Shute Shield Finals Week Two

Jack Norton September 27, 2010 16

No GravatarSaturday 25/9

Randwick 23 – 21 Eastwood

Wicks

They scraped into finals contention in sixth spot, and now Randwick are heading to the Shute Shield grand final after defeating Eastwood yesterday.

Despite leading 10-3 at oranges, Eastwood never looked like shutting the ‘Wicks out of the game in what was a disappointing end for the minor premiers.

Both teams had Wallabies in their ranks, although those in green were most conspicuous, with Rocky Elsom in Randwick colours after a six-year absence.

Elsom’s absence showed early on, as there seemed to be some confusion about his role and what lines he was meant to be running.

Eastwood had done their homework on Elsom and he was allowed minimal space by their defenders, while the best Wallaby (and player) on the field was one of their own, Lachie Turner.

Turner scored both of Eastwood’s tries and looked much more a team-member than a ring-in due to his significant game time with the ‘Woodies this year.

Kurtley Beale looked dangerous with the ball-in-hand for the Greens, but also proved handy with the boot; kicking a penalty goal from outside halfway in his only place-kicking attempt of the match.

Woollahra Oval’s similarities to Bloemfontein ended with the 50m kick. The ground was in poor condition and the sandy surface may have contributed to the high injury toll for the match.

Mark Chisholm’s chances of joining the EOYT squad in October were dealt a blow when he was forced from the field with a knee injury.

Commonwealth Games squad member Nick Cummins also went off and Eastwood number eight Locky McCaffrey suffered a dislocated and broken ankle in the opening minutes.

Sekope Kepu once again proved his worth in open play, consistently crossing the advantage line and contributing strongly to another punishing performance by the Randwick pack.

Eastwood’s backs appeared threatening in isolation but the ‘Wicks backline had a better platform thanks to their forwards, helping them grind out victory in a tense final spell.

Sunday 26/9

University 36 – 20 Southern Districts

Carter, fist clenched, ready for action

History will repeat itself next weekend when University face Randwick in the Shute Shield grand final. Uni offered a clinical effort against a spirited but outgunned Southern Districts today.

The Students were superior in technique and fitness but were always under threat from Souths, who had the ball on the University line for extended periods in both halves, but let themselves down with handling errors and penalties.

To say that the game was lost for the Hobbits by their own hand would not give full credit to the discipline of the Students, who out-thought Souths at crucial times.

Souths hit back against Uni in the 62nd minute with a Kane Douglas try, the student’s lead was reduced to six, if only for a minute. In less than 60 seconds, Lachie Mitchell returned fire for the Students.

This took the score from 26-20 to 33-20, which Uni quickly added to with a fifth Berrick Barnes penalty in 72nd minute.

In the latter stages of the game Souths were awarded several penalties in front of the goals but were unable to take the easy kicks, needing tries for victory.

As at Woollahra yesterday, the surface of University Oval was sandy and poor; possibly contributing to this weekend’s high injury toll.

Uni prop (and Arena Sports Centre hero) Jerry Yanuyanutawa was stretchered off late in the first half with a suspected dislocated ankle.

His absence was noted, especially in the scrum where Dan ‘Pot plant’ Palmer asserted dominance over big Jerry’s replacement, Paddy Ryan.

While the Hobbits were strong in the scrum and in general play thanks to their pack, their backs lacked direction in the face of aggressive Uni defence, a problem that worsened as the game progressed and the Students’ greater fitness showed.

Once again we face the prospect of seeing the Shute Shield continue to gather dust in Uni’s trophy cabinet unless Randwick can defy history and take it down the road to Coogee.

Is six in a row inevitable for the Students?

Discussion »

  • Blinky Bill from Bellingen

    Maybe it was just me wanting underdogs Souths to win and prove, despite not playing on a neutral ground and without ‘stars’, that sport as in life surprises are possible. Sadly not to be.

    No doubt Uni were well structured, skillful, composed, deserved their win etc but there were several moments there that I thought an unlikely win for Souths may just occur. But then a knock-on or two got missed and a penalty for not releasing (which I thought should have gone the way of Souths) was awarded to Uni and that was all she wrote.

