Review: Stormers survive as Rebels go out swinging

Stuart Fazakerley July 15, 2012 5

No GravatarThe Stormers finished the Super Rugby season on top of the table with a 26-21 win against the Melbourne Rebels overnight. They were, however, made to work for it by a Victorian team who tried everything to send captain Stirling Mortlock out a winner.

As the sole Melbourne correspondent amongst the GAGR alumni, and one of few in the ‘professional’ realm, I see it as my duty to occasionally put balanced reporting aside in order to pump up the Rebels’ tyres a bit. Therefore, I have written about how impressed I have been with several performances this year, whether or not they resulted in wins, because I can see how critical those performances are to the team’s development.

Forget all of that, because this, my friends, was not only my favourite Rebels match to watch, but will sit as one of their formative performances as they move on to bigger and better things. You see, nobody had given the visitors much of a chance to get close to the rampaging Stormers, whose textbook defence had seen away bigger threats than the Rebels with relative ease.

Indeed, it looked like history repeating for the hosts early in the match, with hooker-cum-breakaway Deon Fourie having an immediate impact from kick-off, earning a penalty. The Stormers got to within five metres of the line from another penalty advantage, and would have touched down if not for a handling error. When the penalty was called back, the hosts pointed to the sticks, and Peter Grant made no mistake for a 3-0 lead.

The Rebels managed a few minutes of attack but ceded to the Stormers again. Jono Owen conceded a penalty at the breakdown and Grant lined up again. He was successful and the hosts had a 6-0 lead after 8 minutes.

The Rebels were shaken, but by no means out of the match, and, as against the Lions last week, would have had more success if not for simple errors at lineouts and when running with the ball. They had started to run into some momentum when Bryan Habana received the ball from a break and rocketed over the line. The referee sent it upstairs to check the grounding and found that Habana had not grounded it correctly. The Stormers had a second chance through a penalty for not releasing, and Juan de Jongh snuck through the defence for the first try of the match. Peter Grant added the conversion and the hosts were out to a 14-0 lead.

Here’s where my point of why this was a watershed moment for the Rebels starts to crystallise. Towards the end of the half the visitors had their fair share of chances to kick for points. They took none of them, each time deciding to kick for position and attack the line. It was the kind of ruthless, back-yourself-in attack that the Rebels should have done more of this year, if only to build some confidence in their own abilities.

This strategy was initially fruitless, the Stormers defence proving too tight for even the best Rebel attack. The hosts rubbed some extra salt in the wound after the half time siren, Peter Grant slotting his third penalty and giving the Stormers a 16-0 lead at the half.

The Rebels continued their stuff-it-let’s-have-some-fun strategy in the second half, and started to see the results immediately. They made huge ground immediately through a darting Lachlan Mitchell, and controlled the ball brilliantly in the next phase with a maul, earning a penalty from a Stormers transgression in the process.

The Rebels kicked for touch and won the lineout. Hugh Pyle came off the maul and reached for the line, falling just short. Rodney Blake received next and made no mistake, putting the ball down for the visitors’ first try. Julian Huxley converted and the score was 16-7.

Minutes later, the little club that just might silenced Newlands, with the Rebels on the attack immediately and quickly found themselves within five metres of the line. Nick Phipps recovered the ball from a ruck and performed a feat rarely seen this season: easily finding a gap in the Stormers’ line. With his try the visitors had two majors in four minutes, and with Julian Huxley‘s conversion, the Rebels were within two points of the ladder leaders, 16-14.

The Stormers would not be treated this way on their home turf for long, it seemed, as Habana regained the ball from the restart and the hosts hammered the Rebel line. They wore down the visitors and eventually found the line when Juan de Jongh crossed for his second. Grant added the conversion and put the lead back out to nine points, 23-14.

The Stormers held the ascendancy until the last ten minutes, when replacement Rebels scrumhalf Nic Stirzaker broke the line and popped a pass to James Hilgendorf. The stand-in number 10 floated a pass to Cooper Vuna who put the ball down in the corner for the Rebels’ third try. Julian Huxley converted and gave the Rebels the unlikeliest of sniffs at 23-21, two points down with just minutes to go.

