Review: Reds v. Waratahs – They came here to win…

Steve Timms July 14, 2012 55

No GravatarAs the Reds were arriving at Suncorp they heard the news: the Auckland Blues had done them a massive favour, beating the Brumbies and denying them a crucial bonus point. The ramifications for the Reds were that with a bonus point win, they would qualify top of the Aussie conference and earn a home final.

Would the Waratahs let this happen? Could they stop it?

From the kick-off the Reds went all-out on attack, with Higgers scoring a try in the third minute. The Waratahs had a defensive lineout 5 metres out and a loose throw went to Dave Dennis, who couldn’t collect it, the Reds got the ball and came close, then one pass later Higgers had crossed. Mike Harris added the extras.

The Waratahs got the ball from the restart, and earned a penalty shortly after. Bernard Foley put them on the board with some quick points.

The game settled somewhat from there — how could it not? The Reds showed their intent, turning down an easy penalty shot and taking the quick tap instead. That move came to an end shortly after when Saia Faingaa ignored a three-on-two overlap to try out his chip-kick. He shouldn’t have.

A looming Tahs try was foiled by some #shippsanity. The Tahs put the kick through and among the chasers were Chris Alcock and Dom Shipperley. Somehow Shippers got his foot under the ball and prevented the grounding.

From the 22 drop-out that followed, the Reds made their way up to the line and were working it hard when Paddy Ryan was yellow-carded for repeated offside while defending on the line. This made the Tahs’ job that much harder, and at the 24th minute, the Reds got their second try to Liam Gill. Mike Harris made a rare miss with the conversion attempt.

Convinced their move earlier was good, even though foiled, the Waratahs worked it again. Perhaps it was a fact that Drew Mitchell was on the spot, but this time they got the ball down. Grayson Hart missed the conversion.

Pressure-cooking in the cauldron

Then Adam Ashley-Cooper joined illustrious Waratahs from the past such as Matt Dunning by kicking a drop-goal in the last game of the season. It was a cracking kick though, just making it over the bar from 45 metres out (probably 50 on the angle). This made it a one-point ball game at 35 minutes at 12-11 to the Reds. The scored stayed the same heading into oranges.

The big question as the second half got under way was would the Reds put away the hooker-chip-kicking conservative play or throw caution to the wind and gun for the bonus point?

There was a series of three lineouts on the 5-metre line at the Waratahs’ end. We thought the lineout was a bit dodgy when the Reds tried a trademark throw to the front, resulting in Saia being taken over the line. It was clearly a plan though as the Waratahs missed the jump on their lineout and the ball was collected by James Slipper, who enjoyed the taste of his pie last week and helped himself to seconds. Harris again missed the conversion.

A loose pass from the Waratahs was put down and the Reds pounced. As he did in round 1, Dom Shipperley broke the Waratahs and Brumbies supporters hearts by scoring the fourth try and the bonus point. Mike Harris added the extras. It was now all about ensuring the win for the Reds.

Will Genia then scored the cheekiest halfback’s try in a long time. Picking the ball up from behind the scrum he darted over and got through two defenders to put the ball down in the corner. The 29-11 score line was making it beyond doubt they would be hosting a final next week.

Quade Cooper then made a bold move to reclaim his Wallaby jersey with a tackle on his opposite number, Berrick Barnes. The tackle looked tame enough, seeming to start at the shoulder and come up to the head of Barnes. Either way there was a stink, and when the dust had settled, Steve Walsh went to the pocket and Quade got a yellow and a white card. So even though a home final was booked the Reds may be without Quade.

The Waratahs used their time with an extra man to pressure the Reds’ line. Though camped down there for nearly the whole time Quade was in the bin they didn’t look like scoring, until a flying Tom Carter on the end of a three-on-two overlap got a try. Brendan McKibbin missed the conversion, leaving the score at 29-16 to the Reds with six minutes to go.

The Reds got Cooper back, and with a full 15 they were not going to let the Waratahs score last. Adam Wallace-Harrison, who had had a blinder of a match tonight (might have something to do with his appearance on the Podslam this week), went over. He was held up though, so was denied the points. The Reds had an advantage call up their sleeve and Mike Harris kicked their first penalty, making it 32-16.

The Reds wound the clock down and secured the home final. Oh yeah, and the Templeton Cup.

The biggest concern now is how the judiciary will treat Quade. Will the Reds have a full squad for their Qualifying Final?

See you all next week…

Season high (Australia) Crowd : 41 533

Official Man Of The Match: Will Genia

Reds (Try: Higginbotham, Gill, Slipper, Shipperley, Genia Con: Harris 2/5 Pen: Harris 1/1)   Waratahs (Try: Mitchell, Carter Con: Hart 0/1, McKibbin 0/1 Pen: Hart 1/1 Drop: Ashley-Cooper 1/1)

Discussion

  • pants

    Just tuned into the results and can’t believe the Reds have won the conference. Just rewards though. Thankfully they changed the system to use most wins to decide the winning team instead of points differential.