    A highly enjoyable game to watch played at a cracking pace with lots of good hits. Well done Uni. Hard luck Souths. Thanks also to the ABC crew for bringing it to my loungeroom.

  • topo

    Dan Palmer didn’t pack down against Paddy Ryan. Ryan went to THP and Tilse moved to LHP to pack down against Palmer. I thought the Souths scrum was clearly on top early but faded as the match went on. Their inability to get something out of 3 5m scrums just before half time was a critical moment in the match. Nic Henderson was replaced early by Tetera Faulkner as well ?injury.

    • Jnor

      Way to make me look bad! I was at the game and the disadvantage of that was you do miss some of the more important changes.

      Having said that it shows pot plant’s skills in the scrum that he had it over Tilse as well. And Uni’s greater fitness definitely showed all round the park, as I said

  • geraldo mifiadini

    At the ground yesterday and a number of things stood out.

    1. Berrick Barnes was head and shoulders above everyone else, jinking runs and passes leading to two Uni tries, impeccable goalkicking and passing. I maintain he is more a RWC Finals 5/8 than Cooper, who will get you points but leak you many. We dont need a passenger in defence, which Barnes is certainly not, so QC get your D together or I want Berrick. In any case, barnes in the final 20-30 mins of the RWC final matches please.

    2. Second to Barnes, Kane Douglas, who should have been in the mix this year given the front five development policy in 2010. He would have stood out to Deans yesterday and with Chizz (the scrum doctor) being injured, looks as though Simmons and Doublas will battle it out to partner Sharpe in Europe. Mumm to 6 please – too small, should be on bench covering 6/8/4 in 2011. Third place – Peter Betham who will do well with the Rebels next year.

    3. Dan Palmer – best scrummager on the park – wtf did NSW let him go? Surely given his strong 2009 form he should have been given more park time than Al Baxter this year. Jerry Y is a crap scrummager, Paddy Ryan has potential. Tilse, 6 seasons with the Tahs…..puhlease.

    4. McCalman – not particularly large human being, other than his head. Tough as old nails, never turned over ball in running, but simply not a beast at this stage. Gymnasium please.

    5. Uni Wingers – Jedoulev (Oz U20s), Mitchell (Wasps, Rebels) – both super quick, but unfortunately, super super small, which does not add up to Super Rugby. Jedoulev should play for Russia in the next RWC. It would please some oligarchs who will fall in love with rugby after RWC and inject cash into their domestic game and Euro clubs in the near future. Other than the Krauts and the (real) Dutch and perhaps the Nigerians, there is no country with greater rugby potential.

    6 – Miscellaneous – Carter remains a petulant cunt – shoot him (this is from an Ex Uni player). Southos 13 looked good – Kairaru-Henry (sp?), although likely to see time with a 14 on his back for the Tahs.

    • dew-1

      14 on his back for the Tahs? They have the most stable back three in Super Rugby. Turner, Mitchell and Beale.

  • Aussie D

    Disappointed for Souths and to a lesser extent Eastwood, but hopefully with the extended season next year in S15 it will make Shute Shield more equitable with Wallabies / S15 starters unavailable until later in the season.

    I know that all the teams in the finals are close to the city but it would have been good to take the semis this weekend and last out to Western Weekender in Penrith which seems to have a better playing surface and would have guaranteed ground neutrality for all the teams involved.

  • geraldo mifiadini

    In addition, Tom Carter seems to have a vocabulary of two, one word starting with “C” and one starting with “F”. These words are applied in unison, not necessarily in that order and at a volume several decibels higher than my kiddies ears and probably 95% of other onlookers, would have appreciated.

    I wonder if anyone at the NSWRU (for obvious reasons not the ARU) could have a suitably voluminous word in Toms ear to stop acting like a fucking cunt and shut the fuck up. Or just tear the talentless pricks contract up?

    • Jnor

      Old TC seems to get a lot of people riled up around here.

      As I’ve said in the forum by all acounts he is a top bloke in person even if he is a bit niggly and a stirrer on the field.

  • Homer J

    Would like to see Plamer and Kepu bookend a scrum together, two big units.

