Reds Beat Tahs in Last Minute Thriller

Hugh Cavill February 25, 2012 53

No GravatarIt was agony and ecstasy. Death and glory. Victory and defeat.

 

Whatever side of the fence you are on, it was a cracking finish to a pretty good game. The Reds scored a try after the buzzer to take the game 25-21 from the Tahs, who looked like a lock with mere seconds to go. It was a brutal, physical game, with both sides looking good at times. Expect both to feature at the business end of the season.

First up the crowd were treated to an exhibition of Subbies rugby, courtesy of Balmain and Petersham. All eyes were on the ‘caveman’ Sebastian Chabal, who was here for one game and one game only. His locks were flowing, his beard was scratchy, and he had a few very classy touches including a try under the sticks from close range. But largely it seemed he approached the game as casually as his appearances at Sydney landmarks, and spent most of his time on the wing. I can’t remember who won, and frankly I don’t think anyone cared. Both will be crushed by King’s Old Boys this season anyway.

The main event opened with some bruising Palu defence, and an early penalty was converted by Halangahu from long range. Mike Harris hit back soonafter to tie the scores at 3-3 after six minutes. Discipline was an issue for the Tahs in the first half, and they gave away too many soft penalties at the ruck. 3 became 6 and then 9 to the Reds. But it was big Cliffy who would cross the line first after the ball spilled out the back of a Tahs scrum on the Reds line. Hangers failed to convert, but the Tahs gave away a soft penalty after the siren and they went to the sheds at 12-8 to the Cane Toads.

Me in the press box after the game. It's pretty rustic in there. Also I'm pretty ripped.

Hangers knocked over an early penalty to draw the Tahs closer in the second stanza, but Harris hit back quickly to make it 15-11 Reds. The game was fairly even for the bulk of the half, with a disallowed try to TPN a key moment. The ball was deemed to have come forward from Kingston to TPN after a pinpoint AAC bomb. In slow-mo it looked flat, if not slightly forward. I thought it was a fair call by the touchie. As both sides rung the changes the game slowed down with both teams set to fight it out like two country nags in the straight at Warracknabeal. Hangers potted a penalty after a few minutes on the Reds line, and the Tahs looked to be slowly getting on top in tight. The pressure was converted into points after new recruit Sarel Pretorius B.I.G darted over from close range after good build up play from the Tahs backs. Hangers converted and the score went to 21-15 to the Tahs.

Harris pegged the score back by 3 as the game entered the final minutes, with the Tahs seemingly a lock for the game. With the clock ticking down they repelled wave after wave of Red attack, and then the turnover came! And then they kicked the fucking ball away! And then the Reds spread the ball wide! And then Shipperley found himself in space! And he fucking scored! The Reds fucking won on the buzzer! What a finish! Enough exclamation marks for you!!

I thought the standard of play was pretty good for the first round. These games are always physical slogfests, and this was no different. The Tahs were direct and at times brutal. They defended well with big hits coming from Palu, TPN and later Lopeni Timani. Once again I thought they struggled a bit for punch around the ruck with ball in hand, with Mumm, Dennis and Douglas too often caught behind the advantage line. The backs were serviceable but slow. Carter was, well… Carter, and Horne had his good and bad moments. AAC struggled to inject himself but what he did was good, while I thought young Tom Kingston looked good out wide. I do wonder if Daniel Halangahu is a Super quality 10 anymore, for mine he was way too slow with ball in hand and the outside men suffered. Sarel Pretorius was given the MoTM and he had a good game but not a barnstormer. He wouldn’t have been my choice.

For the Reds once again it was a solid 15 man effort. In the pigs Beau terrorised every tuck, while Big Kev got through plenty of work. Higgers also threatened. I thought their inside backs were outstanding. Harris ran the backline with aplomb, and his kicking was pinpoint. Tapuai picked up where he left off last season, and I’m reckon he’ll get plenty of time in gold later this season. Digby was also electric every time he touched the ball, but sadly these touches were few and far between. And Shipperley… well he didn’t do much but what he did was pretty good in the end!

 

Reds 25 (Shipperley try, Harris con, 6 pgs) beat Waratahs 21 (Palu, Pretorius tries; Halangahu con, 3pg). Crowd 32,071. Ref: Jaco Peyper.

 

Tune back in tomorrow for our full length review.

Discussion

  • bones

    To win the comp you need a bit of early luck to go your way so you build some surprise momentum. Reds to take it again this year.

    Tahs are a difficult team to actually like. I think it is because they focus their play mainly on their strengths, which is their front row / pack. Either way it doesnt get your pulse racing. Foley looks good for future 10.

    • Mart

      Good point about Foley. He provided spark every time he touched the ball.

      Dwyer made a good point about Halangahu never backing up after he’s passed.

