fringes. With that said, they weren’t particularly threatening in attack. Morne Steyn’s days as Bok five-eighth must be numbered, especially with Johan Goosen and Patrick Lambie looking more threatening when they entered the fray later in the game. The ever-reliable boot of Berrick Barnes kept the Wallabies in touch and they went to the break 13-6 down. I got the feeling that if the Wallabies decided to hang on to the ball a bit more the points would eventually come.

The second half was a marked contrast to the first. There seemed to be much greater intent to keep the ball in hand and test the line. Quade Cooper stood flatter and took the line a lot more, making use of the fairly quick service he’d been getting from the pack and Will Genia most of the night. There was also a greater use of one his favourite plays: the short inside ball to Ioane coming in on an angle. He also tried it with a few of the ball runners in the pack. The tactic appeared to work too. The Wallaby forwards I thought consistently got over the gain line and recycled quickly. This also brought Genia into the game more with his trademarked sniping runs around the ruck base. Slowly but surely the tide turned and a lot of this had to do with not kicking away possession, especially avoiding the low percentage chip and grubber.

A key moment in the game came when Scott Higginbotham entered off the bench. Shortly thereafter, the Wallabies were on attack and he did what you want all big back-rowers to do: hit the line at pace on a great angle. It worked, with Higgers breaking through the defence and scoring next to the posts. This was probably the first time in the game you could feel that the Wallabies were getting on top.

The two sides exchanged a couple more penalties and the scores were even until more good lead up work from Higginbotham sent Ben Alexander crashing over in the corner. The work rate he showed in his time on the paddock is exactly why many (yours truly included) had been wanting him in the team for so long. His two games against the All Blacks were below par, but tonight’s performance was a step forward for him.

One of the things that I thought was noticeable was that the pack appeared to play a tighter formation tonight. In the tight-loose, they not only hit the gain line, but drove through it with numbers. Several times we saw the big bodies of Samo, Timani and Polota-Nau (who had a good game in the loose, I thought) getting the Bok defence shifting backwards and getting some real forward momentum. It happened a bit in the first half, but unfortunately the backs kicked the ball away too much for it to be an advantage. In the second half, however, the momentum built up from the pods of forwards driving the ball through the gain line started to bear fruit. Genia and Cooper were able to spread the ball with much greater ease and create more opportunities as a result. There needs to be a lot more of this kind of forward play in the coming weeks.

It should also be said that Michael Hooper had a terrific game and was involved constantly. He is developing into a very fine player indeed and tonight further enhanced his reputation. He got left a little bit isolated at times and gave away some penalties, but overall he did everything you would want an openside to do, and he has developed a bit of a running game to go with it.

The set pieces were mostly good, though there were a few wobbles as well. The lineout, a traditional area of strength for Australian rugby, wasn’t as secure as it should be and I’m not sure if it was the timing of the lifting/jumping or the throwing. It’s hard to tell in real time. The scrum had its ups and downs, as the Wallaby scrum often does, but did get stronger as the game went on. There were also a couple of hiccups at the restart.

As mentioned above, it wasn’t a performance for the ages and there are some technical areas to work on. The defence was, however, excellent for the most part. There were far fewer missed tackles than in previous weeks and several times the Boks were driven back in contact. That is very pleasing to see.

So not a fantastic performance, against an opposition who seem to be down on confidence, but an improvement over the New Zealand games. There is still some improvement to be made in attack, but there are at least some signs that if they can keep the ball in hand, there will be opportunities.

Finally, mention should be made of what looks like a mounting injury toll. Will Genia‘s knee injury looks serious and will test our depth at halfback. Barnes limped off too, though that may have been cramp. Beale and Timani were also reportedly replaced through injury.