    I still don’t see why Slipper got all the attention ahead of Plamer in selections, to me they are very similar and both superior to Maafu. Plamer does need to be more mobile around the field but he does look like your traditional hard scrummaging prop which is what the Walla’s need.

    Well done to Uni but it does feel like a bought victory. Plus the constant drone of the Uni crowd chanting away at the ‘neutral venue’ showed how much of a home game it was for Uni, despite Barnes saying it was his first game there (he must be a uni die hard).

  • geraldo mifiadini

    Palmer is significantly better scrummager than either Maafu or Slipper. Slipper is better around the park, but gawd blimey who has Palmer pissed off … ???

    Incidentally Homer, Kepu is significantly larger than Palmer. Thanks OK, Andrew Blades was a midget and he would walk into my Wobbly team today as THP.

  • geraldo mifiadini

    ….and yes, from an ex-uni player once again, i think theyve taken the piss on educational front. Some of the jokers they let in for academic purposes to play rugby raise an eyebrow. No names, no pack drills but ex Gold Coast parking police who now may or may not be Wobblies forwards coach slotting in for a Masters Of Commerce with no undergrad….?????

    Same thing (probably worse) happens in cricket with the likes of Rod Davidson who is, er, not a rocket scientist, being let in. Rod I think you will agree with that assessment and so will Stuart MacGill.

  • topo

    OK, I’ve said it before, and no doubt I’ll be saying it again. At least Uni get these guys in from Colts and develop them from there. Randwick had nothing to do with Beale, Mitchell, Cummins, Elsom, Kepu, the new hooker, Mowen and others’ development. We got lucky with BB, but he picked Uni, not the other way around.Pretty much everyone else has been there since school. And the venue wasn’t Uni’s fault, they simply put in a tender for a semi and the cards fell where they fell.

  • Ched

    What a load of rubbish, Uni don’t produce anyone. The extent of their production is to turn up to the season ending rugby carnivals and offer scholerships to all the Aus Schoolboys players who no doubt were produced and paid for by the smaller clubs and schools through their development from juniors to teenagers. Then if other players exceed at other clubs they come in and pinch them before they hit grade.

    Uni’s contribution to junior rugby in Australia is paying for Canturbury RC’s jerseys and that’s it. Rugby nursery ground my arse.

    Furthmore, the tender system isn’t luck. It means the teams with more money and influence in NSWRU get the biggest games which brings in more money for their clubs. The two games on the wk shoulg have been at T.G. Milner and Foreshore Park respectively as eastwood and souths finished 1st and 2nd. It would also help out smaller clubs who do more for the game financially.

    • topo

      So you seriously think a player’s development stops when they leave school?

      • Ched

        no, but uni don’t really contribute to the development of top players. Most of the guys playing S15 come out of school and train in NSW/ACT academies and so fourth whilst at Club. Sure some will benefit from playing and training at Uni. But let’s not kid ourselves, all the player they ‘poach’ are already on the ARU’s radar well before they join Uni. How many Uni players have come from obscurity? Unless you play Aus/ NSW Schools or GPS equivalent you won’t get near 4th grade colts.

        Your right, it’s not their fault but who controls NSW rugby union? Uni and Randwick. Go figure….

        Your also right about Randwick. They are cats when it comes to poaching talent from other clubs. Difference is, Uni are better and ‘smarter’ when it comes to doing it.

        Overall I think it’s a shame how the comp has developed. Look at the junior competitions, Parra, Wests, Eastwood, Warringah. These clubs are winning and producing great talent. They say there is a gap in rugby development in Western Sydney. I disagree. Look at all the GPS/CAS schools recruitment now days. Look at newingtons 1st XV this year. top team but not really authentic. The same can be said for schools like Joey’s and Kings. I guarantee when these schools look to pump their rugby stocks up year in year out they are looking west. I went to a school like this and their success was purely based on that premis.

        It would be fantastic to see a club like Parra come back and win the comp. Or Wests for that matter. But the reality is as soon as the talent they produce ‘come of age’ they will be playing in green or blue and gold.

  • topo

    Yeah, fair enough. But blame NSWRU not Syd Uni. It’s their system.

Close