      Very painful to watch Dennis ghost along side Shipperly as he straightens then burns every one. I know he put in some hard work but this is for the game have a dive at him or something!?!

  • zeedok

    I thought Foley’s cameo was very impressive, and Tom Kingston looked the goods.

    Pretorius didn’t really get going in attack, and saw at least 2 or 3 bad defensive lapses.

    As a Tah fan I was disappointed with the outcome, but considering the injury and retirement toll I thought the effort was pretty good.

    No matter what the Sydney media hype would have us believe this is a re-building year for the Tahs and the Reds are the defending champs, with close to their best team on the field.

  • Cat

    I really enjoyed your review – great balance in the story. It would’ve been easy to get caught up in the emotion of it all but you nailed it.

    Thanks

  • Blood and Mustard

    30 seconds to go and your team leads by 3 – do you: (a) play three rucks and kick for touch; or (b) hand the ball to the other team?

    That there is the reason McKibbin should have been dropped long ago!

    • BloodRed

      According to grumbles Crowden it was Carter who called for the kick and that was just moments after he’d been head slapping Digby and crowing about having won with time still on the clock and less than one score in front. If you wanted to drop anyone, I’d start with that dickhead.

  • http://landoftheunit.wordpress.com/ Sully

    I love how you kept to the facts and did not allow emotion to effect this review at all. The Reds were very lucky to win this but after losing a few in similar situations I’ll claim it.

    • zuzu

      Agreed, in recent years the Reds were pipped at the post numerous times even if they had the dominant game, what goes around comes around! Kudos to the Tahs with many injuries to apply so much pressure to the champs. Go the Reds!!!

  • D.

    News flash: McKibbin edges out Shippers as Reds MOM!

    Go the Reds!!!!

  • jay-c

    hangers has never been anything more than a good club player-
    in the 7 or so years hes had at the tahs hes never consistanly made it off the bench- in fact he only played this game cause barnes was injured- but from nowhere foley gives him the captaincy
    the only logic i can see in this is that he wont stress out thinking about his own game to much cause he has to focus on the team
    he was not the reason they lost by any means and im not trying to direct blame- but i question a coaching team who makes a decision like his at the start of the season> surely robinson or any of tpn, mumm, dennis would have made a better choice?
    his really has me worried for the season- probably mor than the injury sitch

    • Blinky Bill of Bellingen

      But IMHO he was the main reason we lost. 30 seconds to go & with inexperienced players in key positions HE needed to step-up as Captain & prevent individuals from ‘going for the glory’. We only needed to keep it in tight and wind down the clock. The Red’s only chance of pulling off a win was to get their hands on the ball and unbelievably WE booted it back to them? :(

    • RJ

      Hangers really has just been a bench warmer for 7 years. He must be getting splinters by now with all that time on the pine

    • suckerforred

      I actually think that Hangers was captain in theory only. Robbo was having plenty to say and Hangers was relaying that to to Ref.

      • JJJ

        Robbo: “We’ll have a scrum mate.”
        Hangers: “Scores are pretty tight, maybe we should kick for-”
        Robbo: “We’ll have a scrum mate.”
        Hangers: “But there are points on offer-”
        Robbo: “We’ll have a farken scrum!”
        Hangers: “Yeah but I’m the cap-”
        Robbo: “SCRUM! MATE!”
        Hangers: “We’ll take the scrum thanks ref.”

  • tc63

    As a Tahs supporter – bitterly disappointed, however pleased with the effort from the team and Foley’s coaching to get intensity at the breakdown.
    However – clearly the game was lost due to poor captaincy – Halangahu was a poor choice – did not kick for goal with 20 to go. I see above blame for McKibbon, but surely he was following captain instructions or lack there of. If the captain was a forward I can guarantee that ball would never have gone to the backs with 30 secs to go. So Foles, unfortunately your loss tonight due to a brain explosion in making H captain.
    Captaincy – 3 / 10
    Forwards play – 8 / 10
    Backs play – 6 /10
    Bench – 7 / 10

    PS. Am a big fan of Foles, just made a poor choice in a player over 7 years who has consistently failed to deliver at this level.

  • Tangawizi

    Go the Reds! Getting married first weekend of the finals so need the bye. Thank you Mr McKibbin!

    • The Rant

      haha – great incentive.

    • suckerforred

      Were you involved in the date discussion at all? If so – very poor choice. If not…… very poor choice.

    • Dave

      Haha, ironically I’m in East Africa at the moment – without supersport! Pole sana, Tangawizi…

  • The Rant

    to be fair to mckibbon – he got the call from his winger to put it down the line and his kick still put QLD down in their 22 with 20 secs on the clock. The rest of the tahs can take the blame for´switching off before the whistle.