FINAL SCORE: Wallabies 26 – Springboks 19

The scorers:

For Australia:
Tries: Higginbotham, Alexander
Cons: Barnes 2
Pens: Barnes 4

For South Africa:
Try: Habana
Con: M Steyn
Pens: M Steyn 2, F Steyn 2

Australia: 15 Kurtley Beale, 14 Dominic Shipperley, 13 Adam Ashley-Cooper, 12 Berrick Barnes, 11 Digby Ioane, 10 Quade Cooper, 9 Will Genia (c), 8 Radike Samo, 7 Michael Hooper, 6 Dave Dennis, 5 Nathan Sharpe, 4 Sitaleki Timani, 3 Ben Alexander, 2 Tatafu Polota-Nau, 1 Benn Robinson.
Replacements: 16 Saia Fainga’a, 17 James Slipper, 18 Scott Higginbotham, 19 Liam Gill, 20 Nick Phipps, 21 Mike Harris, 22 Anthony Fainga’a.

South Africa: 15 Zane Kirchner, 14 Bryan Habana, 13 Jean de Villiers (c), 12 Frans Steyn, 11 Francois Hougaard 10 Morné Steyn, 9 Ruan Pienaar, 8 Duane Vermeulen, 7 Willem Alberts, 6 Marcell Coetzee, 5 Juandre Kruger, 4 Eben Etzebeth, 3 Jannie du Plessis, 2 Adriaan Strauss, 1 Beast Mtawarira.
Replacements: 16 Tiaan Liebenberg, 17 Pat Cilliers, 18 Flip van der Merwe, 19 Francois Louw, 20 Johan Goosen, 21 Pat Lambie, 22 Lwazi Mvovo.

Referee: Nigel Owens (Wales)

Discussion »

  • muffy

    Passion, finally we see it! Never mind the score, we just want to see the boys play with pride

    • Stin

      Is Sheehan REALLY the best replacement for Genia?!!!! He’s a block head! What about Lucas or some such?

      • bill

        If Lucas is fit he’s way better than either Phipps or Sheehan as a half. Of Sheehan or Phipps though, Sheehan at the moment.

      • Brax

        Lucas injured his leg badly in the semi final against the Sharks.
        White had shoulder surgery a couple of weeks ago.
        Sheehan is pretty much the last man standing.

  • Pie Thrower

    Ugly win. Barely worth being happy about. I hate it when I agree with Phil Kearns, but what is with all the f#*king chip kicks??

    • Groucho

      What happened to the times when a win against the Boks was worth something to Wallaby fans?

      Moreso, a win against the team we’re vying for 2nd place in thew world with.

      In the Gen Y age of Twitter and instant gratification, nothing more than being #1 will satisfy a rugby fan’s desire for mainline sporting gratification.

      Oh well, bugger it. GO WALLABIES! Well done on a gutsy performance.

      • Pie Thrower

        I’m sorry, that is so far from accurate it isn’t funny. It has nothing to do with being #1 or instant gratification at all. What is has to do with is seeing a team develop, learn from their mistakes and get better each week. I didn’t see much of that tonight. There was still aimless kicking when no options presented themselves. There were still poor skills on display. there was still a lack of spark or flair in the backline.

        Please don’t be so condescending as to say that I will only be happy when we are number 1. I will be happy when we play well and we develop as a team.

        • Anonymous

          How can you say they haven’t developed in some way? Perhaps they weren’t perfect but at least they turned it around. Both teams weren’t that great but the wallabies did better than the fortnight before. You’re calling out for development with the snap of your fingers when in truth, if you want it sustained, development is a very long process and each point can be something very small. I can only guess your frustration comes from contrasting this current team with wb teams of the past but you can’t sorry, esp when the injury list to key players is so long.

        • Joker

          Is it a very long process to tell that backs to stop kicking the ball away? I sincerely hope not.

    • D.

      Barnes needs to go. His stupidity in making game decisions gives the opposition prime territory and puts the Wallabies under immense pressure to defend in a broken play. How this guy keeps getting selected is beyond me. Harris can kick conversations. Put him in the starting side.

      Players like Habanna,De Villiars and Fran Steyn are too dangerous to be given possession in broken play close to the Wallaby line.

      Surely Sookface has worn out his welcome. What scares me though is that it took forever for Robbie to get rid of Mumm and Richard Brown. Hopefully it doesn’t take as long for him to realize that Harris is the player that needs to start.