  • bill

    Congratulations on a good career in super rugby to Dean Mumm. Much maligned at times but a decent player all the same

    Well done Reds.

    • murph

      Much maligned?! He has about 30 Wallaby caps too many! Guys like AWH eat him alive and have none.

      I guess it helps if you play for the Tags and Daddy is on the ARU board.

      Brilliant that his final contribution to rugby on Australia soil was to miss an opportunity to tackle Genia by about 5 seconds

      • bill

        grow up Murph.

        • Redsfan1

          Give me a break break Bill. Dean Mumm is a bad joke. How he has ever played in the Wallabies staggers belief/ must have been a phone call from Dadyy that got him there.

      • johnny-boy

        Mumms career was ruined by Deans thinking he could convert Mumm into an international lock. He may have made a good 6 if hadn’t been stuffed around by Deans and the Tahs. Unfortunately for him he just went along with it.

        • Handles

          The sign at Suncorp said it all.

          “My Mum is better than your Mumm”.

        • johnny-boy

          Pure gold Handles :)

  • Pete

    Worth reading twice :D

    Quade’s tackle will probably see him suspended, but I htought it was barely worth the yellow, and wouldn’t have been at all if Barnes hadn’t been hurt.

    Had to be Barnes and his paperthin skull didn’t it?!

    • murph

      SANZAR will ensure he’s suspended with compliance from the Sydney-centric ARU who’re no doubt choking on their sav blanc and black caviar as we speak

      • Canuck

        sav blanc is for poor people

    • Drop kick

      Filthy tackle, filthy comment.

      • murph

        Appropriate pseudonym

        • Drop kick

          Good one Murph, that is your wittiest comment ever.

  • bill

    Quade is defending a lot more confidently, but one area where he should reign in that confidence is that flick pass to Harris, when it’s the only way to make the pass or create space for the receiver it’s a brilliant piece of skill, when it’s unnecessary it just puts the receiver under completely unnecessary pressure. Harris did well to catch that pass.

    • Alan

      it was a cracking pass though! delighted to see QC back with his bit of magic

      • bill

        I’m not, I think Quade is f*ing brilliant, and one completelyt out of the box, but that wasn’t genius, it was selfish and vain play.

        • johnny-boy

          Bill it may have been a selfish and vain play for 99.9% of rugby players but for Cooper it’s just a normal pass and not low percentage. Big raps to Harris for not being surprised by it.

        • bill

          actually I’m dead wrong. Saw a replay and Lachie Turner is crowding up close enough to maybe intercept/disrupt, so, it was the safest option to pass behind the back, maybe not the highest percentage pass but the safest.

    • Dave

      It was a great pass. It’s when he tries it when the reds are in their own 22 and they are down on the score board that puts my head in my hands.
      Also these passes are a whole lot harder to read for the defence. I reckon it gave Harris 1 or 2 extra meters out of the sheer unpredictibility of it. Harris did well to catch it.

  • Alan

    Congrads to the Reds. Few weeks back it looked like they wouldnt make it into the top 6 so to top the aussie conference is a great achievement.

    Really hope:

    1. Quade doesn’t get any ridiculous suspension. I thought the yellow was warranted but high tackles (like this one without malice) shouldn’t be on par with spear tackles and receive bans.

    2. Results go the Brumbies way. They have been pretty fantastic all year and despite taking the foot off the pedal recently id love to see them get rewarded with a play off spot

    As a Australian rugby fan 1st ahead of any provincial side, i really hope we can have two of our teams make it through

    • Westo

      Yeah mate I am with you there and I am excited and there is a high likelihood I am gonna jump on a plane and head south (from London) again to watch the finals. You beauty!

      I would love two Ozzie teams in the finals to shut the holes of the other two SANZar’s!

  • murph

    So how many Tahs players will make the Wallabies 30 man squad? 12? 15?

    • johnny-boy

      Deans will be spewing at how stupid he looks selecting Silati ‘where the bloody hell am I’ Timani instead of AWH. But then I guess it’s hard to see reality when you’ve got your head up the a ….of one of your romneys.

  • Mighty Moth

    Great win by the REDS. The Brumbies didn’t do enough to show they should even contend finals footy and did the REDS a big favour. Quade’s tackle was high, yes, but there have been some damaging high tackles this season going without further incident, begs the question, why do it to Quade? (Ref was an ex-kiwi maybe?) Waratahs were very poor again this game, especially Horne. Why is it that everyone raves about this guy, he has done nought in my opinion and come test footy time really stunted the Wallabies back lineon every occasion. If the REDS keep this up and Quade escapes this ridiculous carding they have every chance of back to back titles.

