Review Reds V. Chiefs – WE’RE BACK!

Shane Sullivan May 14, 2012 49

No GravatarSunday afternoon Rugby in Brisbane is always special, but when it’s on a beautiful clear Autumn day it’s nearly perfect.

The chiefs had the early running until Liam Messams pass into the arms of Mike Harris, who scuttled off downfield attracting three defenders before passing to Dom Shipperly for the Try. Harris couldn’t convert the try but the Reds lead 5-0

All of a sudden the reds are looking dangerous! They move the ball left from the kick off and Morahan slips the tackle of Kahui  and bolts off down the eastern touch line. This time the Chiefs defence is everywhere and Morahan’s pass to Ant Faingaa goes to ground.

The Reds are looking to make metres around the Ruck and it’s working. The pick and drive from Anthony Faingaa and the forward pack is beautifully executed.

The Chiefs backs are looking very dangerous. Every time they get the ball in space their making big metres. After another big run there is a forward pass in the Reds 22. The Reds collapse the scrum and Cruden easily puts the resulting penalty kick between the posts, it’s now 5-3

The Chiefs work their way out of their half but knock on near the 40 metre line. They try to walk the scrum around the 90 deg mark but Jonkers pings them for spinning the scrum. Harris kicks the penalty to stretch the lead to 8-3

The first 20 minutes have been fairly even with the Chiefs having the better of the play but the Reds scoring more points. Both teams are looking very dangerous ball in hand.

The chiefs are dominating this period of play. They are camped deep in Reds territory and there is nothing the Reds can do to get out. This much ball and territory must surely start to tell. And it does! After a great run from Aseli Tikoirotuma Aaron Cruden takes the ball across field drawing 2 defenders and putting a perfect pass on Sonny Bill Williams chest to score under the posts. Cruden converts the try to have the score sitting at 8-10.

Liam Messam is over just 2 minutes later. After some aimless kicking Mike Harris tries to kick long for touch but the ball doesn’t make the touch line. Alex Bradley takes the kick and finds Williams who decides to run it back. He gets past James Horwill and from there quick hands beat the Reds brutal tackles to put Lelia Masaga away who sets up Messam  beautifully. The conversion is missed but the score is 8-17.

Five minutes until half time and Richard Kahui is flying down the western touchline and slips a pass to Aseli Tikoirotuma in the tackle. He falls awkwardly and appears to dislocate his shoulder. This is a huge loss for the Chiefs side and only time will tell if it makes an impact on this game.

The chiefs win the ball back from a turnover at the ruck and stream down the left flank only to be pulled up a metre from the line. Sona Taumalolo is the king of scoring from this position and barges over for his 6th try of the year! He now sits comfortably in 2nd place on the try scoring list. That’s 3 tries in 8 minutes to the Chiefs the Reds need to come up with something to stay in this game. 8-22.

The Chiefs are on top with 90 sec to play in the first half. The Reds get a penalty for obstruction from the kick off. 30 sec from half time Skipper Jame Horwill elects to go for touch! The crowd loves it, but it’s a long shot from here. Another penalty at the lineout for driving under the jumper while he’s in the air. The Reds run it as the half time hooter sounds. For the next minute they smash their bodies against the Chiefs brick wall defence until they shift the ball to Ben Lucas on the wide blind side who slips through the defence to score. Harris converts the try for a 15-22 half time score line. An amazing 13 minutes of play that has seen four tries scored and the fortunes of both teams hang in the balance.

The half time stats heavily favour the Chiefs.

  • Ruck and maul Chiefs 34-24
  • Line breaks Chiefs 6-2
  • Missed Tackles Reds 22-7
  • Turnovers Chiefs 12-9

It will take a big second half to turn the game around for the Reds.

Straight after the break the Reds score a try that will make any forward proud. Harris shoots a low hard kick off to the left that Rob Simmons regathers. No back touches the ball for the next minute and 10 sec. The Reds forwards pick and go for 40 metres until  Scott Higginbotham plants the ball over the line. Harris converts and it’s back to even scores at 22-22.

The Reds have come back from Half time with a new commitment. Greg Holmes comes on for Ben Daley who looks like he has a shoulder problem.