      • http://BigFella Big Fella

        I can’t remember when I’ve watched a player who frustrates and angers me as much as Barnes currently does.
        His style of play is the anti christ of Wallaby backline play.
        The more I watch him, the more evident his limitations become.
        Here’s what shits me;
        - He kicks off so deep into the opposition’s 22, the receiver can catch it and kick it out on the full without any possible chance of pressure by a Wallaby.
        - He continually throws cut out passes which telegraph our attack when just simply putting it through the hands is clearly a better option.
        - Whether he’s playing 10 or 12, he hates running the ball. Cooper and Shipperley show infinitely more courage hanging on to the ball and taking the tackle in readiness for recycling.
        - Left footed kicks and feeble grubbers that stink.
        - I think he’s a dumb footballer who has proven incompetent in making the right decision under the slightest hint of pressure.
        Finally, I’ve worked out why he’s OK at kicking goals……the game has stopped, there is no other decision for him to make other than kicking a resting ball off a tee.

    • skyblue

      A win is a win. but gees I dont know if we actually improved or the boks were bad.not impressed by the boks at all.pretty one dimension team but we did not look muchbetter.they gave us abit of room to get to the gain line which helped.

    • Brax

      Some people go out of their way to whine & will never be
      happy.

      Sure, it wasn’t always pretty & I share the frustration with chip kicks….. BUT we have just beaten the Boks five games on the trot, ever & held onto an important piece of silverwear. Show some pride in your teams achievements, not YOUR perceived shortcomings of them.

      • Pie Thrower

        Brax old boy, I think you’ll find I’m not on my Pat Malone when it comes to my perceptions of their shortcomings.

        Yes it is good to get a win and retain the Mandela plate, but I think last night shows we aren’t developing and hides a few issues we have – primarily our backline showing zero spark on attack.

        If you can honestly say you were happy with that game (especially that first half) good for you. But I’d prefer to look at things objectively and realise that if we keep playing like that we will never beat the AB’s and will get absolutely flogged bythe BI Lions next year. But as long as you are happy with mediocrity…

        • Brax

          It’s often said you’re only as good as your last game. Well we won that against a world top three opposition, nothing else matters this week.
          Yes I was frustrated in the 1st half, yes there is room for improvement. I reckon a lot of that improvement will happen when talented players return from injury layoffs But it’s not my job to worry about that, I watch for entertainment & last night I was entertained & happy we won.
          If you want to spend your life worrying about things that are completely out of your control, knock yourself out.

  • RedsfanDan

    Best part of the whole game was when Kafe nearly got his clock cleaned with a crutch

  • BK

    Wow, what a rollercoaster. Great to see the forwards, well, going forward. Deans must be the most relieved man in Australia.

    Hooper was epic, so strong in contact, christ I hope he stays injury free, as he will be an even bigger force in years to come. AAC’s 2 in 1 tackle was the stuff of legend.

    Not forgetting the flat attack, makes such a difference (on the back of the forwards).

    WBs still have a lot to work on, and fingers crossed re Genia’s knee.

    Agree with the comment re chipkicks, for the love of god, ditch it.

    How funny was that moment when that bizarre soundtrack stating coming through on the fox coverage in the first half?

    • Timbo

      I thought that was my dodgy internet feed

      Few comments…

      AAC – tackling two guys at once. Awesome. Timani had some good go forward. Sharpie was begging for a card. Shipperly had to inject himself into the game and was rewarded with some good carries. That hit by Samo on the winger was a pearler. Played a good half. Interesting call subbing Fat Cat early but paid off with him being fresh at the end. Barnes was too kicky early on but learned finally with some good crash balls. Beale was lucky to get away with some average play. The chip kicking was just to evidently planned. Ditch that manual Deans!

      • KLubby

        Ha! I thought that was music playing at the venue I was watching in KL. Got grouchy at the staff about it. Now I understand why they looked mystified, and it wasn’t a language problem…

  • spectator

    Some Match impressions:

    Good game, Wallabies back in the hunt as a team, wahoo!

    Higginbotham great in both of the tries as an impact player and had a different focus in his play to previous games i thought. Still needed a perfect goal kicking game from Barnes, who was also involved in some great defence along with AAC that was crucial in stopping try scoring movements.