    • murph

      Horne will get picked for the Wallabies. You just watch

  • stillatragic

    Well done Reds. Worthy winners of the Australian Conference. Best is yet to come! Hope some sanity prevails regarding Quade Cooper but , hey, we are talking SANZA. Regardless, see you next week. We Are Red!!!

  • johnny-boy

    Wooooooooooohoooooooo ! Wow, wow, wow, wow wow. That’s my, that’s my, that’s my teeeamm. Woohoo ! That’s what we’re talking about ! All you Red doubters, suck it up, suck it up long and hard … and all the way down ya windpipe. Wooohooo !

  • Jimbo81

    Justice!
    Top of conference again and bees-d1ck from two in a row!
    WE ARE RED!

    • bill

      A bee’s dick hey Jimbo, I’m sure the crusaders or whoever we face next week will just obligingly bendover for you.

      • Westo

        …and bring that on, because correct me if I heard incorrectly, Brett Lee, but are the Reds 21 from 23 at Suncorp.

        If that is the case that is massive and if its not the case then call me retired?

        • The Rant

          Sharks at suncorp followed if they win with a semi against the chiefs in nz. Final either cape town or suncorp if any team beats stormers. Potentially a rematch of last year.

      • Redsfan1

        Bill grab yourself some Kleenex.

        • bill

          I presume that’s to go with my poster of the wallabies in that weird aru ad that seemed to involve a lot baby oil and really short shorts. I have no idea what they were selling , all I remember is snorting whisky through my nose thinking this is just not sending the right message.

          …now if they’d a sheep in there….

  • Kiap

    Shippsanity! Love it.

  • Bobby

    Well done boys what a Great win. I really didn’t think we could score 4 trys tonight but amazing what happens when you don’t have a shot at goal! We deserve top spot and I can see a Reds Crusaders Final at Suncorp yet again!!

    I hate the call at the game but what the hell!

    WE ARE RED!!!

  • Skip

    A ‘flying Tom Carter’??? Not words you read often.

    • Handles

      Unless he is on his way home from South Africa

      • RedMan

        I’m not sure about that. He’s probably too annoying to have in the confined space of a plane for long periods of time. They probably make him catch a boat.

        • Funk

          Any chance we can get him detained on Christmas Island?

  • Expert69

    Well done REDS, nigh on unbeatable at SUNCORP and on track for possible back to back. Cooper brill but also unstable against great teams needs to curb some habits. As for TAHS, all too familiar tale, seriously the evaluation has already occured, have to agree with Burkey’s article,and Growdens thoughts, though tempting to clean out coaching staff and making ROCKY skipper a joke with benefit of hindsight. Robinson great player but not a captain, he’s a silent quiet achiever doing the important things noone see’s in tight but as an outsider I dont see him stirring up his colleagues with venom. Hooper will be essential to get fast recycling 2013 and I suggest make him captain. Seems rash, but an outsider is the answer. I do not rate Bowen as a coach at this level and personality is questionable, he was 10 man rugby kinda player and lacks innovation in attack as a backs coach when at his disposal he has the talent and the Gaff has spent alot of time in Ireland previously so attacking innovation not his thing. Get a kiwi backs coach Tana Umaga, play with speed and discipline and ban all players from the temptations of Sydney nightlife for the season, but part of their wage goes to STILLETO’s which should allieviate theirn twitch and clean out the board of hasbeens that should really leave out of embarrassment of current association, but of course that wont happen because noone wants to go out a loser. As for HORNE, he is talented, but a massive HOG who does not play for the team (watch the WALES test series).I could go on, but CULTURAL changed a must and can be done as achieved by WHITE and MCKENZIE.

    • Westo

      You are right, but all teams a cyclical. It was only 2 years ago the Reds were bailed out $5M from the ARU.

      The Waratahs have been up there own asses for years and this wont change (Jesus, imagine if they won the thing). The Force have been bandaged since Firestone. I still don’t forgive them for 2006 anyway, but I am slowly relinquishing my hate, its more like distaste.

      You cannot beat new “quality” and “proven” coaches and players who want to play – put your hand up and clean out; or we are going to see the same ladder net year.

  • Lee Enfield

    The Reds are mirroring the Giants from the NFL last season. A late season form surge catapulted them into the playoffs and they rode that momentum all the way to a super bowl victory.
    I have a feeling that it is going to be a Red High Tide with a storm surge to back to back championships.

  • Robson

    The Brumbies getting beaten didn’t surprise me because the Blues have been threatening to put a good game on the park for a couple of weeks now. All the same I was surprised at the number of errors the Brumbies made. In a way they beat themselves.