Will Genia decides it’s time to re-enact his heroic try from last years final. He splits Bradley and Latimer at the scrum base and sprints 50 metres through the centre of the Chiefs defence to score in the left corner. The 2 tries are so similar you could almost say only the defences jersey’s have changed. Australia’s first choice half back is back in the big time! Converted for a 29-22 lead. Both teams have now scored 3 tries in an 8 minute period!

Jake Schatz makes way for a second fetcher in Beau Robinson. Robinson makes an immediate impact with a beautiful grubber down the eastern touchline forcing Aseli Tikoirotuma to run it over the sideline. The Reds set up a maul from the lineout 5 metres from the tryline and with the help of Harris and Ant Faingaa cart the ball forward for Saia Faingaa to Score. Harris’s kicking is on song now and he nails the kick from the sideline for a 36-22 lead.

The Chiefs are desperate for tries now. They knock back 2 kicks at goal for a chance of a try. And after a long build up Aseli Tikoirotuma crosses in the corner. The reds simple ran out of defenders. Cruden shot a goal misses to the right so the score stays at 36-27 with 20 minutes to play.

Field Goal! Mike Harris slots it just inside the right post to stretch the lead to 39-27.

The Chiefs are desperate for the win now. They’re running everything back at the Reds. The Reds seem to be growing in stature as the game goes on. They are determined to stop the chiefs scoring again. Every time the Reds win the ball they are kicking it long and deep into the Chiefs half. They don’t want the New Zealanders anywhere near their try line. The Chiefs are desperate for the ball now and they push the offside line too hard and give a penalty for Mike Harris to kick. 42-27.

The Result

QUEENSLAND REDS 42

(Saia Faingaa, Will Genia, Scott Higginbotham, Ben Lucas, Dom Shipperley tries Michael Harris 4 cons 2 pens drop goal)

CHIEFS 27

(Liam Messam, Sona Taumalolo, Aseli Tikoirotuma, Sonny Bill Williams tries Aaron Cruden 2 cons pen)

Referee: Marius Jonker.

Crowd: 36,479.

The Damage

The Chiefs lost Richard Kahui with a Shoulder dislocation.

The Reds subbed Ben Daley with a shoulder problem

The Moment

We could talk about Richard Kahui’s injury. Or the Try blitz either side of half time. But for me the moment was James Horwill decision to forsake easy points and kick for the sideline and a chance at a try with 90 seconds to go in the first half. And then to score the Try. The reds went into the sheds on a high instead of thinking about the 3 try hammering they had copped in the 10 minutes preceding.

The Man

Kahui was massive until his injury. As were Sonny Bill William and Aaron Cruden. For the reds Morahan besides the tip tackle was good. Higginbotham stood out as did Liam Gill. Anthony Faingaa was massive in defence. But my vote goes to will Genia for his kicking, leadership, direction and for repeating the try from the final last year.

The Talking Point

Luke Morahan Attempts to tackle Sonny Bill Williams with about 10 minutes to go in the match. Williams tries to turn and off load in the tackle as Morahan drives through. His feet leave the ground and he lands on his shoulder. The referee’s indicate that it’s a yellow card offence but because they have no number it’s a penalty to the chiefs. Morahan plays the last 10 minutes saving 2 or 3 tries in the process.

I haven’t looked at the tackle in detail but at first glance it didn’t seem particularly bad. The question I think coming out of this situation is the role of the Television match official. It there a case for this referee to be instantly looking at foul play as soon as it is alerted to? Shouldn’t the on field referee be able to ask the off field referee for a players number and clarification of foul play? IT’s not like it’s an extra cost for SANZAR the referee and the equipment are already there!

 

 

Enhanced by Zemanta

Discussion »

  • ANON

    BEST GAME OF SEASON

    • http://landoftheunit.wordpress.com/ Sully

      You bet it was!

      • ula

        don’t mention tmo for yellow cads, it was a textbook tackle

        • Bobby

          I wouldn’t call it textbook. But it wasn’t a yellow card and really not a penalty. I really believe the tackled player needs to take more responsibility. If you watch Morahan’s hands they never lift, its Sonny Bill who twists trying to offload and he loses balance in the tackle. It actually looks like he launches. He lands on the corner of his shoulder on maybe a 45 degree angle hardly 90 or anything like that.