    General kicking game: need to improve ball retention in kickin attack game but is an area of game that needs to be developed & not abandoned.

    In strategic kickin game, the Boks had better of them, as well as creating the Bok try, & i don’t understand why the Wallabies don’t kick for touch more, as they just lose ground and position with just distance kicking general game. This is a pattern from A.B. games too.

    The Wallabies need to spend more time in opposition territory, & at least kickin it out gives opportunity to pressure defensively in line outs in right side of half, as well as open space when fetching kick backs from that end of field rather than defensive line outs stuck deep in own territory. Wallabie backline needs more time in half way area-opposition half in order to develop it’s attacking rhythm. Good to see Cooper flatter & involved in abit more helter skelter attacking play, like to see more of this with flow on effect out wide.

    Boks need to develop game with Goosen. Both sides have potential for much improvement.

  • mad italian flyhalf

    Great match from the forwards all!
    Finally 8-man pack, with good substitutes!

    And what about Phipps?
    Looks Deans was right also about him, he came in in a key moment and well in a extremely difficult situation!
    Big shoes to fill in the next games!

    Chip kick was a tactic but didn’t worked completley, it was to move the back three and opening space in depth to explore with long kicks, but the Saffa trio played well in this occasion!

  • pedro

    It was entertaining match, but I hope all of those kicks weren’t part of a strategy Things were looking dire for a while, what ever happened to running kick returns. Beale was still flat and seems to be distracted somewhat.

    • D.

      He was wondering what his followers on twitter were saying. Bench this guy, and send him to catching and kicking school. I so can’t wait for JOC to come back.

  • Knackers

    FARKING CHIP KICKS – GIVE IT UP!

    I’ll say it louder if the wallaby camp are listening… FARKING CHIP KICKS – GIVE IT UP!

    First half was THE worst 40min performance I have seen from the wallabies. Saved only by the fact that the Springbulls are just as lost as we are.

    What concerns me most though is Kafe and Cannon both remarked to Deans about the kicking at half time and full time and he said they keep telling the players not to do it – but it still happens!!! Hook the next prick that chip kicks inside our 22 off the field and strap him to an electric chair FFS!!

    Good to get a win over the Jaapies – but seriously we were SHIT.

    • spectator

      It is significant that the best executiion of an attackin kick by the Wallabies created a fast confusion which lead to the Bok forward pack having to play a man down for ten minutes…..later on in the game the Bok forwards lost their edge & Wallies scored through forward play.

      A diff. type of kick attack which is Bok forte, was their try which had it’s go forward from a bobbling bomb.

      I’m not saying when you have the ball in space with momentum, particularly in a backline situation with numbers, there is much comparative gain by chipping or grubbing to a defence more set for it. But the percentage of ball in hand that creates tries isn’t necessarily going to be close to that of attacking kicks regathered, which do seem to figure quite often in scoring situations when they occur or at least situations of sudden intense scoring pressure.

  • Dave

    Better performance in patches than the two Bledisloes. We did our best to lose it though. We gifted the Boks nearly all their points with dumb  ”tactical” kicking and poor decision making. Seriously? Again? I thought we saw the end of that two weeks ago. 
    Hooper was awesome, as was Timani. Samo good too. We needed these guys to step up and they did. Sharpe pulled his head in (literally, the head butt missed after all) and put in a better 2nd half. Cooper’s flat, quick passing almost has no equal. Solid game from him. He’s really improved his defence.

    Barnes, Barnes, Barnes, Barnes, Barnes. No one doubts your effort son but seriously, why grubber kick when ball in hand is working, why grubber kick in your own 22, why grubber kick into non recoverable space, why grubber kick? It must have been infectious as even Shipperly had a dab. That worked out just as well. One grubber kick worked, one. And that was because Digby ran hard and did what Digby does. The ball was turned over every other time.  If nothing else it was slightly embarrassing. Please oh please stop it. The Argies defend like demons. They kick well too. They’ll be hoping you gift them such easy procession.
    And Beale. Not himself. Hope he comes out of it soon. Too much talent to be wasted in a slump.
    AAC. That has to be the world’s fastest sequential tackles by a single individual. Congrats! Ioane was Ioane. I know it’s a bad look seemingly jovial after a loss but how can anyone doubt his dedication to the green and gold jersey? So consistent. Must be a nightmare for defenders. 
    Genia had an average game. Did some okay things punctuated with some, again, dodgy kicking. He knew he didn’t play his best giving himself up to Kafe in the post match interview in an awkward misunderstanding.