The hosts turned up the pressure late in the game, looking to seal a win that should never have been in doubt. De Jongh came close to getting a hat-trick but his run ended short of the line. After a few phases in penalty advantage, the Stormers looked to have driven their captain over the line, but it was referred to the TMO. Five camera angles later it seemed that while Mark Gerrard‘s tackle may not have definitely saved the try, it had certainly obscured the vision enough to cast doubt in the TMO’s mind.

The home team took the kick at the penalty’s callback and Grant kicked his fourth, extending their margin to five, where it would stay.

It was a great game, bookmarked by the skill and showmanship of the Stormers, and the guts and resilience of the Rebels, but the highlight for me was the efforts the Stormers went to after the match to congratulate Stirling Mortlock, including presenting him with a signed No. 12 Stormers jersey — a gesture that smacked of class.

Stirling may not have been sent out a winner, but considering the effort his Rebels put in, and the potential they showed against the benchmark in the competition, he would have said goodbye a very proud man.

STORMERS 26
Tries: Juan de Jongh 2
Penalties: Peter Grant 4/4
Conversions: Peter Grant 2/2

MELBOURNE REBELS 21
Tries: Rodney Blake, Nick Phipps, Cooper Vuna
Penalties: None taken
Conversions: Julian Huxley 3/3

HALF TIME: STO 16-0 MEL

What did you think of this match? Was it the stumble the Stormers had to have? What are the Rebels building to?

Discussion »

  • RyanP

    Great to see the Rebels put up a fight to the last minute with a host of original players. Gerrard and Huxley gave their farewells in a champion fashion and Stirlo was farewelled as the great exponent of the game that he has always been. What a legend!

  • Jimbo81

    Stormers can b beaten!

  • wiggety

    Great write up Stu. I am curious to know what would have been the score line if the Rebels had taken shots at goal when in range?

  • Peter Robson

    I don’t normally stay up and watch games from SA live but having lived the highs and lows of rugby all day since 3.30 I decided I would – and thank goodness I did.

    I agree with Stuart – just about the best the Rebels have played all year, except for once again having to overcome a flakey start. I too have done the “what if” scenario on the penalty shots not taken, and if they had gone over we could have won, but perhaps the Stormers would have been a little less complacent at the start of the second half. I do think they should have taken the shots in the first half – there was a game to won against the toughest defence in the competition – but hey, who cares now. We took three points out of the African tour – many have done much much worse.

    By my count we are losing nine players now ( and with Cipriani already gone thats 10 from what we started the season with) and we have gained one – Jono Owen. For Stirlo, Al Campbell, Adam Freier and Lipdog – all things must pass: good luck and many thanks for the last two years. There are a couple I am not unhappy to lose, but the one I do regret us losing is Mark Gerrard. He has been in my top five players for the last two years and he will be greatly missed. He can come back anytime. Also many thanks and farewell to Harold MItchell – we would not be here without you. I look forward to farewelling them all at the WDC lunch on Thursday.

    So far I have only heard of one recruit, albeit a very good one in Higgenbotham. We desperately need a world class tighthead and number 7. But please no Waratah’s rejects (especially backs) next year.

    Some final reflections on the last full day of Super Rugby this year: commiseration Brumbies – your still my second team; the best rugby of the weekend was the first half of the Hurricanes – Chiefs game until the touchie nearly screwed the Canes with the yellow card; and finally yet another out of touch touchie – Mark Lawrence stepping in and awarding (yet another) penalty against Jono Owen for “slapping” someone, with the Rebels with a scum feed after the siren deep in Stormer’s territory – who knows what may have been. (I resist the temptation to bring up the subject of non- neutral officials).

    Go Rebels!

  • andy sm

    One thing not commented on yet was the appalling reffing in the first half. So many examples but the worst was the stormers not being pinged for the mall on their tryline. Then the rebs pinged twice for the same missed offense (coming around the side).

Close