        • johnny-boy

          That’s a very interesting point Bobby, as to whether SBW launched himself to land on his back and milk a yellow card. I’m not sure if he did but that tactic is not too far away. The Saffas milked DIgby’s penalty for all it was worth and some team will soon wake up to the fact that if they ‘launch’ on to their back they will get a huge advantage (and yes it will probably be the Saffas who try it first) . Sanzar has made themselves look silly by coming down, over the top, on all remotely lifting tackles rather than just dangerous ones. Once again common sense comes second.

      • cantab

        yip, without a doubt! best super rugby game at suncorp..ever!! (excluding finals – apples and oranges). the only downside? I’m probably going to have to get up at 1am to watch the final now.

    • Peter Ross

      It was a cracker, but I actually enjoyed the Rebels game even more (but only just). I knew the Reds could beat the Chiefs, but the Rebels the Crusaders, never in a million years!

  • ANON

    I mean it. was superb. I enjoyed sunday rugby hugely loved it!!

  • commonasmud

    Random musings:

    Bad luck for Morahan, finally shows what he is capable of and he’s going to cop a suspension for a fairly soft infringement.

    SBW sure attracted some attention, some of the Reds (Faiinga twins prominent) tried to make a name for themselves by cleaning him up with a big hit, didn’t come off, SBW too physical and too spatially aware for that. TPN-like efforts like that instead let their fellow defenders down.

    Kahui – a classy player, great shame for him. Chiefs frontrow VERY intimidating. Otherwise, the Chiefs pack worst performance of the year?

    Genia is back! Gill is a machine, great to watch. Lucas, Harris & Shipperley are playing their way into the wallabies squad.

    Sunday arvo rugby? When your 4-yr old boy arrives home from the game chanting ‘we are Red!’ you know it’s been a great day!!!

  • murph

    David Rennie has said that a yellow card would have been an injustice. Good on David Rennie! Morahan’s tackle was clean. The momentum caused Williams to lose his footing which resulted in him falling backwards uncontrolled. There was no malice, nor was there technically anything wrong with Morahan’s tackle. This incident highlights how officiously ludicrous the policing of “tip tackles” as become. We saw Digby Ioane get 5 weeks(!) because Marcel Coetzee leapt into the tackle, thereby falling backwards upon contact.

    • Dave

      Whole heartedly agree. Sometimes there is malice intent but his was clearly not one of those times. The cause of a tackle that goes past the horizontal should be considered, that is, both intent and momentum of the tackled player. Seriously, bring him to ground safely!!?? You can’t ask a tackler to defy physics.

      But anyway, great inspiring win by the Reds. I don’t know what was said at half time but whatever it was they should bottle it.

  • mrtimms

    News just in, Luke Morahan has been given an off field yellow card, no suspension.

    I think that’s fair. Was a good sold tackle that only went bad because SBW was swiveling looking for an offload.

    • Red Kev

      What is an off field yellow card?
      Does that mean the Reds start with 14 against the Lions (probably the best team to do that against)? Or does it just go on Morahan’s record and count against him for future citings?

      • http://www.timmsonline.com Steve Timms

        Just goes on the record. Would count when x number of yellows are needed for an automatic ban, etc.

        • Train Without A Station

          When the ref said it would have been a yellow card I thought what a crock. But in the context of other tackles and suspensions I wouldn’t have considered us hardly done by. Good to get off though after Digby’s 5 weeks. Evens the ledger a little.

        • Jay

          There’s no such system in Super Rugby though is there? The only thing I can imagine it might count for is if a player found guilty by the judiciary, it might be of some relevance in determining the severity of their sentence.

        • Garry

          and what is a white card? the difference?

          was it a nice way of the powers at be saying the ref got it wrong?

  • billybobv

    I’m not a Red’s fan, but after watching their past couple of games, I think Horwill is easily the best team captain in the competition.

    • Muffy

      If you try harder, you will be…

  • Gallagher

    Horwill, Gill, Genia and Morahan where EPIC!

    SBW deserved that slam tackle from Morahan, after putting Shipperlys face into the ground with his fist after tacking him earlier in the game, such a tool.

    • murph

      Agreed. The commentators had their tongues fair down the front of SBWs shorts too.

      • Joker

        That must have made it hard for him to run…

      • RedMan

        Why is it that every journo, commentator, ground announcer or even the person giving out the programs is obsessed with SBW? I heard the Chief’s referred to as the Sonny Bill William’s Chiefs – when did he start sponsoring them?

        • Dave

          He is pretty talented. But I agree the adoration is out of proportion.