    I was watching a dodgy stream so one moment the reds are picking up the kick and then it froze and came back with the image of 10reds doing a stacks on in the in-goal… good for my tipping, shit for the tahs.

    • wato

      Who would listen to a winger, especially in that situation? with 20 secs to go, you look for a lock or back rower to rumble it up and recycle the ball. Tell the winger to $%@# off.

    • Dave

      I think you’ll find that it was Carter who told McKibben to put it downfield. Carter then chased (from an arguably offside position) what was a good, albeit unnecessary and ill timed kick – but instead of following the chase through decided to show off his comedic skill set and ran directly into a Reds’ player and fell to ground. Bravo.

      Carter seems to flip a coin on every play to decide if he should help his team or challenge them. Can’t fault his effort but his execution and decision making seem to go missing at times.

      The try was then a result of taking advantage of a tired an unstructured defence by quickly spreading it wide followed by a good display of Dagg-like speed and deception from Shipperly. Bravo (not sarcastic this time).

  • murph

    The Tards stole it two years ago, so we’re stealing it back. Cheers!

  • Robson

    A tale of taken opportunities and one where the Tahs switched off 20 seconds too early.

  • theyank

    Well that game was played out exactly as people predicted it would. Sloppy ball handling and a brawl at the breakdown. Without Quade the Reds quick ball has turned to semi-quick with the high probability of a knock on. As for the Tahs, well they didn’t have their three best backs but how money was #13? Nails on defense.

    The only thing that made that game worth staying up until 3:00 am to watch was the last minuet try. GO REDS!!

    PS- Palu getting back into form is GOOD news for the future wallabies

  • Gallagher

    Tahs played a far more controlled and powerfull game at the ruck, we need to commit more numbers here if we are to keep possssion against Saders, Blues, Cheetahs, Force etc, but it gives us flexible game plans, try and read us now!!!
    I cant wait to get Qude back now, Harris to centre/fullback (has to stay on the field with his kicking), morahan/tapuai have to miss out unfortunately. We need Quades spark on attack and Harris’s boot. Robinson and Gill is going to be a SWEET battle for the seven jersey this year! Hanson for mine was MOM.
    Great to see Palu and TPN back and fighting fit, Tahs will be a force to reckon with this year once Barnes, Mitchell, Rocky etc return.

    • Westo

      Good call G.

      Bring on the Force cause I still have not forgiven that team for 2006 pilfering of 13 qld players.

      I promise i will when we, the reds, rip them a new asshole.

      By the way NZ and RSA, I love the easy conference so fuck off and take you constant winging with it, Perhaps to the UK.

      • wato

        Nothing like a QLDer to hold a grudge

    • Westo

      Good call G.

      Bring on the Force cause I still have not forgiven that team for 2006 pilfering of 13 qld players.

      I promise i will when we, the reds, rip them a new asshole.

      By the way NZ and RSA, I love the easy conference so f*** off and take you constant winging with it, Perhaps to the UK.

  • theyank

    mitchell, turner, tpn, palu, kepu, AND elsom…. sheesh what is this the super 14 wallabies representative side. Only aussie team i see givin them a run for their money is the up-and-coming REBELS.never count out the evil wizard mortlock, (as the kiwis would say)

    • murph

      Bullshit

  • pants

    Thank fk rugby is back on. Cricket just does my head in these days. Not sure how good an omen it is for the Reds to win the first game of the season. I usually write off the first game as the one they always lose, usually to the Waratahs. Even more strange is i felt a twinge of sympathy for the Tahs in how they lost that one at the death. It didn’t last more than a nano second though. With Wales beating England as well, its good results all round.

  • Skippy

    Wasn’t overly impressed with Pretorius. His passing certainly leaves a lot to be desired and despite Burgess having issues over accuracy, Pretorius’ slow passing is more of a hinderance than Burgess ever was.
    Hangers – Why he never took the money overseas and made himself available for whichever Island he has a background from and played in a World Cup is beyond me. Never been a Super 15 player and never will be.

  • godfrey

    Yes, Foley should start next week and Kingston should get a run in the centres with Horne.

    Dreaming of an all Aloysian Wallaby midfield: Foley, McCabe, Kingston…..BOOM!

    • TSP

      Spot on mate

  • Brisvegas54

    Solid article. Just read some of the commentary on foxsports where all the punters were whinging about the quality of the game. Wake up. It’s the first game of the season and reds/tahs is never a free flowing affair. It’s trench warfare. No different to to the force game last year.

    Thought Harris played well. Some nice little breaks but just couldn’t link up. Reds can Only improve.