    Scrums were good. Line outs average. We again didn’t compete on their throw choosing instead to defend. A shame as I think we had an honest chance at procession. Especially against a young bok lineout. Oh well, another skill we’ll have to relearn.

    All in all not so much satisfying as it was a relief to get a win. Nothing overly comforting to come out of it though. A lot of work needs to be done. Especially putting the ball on the boot.

    Last of all, well done the WBs! Great to get a win coming from behind. Showed some grit and courage. All in all pleasing although although I’m still not ecstatic. Maybe I’ll feel better about it on review.

    • Dave

      Sorry about the double post. My comment didn’t show up immediately so I thought there was a glitch so I posted it again. Apparently there was a delay. Feel free to delete the first post as I think I made changes to the second one.

  • Dave

    Better performance in patches than the two Bledisloes. We did our best to lose it though. We gifted the Boks nearly all their points with dumb “tactical” kicking and poor decision making. Seriously? Again? I thought we saw the end of that two weeks ago.
    Hooper was awesome, as was Timani. Samo good too. We needed these guys to step up and they did. Sharpe pulled his head in (literally, the head butt missed after all) and put in a better 2nd half. Cooper’s flat, quick passing almost has no equal. Solid game from him. He’s really improved his defence.

    Barnes, Barnes, Barnes, Barnes, Barnes. No one doubts your effort son but seriously, why grubber kick when ball in hand is working, why grubber kick in your own 22, why grubber kick into non recoverable space, why grubber kick? It must have been infectious as even Shipperly had a dab. That worked out just as well. One grubber kick worked, one. And that was because Digby ran hard and did what Digby does. The ball was turned over every other time. If nothing else it was slightly embarrassing. Please oh please stop it. The Argies defend like demons. They kick well too. They’ll be hoping you gift them such easy procession.
    And Beale. Not himself. Hope he comes out of it soon. Too much talent to be wasted in a slump.
    AAC. That has to be the world’s fastest sequential tackles by a single individual. Congrats! Ioane was Ioane. I know it’s a bad look seemingly jovial after a loss but how can anyone doubt his dedication to the green and gold jersey? So consistent. Must be a nightmare for defenders.
    Genia had an average game. Did some okay things punctuated with some, again, dodgy kicking. He knew he didn’t play his best giving himself up to Kafe in the post match interview in an awkward misunderstanding.

    Scrums were good. Line outs average. We again didn’t compete on their throw choosing instead to defend. A shame as I think we had an honest chance at procession. Especially against a young bok lineout. Oh well, another skill we’ll have to relearn.

    All in all not so much satisfying as it was a relief to get a win. Nothing overly comforting to come out of it though. A lot of work needs to be done. Especially putting the ball on the boot.

    Last of all, well done the WBs! Great to get a win coming from behind. Showed some grit and courage. All in all pleasing although although I’m still not ecstatic. Maybe I’ll feel better about it on review.

  • Tom

    Fuck channel nine they just finished their broadcast. Fuck Tom Waterhouse too and Harvey Norman

    • bill

      Channel 9 remind me of those reflex ad’s, u just can’t trust them. They advertised an 1140pm replay perth time, walked out on my break at work at 7pm perth time and they were rolling. F*ng GAYFL trolls.

    • Packy

      channel 9 is not taking this seriously – looks like they delayed the telecast to pack the ads in
      And the SMH website said 10.35pm kickoff. That was about 40 minutes too late.

  • Skip

    It ought to be a clause in dingo’s contract whereby every time there is useless chip kick by a player he coaches, he has to publically explain what one of his bullshit bingo expression means.

    • bill

      I believe the ARU are in a pre-contemplative phase of considering that very idea!

  • Alan

    Fantastic to get the win especially against the boks – not something to ever take for granted.