    • SW

      SBW is a grade A muppet – and the Shipperly face grind was case in point. Hope he goes back to league.

  • RedMan

    I think Horwill’s decision to kick for the corner rather than take the three points must have come from him reading the article on here last week. He knew that the Chiefs are likely to infringe in defense, so keep the pressure on them and attack.

  • Tim

    Great win by the Reds. 19 out of the Chiefs 27 points were scored in those 8 mins so there is potential for improved concentration throughout the game but they regrouped and pulled it back quickly. Great to see other members of the team step up when Digby had a quiet night by his standards.

  • commonasmud

    Sully, I forgot to add: I saw the real hallmark of a Reds turnaround yesterday – Rod Davies made an effective one-on-one tackle. I really saw it. Grassed the bugger, and didn’t even need a grown-up’s help. Almost spilt my beer (almost).

  • Packy

    Late in the first half with the Reds ruck near the tryline, the crowd is quiet and tense Genia looks to the long backline on his right and a bloke in aisle 319 screams WRONG WAY and Genia goes left to Ben Lucas and he scores. That was the moment
    Link find that bloke and get him on the sidelines as a waterboy he called the ref on a few cockups too

  • Justtacklehim

    I liked so many aspects of that game but I loved that the reds attacked on the fringes of the Chiefs ruck and exposed them consistently.
    McKenzie must have viewed some Chiefs games and spotted a weakness that was beautifully exploited.

  • Jimbo81

    Reds won’t drop a game from here. Just beat the best at their best – there are none better. Title defended!

    • Red Kev

      My god if that happens the whinging across the ditch will be deafening.

    • RedMan

      First win in Auckland, then held the Crusaders try-less in Christchurch and then scored five tries against the top-of-the-table Chiefs. All no easy feats.

      Things do appear to be finally coming up Milhouse for the Reds.

      • Jay

        To be fair, winning in Auckland is kind of an easy feat this season. Unless you’re the Blues.

      • Joker

        Lets just hope they don’t break anything else, like their sports goggles.

  • Bobby

    Took my 1, 4 and 5 year old to their first game. I thought they would be bored and be very annoying but boy did they have a blast. Best thing was my lovely wife has to eat her words. My 1 year old son has never been that excited. (kind of like his dad)

  • Redslug

    Well for me the Chiefs looked a little put out by the little kids playing in their sandpit and seemed to be niggled by them and just to show them who was boss scored 3 tries “so there” and when the Reds came back seemed to look they where shown up by the end. The Reds showed them who’s sandpit it really was! Go The Reds!

  • the realist

    Definitely the game of the season and I am not easily entertained!

    Great to see such an inspring come-back and fantastic to see so many reds players playing their best rugby but in particular Genia who is the keyest of key ingredient for wallabies success.

    Although I am personally not a fan of reds fans, I am indeed a huge fan of the reds when they play attractive, intelligent, bold and solid rugby, not just the fairy floss stuff they’ve been trying to play with moderate success this season until now. The backs will look after the point scoring but it is the forwards at the breakdown and the set piece that needed to step up and I think the key is young Gill and Schatz seemingly cementing their spots finally as i’ve thought they should for 12 or so months ahead of Robinson/Samo. I think this weekends performances of the rebels, red and even the tahs, plus the brumbies of course bodes well for the wallabies, which I think is the whole point of this nonsense aka super xv. from the force we’ll take pocock and sharpe but the rest of them….

    • commonasmud

      Great to have you here Realist. You might not be a fan of Reds fans but believe me, we Reds fans cannot get enough of your work.

  • Brax

    One of the most satisfying aspects for me (other than the awesome way they won) was the bogan Chiefs supporters total silence in the 2nd half. They even stopped booing “Aussie Mike” when he was lining up kicks for goal.

    • RedMan

      Watching them get up and leave with 10 minutes still to go was also quite satisfying.

      • Joker

        They had to go home and iron their highlanders jerseys and practice their dunedin accents.

  • Garry

    Great to see Poopers Cooper running the water, but the way the backs clicked is their room for him?