    Good on the tahs. With a full strength team on the park they will be hard to beat at home but lack a spark without Beale. I would like to reinforce that Tom Carter is the biggest knob in world rugby. I saw about 5 arse or head pats on reds players after mistakes or turn overs were made. That’s just not rugby champ. You are the Benny Elias of league, the Collongwood of afl, the souths of Brisbane premier grade.

    • Pie Thrower

      thank god someone else saw that tw-t Tom carter carrying on with all of that rubbish. It has no place in the game – especially from a two bit hack such as he is.

    • brisvegas54

      I think I started something here……..

  • Brax

    Fully agreed with your post Brisvegas….. until your little dig at the Mighty Magpies!!!! Don’t you mean the Filth that is Brothers? Unless……..

    • bill

      yeah, bros in my day were a chattier mob.

  • liquor box

    “In the pigs Beau terrorised every tuck”
    I have to disagree, he had a great game but missed quite a few breakdowns (obviously cant be at them all).
    If you look at Gill he must surely compete at a higher percentage of breakdowns than any other flanker in the game, granted he is a sub so he can run himself ragged but he covers a lot of ground to do his job.
    I would like to see them both start and then who ever plays best stays on field at the end and Samo can come on.

  • JJJ

    If Robinson had been made captain he would’ve called for a scrum at every penalty.

    • suckerforred

      He did on those close the the line.

  • ChumbaWumba

    The final result was a relief for Red people but it was hardly an inspiring win. Mistake strewn are the words for Qld. The Reds showed lots of enterprise and exciting promise (Higgers v threatening on the wing; Tapuai penetrating, forwards with some excellent ball carries) but lets be honest without Harris amazing accuracy with the boot Qld would have lost horribly. The stuff up on their own line that resulted in the second Tahs try was emblematic. The Reds are too used to Quade weaving magic in that situation and extracting them from disaster – without him Qld looked flat and even when linked moves got somewhere there was an inevitable turnover. A wins a wins for sure but we’ll have to do a lot better than that to repeat 2011.

    • Dave

      Having seen a replay, we did look rusty, but bear in mind how we started last season against the force

  • suckerforred

    As a reds supporter sitting in amoungst the blue on Saturday – wasn’t it f&%^$#g great!

    Now from what I saw….

    Cliffy looks bloody good. Much fitter (smaller maybe) then I think we have seen him for a while. This can only be good and here is hoping he stays that way.

    I think Morahan actually had quite a good game. I forgot how bloody big he looks amongst other backs. Think he needs to stay at 15, but what are we going to do with Harris when/if QC comes back? Nice problem to have. Based on that game alone I would say Ant to drop out, Taps to 13, Harris to 12, QC 10.

    Taps had a fairly quiet night, by his standards. That could apply to a lot of both sides though.

    Beau and Ant need to get their tackles sorted. There were a few where they went in for the big hit, were ineffective, and then were out of the play for a passage while they were realigning themselves. I did like Beau’s hyena cackle at Cliffy though.

    Higgers played well. Did make a few mistakes but played well. I think he has been given a roaming comission like Digby so the fact that he ends up wide a lot I don’t think is an issue, except occasionly he is on the wing when we reall do neeed him at the breakdown. Nice punt and bit of niggle with Carter.

    Horne tackling well, lets hope he stays fit. AAC seemed a little lost. Would it be better for the Tahs if he was on the wing and BKH & Kingston at fullback? Alcock looks good. Sarel I think played well and will only get better from here on. Glad I had both him and Harris in my fantsay team. Shipperly did show some toe. Charter had a slow start to his season.

    Over all it was a scrappy game, but that is to be expected first up in the season. Lots of ball handling mistakes on both sides and the Reds forgot at times that they did not have QC. And to the Tahs fans – lay off McKibbin. He made a mistake but he had about 30,000 people yelling different instructions at him. Guessing he will not do it again.

  • hannibal

    I dont know if anyone saw the Stormers vs Hurricanes game but after watching both the Brumbies/Force and Tahs/Reds games I started believing we’ve got a soft conference. The standard of play for a first round game by the Stormers was way above anything we’re seeing from the Australian teams right now. Offloads, accurate passes, speed, an awesome rolling maul – everything.

    I’m a tahs supporter through and through but all the Australian teams need to sharpen up to take on the teams I saw paying in that Stormers game!

    • Reds Fan 2012

      Hey Hannibal. The Reds beat every South African team last year and the Crusaders 3 times. Call your Waratahs what you like but don’t bring down the conference because your team aka TPN are nancy boys.

  • Jimbo81

    Thought Palu should have been binned in the first half – that was a disgrace!

  • Pingback: Rugby News from SportRightNow » Reds Beat Tahs in Last Minute Thriller

  • JT

    The comments here are wayyyy better than on foxsports huh.

    • Dave

      So’s the reportage.

  • Reds Fan 2012

    As my mate said he was shipperly like an eel.

Close