    Still though… there is MUCH to improve on if we are to come close to challenging the ABs, i cant help but think they would have made shit of both those teams on the field tonight.
    Im really worried with how stifled and clueless our backline is. What has happened to the side we saw not long ago in bloemfontein who seemingly scored tries for fun??

    Hooper is outstanding. Does anyone honestly know what he squats? He has immense leg drive and a running game i only wish bambam possessed.

    ….Would it be absolutely insane to slot him into somewhere into the backs when pocock returns? he sure as fuck could do some damage and break the game line more often then faainga/mccabe/horne. I cant see him replacing poey and with gill being a great impact 7 its seems a real shame to leave a talent like hooper contesting just a bench spot

    Liking the look of Timani also, he is starting to impose himself more and more now, another great prospect

    KB sadly still looks out of sorts and is a long way off the player he was 2 years ago

    If genia is out injured its a real shame we wont have Nic White to call upon, i think he is miles better then phipps

    • RJ

      Never thought about tht option. I hear Hooper has the secnd or third fastest 40m in the brumbies too. We could use a 100kg 11 second inside centre actually.

      Oh wait, we got one, and he might be playing next weekend. At least you know Tapuai wont chip kick

      • bill

        I was looking at the lack of a back up second rower on the bench and thinking Gill/Hooper could cover some backline possies. I don’t think Hooper can really start as a 6, but he can cover there later once the opposition are worn.

  • Jman of Brissy

    Clearly you can’t be a Wallabies fan without Foxtel. Channel 9′s coverage of tonight’s match was a joke – they just relayed the Fox Sports game commentary, delayed the broadcast and filled the game with ads, and then cut to a dodgy movie on the final hooter, with no post-game analysis or interviews. How much did they pay the ARU for the right to do that?

    • Mart

      It was disgraceful. I fell asleep in the second add break, the ads took fore ever

  • Canuckruck

    Well done Wallabies. Not quite France in November 2010, but certainly an improvement from the last game.

    The “9-10-12- kick” play by Barnes has got to stop. Please!

    • bill

      That match is why I think we need to ditch Deans, I don’t understand how we can play that clinically and then disappear ever since. It’s just f*cked. Moses only spent 40 days in the f*ng desert for god’s sake.

      • JJJ

        Think you mean Jesus. Moses spent 40 years in the desert.

  • bill

    Well here we go, good performance in the final analysis, but a shitload to work on. General execution better, but still a lot of rubbish played in the backs. And now Phipps, presumably at halfback.

    …still, can’t imagine Cooper will fail to appraise Phipps of just what he thought of that attempt to kill him by bok chargedown at the end.

    Biggest macabre disappointment of the game, not seeing that arrogant wannabe secondrower of the boks who tried to headbutt Sharpe try the same shit on Higginbotham… would’ve been a redcard for someone for sure.

    • RJ

      If he did that to Higgers, he would have got KO’d.

      • bill

        I don’t know, Higgers is fiery but I’ve never seen him start something he’s usually just standing his ground, but that look of entitlement on that dude’s face just wanted punching.

    • Patrick

      He did get reported at least

  • the ardent b’stard

    Interesting reaction from Genia in the post match with Kafe – a little touchy about his form perhaps.
    Looking forward to next week – Big Argie backs gave ABs an issue yesterday with drift defence, cant see Cooper goingt to the lie against these guys, and he didnt really ask the defence to make any choices yesterday although he distributed well, should be interesting – as will be the Big SA loosies against a far more mobile AB pack
    Good stuff this rugby!!!

  • Robson

    So much for Barnes whinging on about needing the forwards to give the backs some front foot ball. When he got it he kicked it away – often with space in front of him and then usually right down a Springbok’s throat!!!!!!! What is going on in that boy’s head??

    But that was the only thing that really pissed me off. I thought it was a big step up from Auckland especially in the intensity appplied at the breakdown, but it also needed to be.

    For a No. 6 Dennis was pretty nearly invisible, but I’ll give him the benefit of the doubt and say that he was probably buried in the tight stuff! I was annoyed to see Benn Alexander resting with his hand on the back of the ruck when he re entered the game in the second half. Some one needs to tell him that his job is in the ruck not watching it.