  • johnny-boy

    Hanson is playing great. A real physical presence but he’ll have to keep on his toes cos gee those Faainga boys make a difference to a team in enthusiasm and totally fearless inspirational committment. Gold. I love Horwill’s angry firing up. That’s exactly what Aussies need. None of this wishy washy I’m only here for the paycheck, passion is overrated Gregan copout. Scahtz is coming along real nicely too, starting to make a bit more impact each game but he’s got his work cut out keeping Beau at bay. The pressure for positions at the Reds is getting intense. Great stuff. Lucas would have to be the unluckiest if he gets dropped for Cooper. He’s starting to play so damn well it would almost be an injustice, freak tho Cooper is. Best to keep Cooper warm until after the break methinks. Just to be sure because he’s sure to test the boundary and beyond. Perhaps Cooper could go to fullback ? I’m still not sold on Morahan as fullback but it’s no doubt great experience for his wingin. Or Harris at fullback, Cooper at 10 and Lucas at 12 til Tapaui comes back. Backups will get plenty of game time in this brutal comp. Shipperly still has more work to do making breaks rather than just finishing them off. It’s not often Ioane has a quietish game. Actually I hope he keeps a lid on it against the Lions and then explodes after that. And Daley seemed to slip back in to his bad habit of not keeping his back dead straight at scrums. Old habits die hard I guess. Thrilled to see Genia starting to run again. More of that and what surprising pace. Unleash the beast. The Chiefs were at times very very good. Reminded me of the Reds at thier peak last year. Fast, clinical, slick but the Chiefs went to sleep, looking like stunned mullets when they have it stuck up em, as they do :). Onya Chiefs, so dependable.

    • bill

      I think Gregan was right. I don’t think he lacked passion for the game he just wasn’t sentimental about it, I’d say he followed Muhammad Ali’s attitude ‘the bout is won long before the fight, out on the road when no one else is around’ or words to that effect.

      Where do you get the paycheck business? The guy played 130 odd tests for us. I’m thinking his passion didn’t evaporate with the oxygen debt, he just didn’t need to emote it on twitter.

  • bill

    My favourite moment of the match? Well it wasn’t the 40m pick and drive score which was the pivot for mine. It was a little later, I think Harris was trying to help Sonny Bill up or something and SBW reacted badly, the look of hurt on Harris’s face like a kid who’s asked for an autograph from their idol only to be abused. Well it wasn’t that either, it was Harris’s response, next time they met he smashed him in the tackle to force a knock on from SBW. Great stuff.

    Btw why all the hate for SBW? Maybe people are just afraid of him, I thought he had a pretty decent game aside from that attitude to Harris. Didn’t see the Shipperly thing. He’s struck me as being pretty down to earth in the interviews I’ve seen him in.

    • Dave

      Have to go back and look at that Harris incident. Sounds like a highlight to be sure. The Shipperly thing is a non event. Happens 10 times a game, 20 times in league.

      Since we are doing favourite parts of the game. For mine it was the build up to Higger’s try at the beginning of the second half. Perfect execution derived from accurate analysis. The coaching staff obviously saw something there and the Reds exploited it perfectly. So gratifying.

      I don’t understand the hate for SBW either. He’s a talented player – I would have thought that is obvious. I think there is a touch too much attention placed on him though. His manager, Khoder Nasser pushing his boxing does make him look a little self serving and fickle. The initial appearance of which wasn’t helped by his surreptitious jump to rugby from league, not to mention his switch to the chiefs, and now Nasser is speaking of the Stormers and Tolouse being an option for one year because they’ll allow him to pursue his boxing. Then there’s the talk of heading back to league or going off to Japan. All of this makes him look disloyal – motivated only by money and not the love of the game. Not something that many find endearing.

      Most of this is the work of Nasser but Williams has to bear the brunt of the negative public opinion that will inevitably come his way. I imagine the moment will come when he turns down the AB jersey and the NZ public will turn on him too. It won’t be because he’s isn’t, like you say, down to earth or a likeable individual – but more due to the fact the marketing machine that Nasser has created flies in the face of values that the rugby going public traditionally hold.

      • commonasmud

        agreed – SBW did have a decent game. The simultaneous hit-and-steal on Harris was a beaut. He’s clearly put his head down and is working hard at his game, not just relying on the party-tricks he brought with him.

        The face grind? Who cares. Got the crowd going when they replayed it on the big screen, and I’m sure all it did was fire Shipperley up. Take it as a compliment – he must have stung him if he could be bothered to pause to deliver a good old fashioned facial.

  • bill

    This game reminded me of the corresponding fixture in 2009? where the chiefs put 50 past us. Same little warnings we need to do better. They looked really good in the backs and their attack.

Close