    However the beneficaries of that were the Reds and they didn’t waste a single crumb of it. I have some difficulty in seeing how Quade is going to be suspended for his tackle on Berrick. It was high for sure, but was it really so dangerous that it deserves time off?

    I personally don’t think so and if that does happen the whole judiciary process is farce.

    On the other side of the ledger the Reds will have to play with more composure whoever they meet in the semis, because they were guilty of some harem scarem moments last night. But I loved every second of it!!

  • RJ

    QF Finals winners -, Reds, Crusaders
    Semi 1: Saders v Stormers – saders win
    Semi 2: Reds v Chiefs – Reds win
    Grand final would be at suncorp as we qualify higher than the crusaders.

    We will once again be playing the saders who will have travelled to South africa and back over two weeks.

    This title is in the bag me thinks.

    • The Rant

      Not complaining, i like conference system that ensures every country gets a finalist and at least one home play-off. but it does seem shit that we’ll get the final over the saders who technically finished higher… I’m sure they’ll complain if it does happen, and they won’t miss an opportunity to point out that the reds won the weaker conference.

      • The Rant

        ps – if you had to argue which is strongest conference, I’d say these are the main numbers to look at:
        Total comp points in each conference
        Aus: 210
        SÅ: 249
        NZ: 264

  • RJ

    Wow get on all the rugby websites. The comments are amazing. Soo many reds hating trolls. I can almost smell the fear in their posts.

  • My Blood is RED

    Hi Guys,
    Great work on website is really cool, alleviates my boredom at work.

    Just wanted to say as a true blooded reds supporter I am gutted that the brumbies didn’t make the finals.

    That is all.

  • Blinky Bill of Bellingen

    From me it’s hats off to the Reds. Well played and a well deserved win.

    As for the Tahs – What can I can say that hasn’t been said already throughout the season? We aren’t nearly good enough, so bloody fix it!

    It’s good to finally see Bernard & 10 and Berrick at 12. I choose to see potential there. Once Drew & Lachie get full match fit we will have some serious threats out wide too.

    I hope the coach brings-in an absolute fitness bastard that will see the team trim & terrific, and needing smaller jerseys for 2013.

    Go the Tahs!!!!

    • johnny-boy

      Funnily enough BBOB the Tahs look like a bloody good team when they run it but it is so unnatural and unpracticed to them they can’t keep it together for long enough. I thought Douglas and Kingston stood out last night. It would be tragic for Cooper to get suspended as well as a yellow card. Every man woman dog cat and ferret in world rugby has been bagging him to toughen up his defence and when he’s just getting the hang of it a bit of over exuberance gets him trouble. After Ioanes’ excessive penalty earlier in the year the Reds don’t deserve another excessive one. Barnes does appear to be crouching in to it a little and you can’t have a rule for soft tacklrs for those who have had head knocks. Barnes really needs to give it away. It’s probably not going to get any better for the Tahs next year and I think he would make an outstanding commentator. Intelligent no nonsense straight talker. He’d improve the profile of rugby no end compared to Marto and Kearns. Do it Fox !

      • Blinky Bill of Bellingen

        You make some astute observations johnny-boy. I was actually thinking something similar as I watched the game unfold and tear my follicles out. The expansive ball in hand doesn’t seem natural yet but I live in hope that if they persist with it and watch the good NZ teams (until their eyes bleed), that they will finally embrace the idea.
        Yep, for me Cooper’s thing was a yellow card & that’s sufficient. No malice & BB did duck down or slip or something. Hope the Reds continue to go well.
        With Barnsey I just want him to straighten the attack and stop with too much of this second 5/8 stuff. We need attack, not another chance to drop the ball with super long passes. Best leave that for teams with some ability. I think we need to look at our centre pairing as IMHO we’re even less potent than the Wallabies 12 & 13 and that’s just not good enough.

  • The Other Dave

    Maybe it was the beers last night, but the Tahs just seemed to be getting as loose as I was during the second half. Naturally I was gunning for a bonus point win for the Reds, and was therefore pretty bloody happy with last night’s events, I expected an 80-minute effort from NSW and was left wanting.

    As for the preceding match, it sucks that the Brumbies let the finals spot go in that fashion, but even if other results went their way, nobody would expect them to make it past next week on the strength of yesterday’s match. Gotta win the big matches, and while they got their arses handed to them a few times this year, the Reds are the better big game team.

  • #1 Tah

    Few small errors –
    1: Shipperly stopping Alcock was after Genia’s kick had been charged down, not Bernard Foley’s left foot grubber.

    2: Bernard Foley was kicking for goal, not Greyson Hart.

  • SonofSamo

    Great work by the Reds. Showed a ton of heart in the last few weeks. Bring it home boys!

Close