    A hair cut and a shave obviously do good things for Scott Higginbotham and the mop chop that Samo had kept him going longer than I anticipated he would. Both these loosies played well and Hooper was also very impressive.

    So in summary it must be said that two weeks of humiliation brings out the best in a team.

    Now for the Argies next week. By the look of their style in Wellington last night, the Wallabies will have to have to shift up another couple of gears to deal with them. Their line speed in defence is very good indeed and they make their tackles count. They produced more dominant tackles in eighty minutes last night than the Wallabies have all season.

    This could be a closely fought encounter.

    • Dave

      Spot on Robson. However I think the Argies might have trouble backing up. They gave everything they had in that 1st half against the ABs. Clearly tired in the 2nd the shifting of gears by the ABs caught them out. We matched the Saffas forwards and even, dare I say it, dominated them occasionally. No reason we can’t do that against the Pumas. Unless of course we suffer from the usual over confidence that seems to infect us as soon as we get a win. But you are absolutely right, it’s probably going to be close.

      Great to have them in the competition. It really has livened up a formula that was, in retrospect, getting a bit tired.

      • johnny-boy

        By the look of some faces the Wallabies might have trouble backing up to. Some good efforts there and they gave it everything but at times the Wallabies were awful but the Boks were awfuler.
        I almost feel sorry for Saffas.

    • Garry

      And with our history of “click, boom” consistency, we’re about due for another Samoa/Scotland/ (add team) pant-sing.

      I’m worried.

    • bill

      I thought Dennis was the glue that held us together against the all blacks last time out, and fairly solid here as well… but he isn’t a Samo or Cockbain in defence and against NZ that killed us, we need a guy at 6 who is better than solid, we need someone who makes the opposition look at the defensive line when they receive the ball to think who’s where to run AWAY from.

      It’s a pretty easy test,once the oppo start looking at the defence and knock on you know you’ve found your guy.

  • Justo

    Nic white having a shoulder recon so is unavailable.

    Over all a much better 2nd 40. Cannot understand if the coach is feeling the heat and his players chip kick everything and at 1/2 time Deans appears mystified that this is happening. Maybe their just paying what’s in front of them

    • Dave

      It was never in front of them. Grubber kicks work but they have to be executed correctly and in the right part of the field. The aim is to turn defenders around not have them running onto the ball just gifted to them. Perplexing.

  • Joe

    Signs of improvement from the Wallabies but they were also helped by a very below par Springboks side who were not their usual selves.

  • Blackness

    It was nice to see a couple of teams showing some respect for the laws of the game at the breakdown and a ref that was willing to police it. Sure they were both testing the boundaries as they should but it is a different game for the most part seeing players, actually rolling away, not playing the ball or other players on the ground, not diving over the top or coming around the side (and getting penalised if they did) or constantly loitering offside (lest they get ironed out like Sharpy).

  • Tropical Sauce

    Does anyone know who is in #TeamRehab currently ??? It must be a pretty good side

  • TropicalSauce

    Does anyone know who is in #TeamRehab currently ??? It must be a pretty good side !!!

  • Dirt Tracker

    It all makes sense now. Deans’s comments about telling the backs over and over again not to chip kick, Cooper stealing a laptop, Beale carrying a shoulder reconstruction and (allegedly) hitting a security guard.

    Seems to me that the Aussie backline is not selected on intelligence.

  • TerribleTowel

    well, the decision of the selectors to bone Nick White for Phipps is looking so incredibly stupid now that Genia is injured. I mean fuck, you tell the guy he’s the second string half-back after Genia, getting him to put off surgery that the guy needs, then leave him out of the side for a player in Phipps who simply isn’t as good as him, now Genia’s down, White is off to surgery 6 weeks later then he should have been so there’s no chance of getting him back in time for anything, and we’re stuck with Phipps at scrum half. (Rant over) Good match from the wallabies forwards, especially the scrum, Benny A and Fat Cat were dominant when they were on together, and slipper was solid after giving up that first penalty. Well done to those backs (AAC, Shipperly, Ioane) who didn’t indulge their inner chip kick loving fuckwit

    • Patrick

      I actually thought Phipps did quite well when he got on, focused on passing quickly and straight and pretty much did that.

      One of Nic White’s real strengths is the box kick, which we just don’t need right now.

      • Pedro

        White would definitely be in the squad if fit, he should’ve been there anyway. His box kicking is good, but his kicking distance in general would be better than any current wallabies. That’s something that would be useful.

  • boutbloodytime

    Well that was a game interspersed with brain explosions & brilliance!!!

    The first 40 minutes….WTF?!?…braindead kicking options that only serve to put your own side under pressure are beyond me…It’s time for another GAGR T-shirt idea:

    “I’m not an alcoholic, I only drink when the Walabies kick away possession’…

    I just hope QC, Beale or someone else in the starting XV is practising their penalty kicks & conversions so that it puts Barnes under pressure for his spot, cos unfortunately, he’s the incumbent kicker & wont sort his shit out until he realises there is a real chance of being dropped (Mike Harris is a great kicker, but after Wales, Deans will stick with Berrick through thick & thin or until his next concussion).

    After having a first 40 minutes of rip my hair out & swearing at the TV, Higgers try & the double ‘F*&k me that was awesome’ tackle from AAC in the second half, has hopefully signified a turning point for this Wallabies side.

    In the last 20 minutes, especially as the body count was mounting, some of the guys stepped up & injected some onfield leadership, showed some cool heads & it was the Saffers turn to crack under the pressure…

    Fortunately/Unfortunately?!? I think the ongoing injury toll has demonstrated that there is depth in Australian rugby, if the fringe players are just given a run, rotated effectively & shown some faith by the coaching staff…Shipperley & Hooper being just 2 examples & Timani is beginning to assert himself…I don’t know if Robbie deserves the credit there or not….bit of a double edged sword.

    Whether it was tactics from the coaches or necessity, the Wallabies manned up & did the job when it counted in the closing stages, so a massive congratulations there.

    Poor Sharpie though- the ticker is huge but the legs don’t seem to have the miles in them anymore…huge effort & showing a bit of mongrel so the young pups show a bit of respect to the old dog…kudos for hanging in & not retiring yet!

    In summary, great to get a win against SA, but still so much to improve. Ultimately it’s one of those bittersweet moments with this game producing 2 records…first Wallabies side to win 5 in a row against the Boks…longest period of game time for the Wallabies to not score a try since 1972…kinda says it all really…

    • Dave

      Great write up and summary. Balanced and fair minded. Couldn’t agree more with your summary of what was essentially a good night for Oz rugby.

    • ooaahh

      “I’m not naturally bald, i just tear my hair out every time the wallabies kick away possession.”

      • boutbloodytime

        ‘I don’t have Tourette’s, I only swear when the Wallabies kick away possession’

  • PD

    An average game between two average sides. Two soft tries by poor Bokke defence. Two teams still seaching for their game. Not many positives for either team.

  • Chairman

    If Shipperley is Wallaby # 800 and something, who was # 1?

  • jimmyc

    poor Nic White – made his decision one week too early!!!!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/RebuildTheWaratahs hannibal

    That AAC double tackle was gold. Its been too long since we’ve seen what he can really do. Maybe he’s finding some confidence.

    Not much talk about Shipperly but he was brilliant for a debutant in a pressure match. Looked dangerous at every touch. Deans – pls keep him in the starting 15.

    Whats going on between Nigel Owens and Sharpie? There seems to be some bad blood there and Sharpie’s doing some wierd stuff in the last 2 matches. This cross the lineout stuff seems deliberatly instructed but not sure what its achieving other than the ire of the ref?

    • Red Kev

      The AAC tackle was red not gold. Two neck-high contacts within a second of each other, that’s a red card.

  • tombo

    watched the league -NQ v Broncoes before the test.

    Sadly the inane tactics of Barnes et al made it a hard slog to stay tuned after Bowen & Thurston

    • bill

      I only really watch the state of origin each year but even though union can stretch a team out of shape more than league it was an embarrassing contrast between that and the wallabies vs the all blacks, a real amatuer hour. And they still have a way to go.

Close