Sunwolves too strong for Rebels - Green and Gold Rugby
Melbourne Rebels

Sunwolves too strong for Rebels

Sunwolves too strong for Rebels

The Rebels ventured to Fukuoka to kick off their celebratory tenth season in Super Rugby.

Going into the match Rebels fans would have been hopeful that the celebration will culminate in an inaugural finals campaign.

Whilst the Sunwolves started what, unfortunately, is to be their last season in Super Rugby. This is disappointing considering the impact the Rugby World Cup had in Japan. Alas the “Moondogs”, as they are affectionately known by some, was probably likely to fail from the start because the JRFU were unable to obtain the buy-in of the Top League teams (and ultimately Japan’s biggest companies). Anyway, I digress, back to the game at hand.

The story of this game was that the Sunwolves out enthused the Rebels. They were crisper in attack, were stronger in defence and were able to exploit some holes in the Rebels’ defence. Sorry Rebels fans, I know it is early, but this year it doesn’t look like the Rebels will break their finals duck either.

First half

James Dargaville knocked on during the first carry after the kick-off. Frank Lomani ran from the back of the scrum inside the Sunwolves’ 22 finding Matt To’omua who threw an inside ball to Andrew Kellaway. Unfortunately, for the Rebels, Kellaway was isolated and his first touch in a Rebels jersey resulted in a penalty to the Sunwolves for Kellaway not releasing the ball.

For a number of minutes, both sides exchanged possession, with the Rebels losing two lineouts against their throw. The Sunwolves gained some good ground with a chip kick over the top, which went into touch 10 metres out from the Rebels line.

The Sunwolves were attacking just inside the Rebels’ half, a lovely short ball from Sunwolves’ scrumhalf Rudy Paige to winger Siosaia Fifita who gained 30 metres. The Sunwolves then took the ball from one side of the field to the other after a good run by Kotaro Yatabe. Ben Te’o threw the final pass to Keisuke Moriya, who strolled over virtually untouched to open the scoring. Five-eighth Garth April’s conversion attempt hit the upright and was unsuccessful. After ten minutes, the Sunwolves led 5 nil.

The Rebels showed their first promising signs from a lineout just inside the Sunwolves half. Lomani passed to To’omua who then found Kellaway, Kellaway stepped back inside and gained 20 metres. Dane Haylett-Petty put in a grubber kick which Marika Koroibete chased through. Fifita defused the situation five metres out from the Sunwolves’ line.

Sunwolves co-captain and former Rebel Jake Schatz was penalised for being off his feet at the ruck on his defensive 22. Matt To’omua put the Rebels on the board with a successful penalty goal.

The Sunwolves received a penalty for Dane Haylett-Petty knocking the ball down. The Sunwolves received a second penalty for side entry following an attacking lineout. Georgian hooker Jaba Bregvadze scored from a driving maul from the second lineout. April converted to give the Sunwolves a 12 – 3 lead after 20 minutes.

The Rebels earned a penalty at a Sunwolves scrum and the kick for touch by Reece Hodge saw the Rebels 10 metres out. The Rebels employed their own driving maul and Anaru Rangi broke away from the maul to match his counterpart hooker’s try. To’omua’s conversion missed and the Sunwolves were leading 12 – 8.

A box kick from Lomani that went on the full gave the Sunwolves good field position. From the line out on the right wing on the 22. A brilliant long ball by Keisuke Moriya to left winger Tautalatasi Tasi, saw Tasi run 25 metres down the wing to score. April converted from the sideline to give the Sunwolves a 19-8 lead.

Isi Naisarani earned a penalty for the Rebels with strength over a defensive ruck. After a sloppy line out, good runs from Angus Cottrell, Reece Hodge and Matt Philip gave the Rebels some momentum. Then strength from Billy Meakes to stand in the tackle and offload to captain Dane Haylett-Petty for Haylett-Petty to score. To’omua’s conversion hit the upright and the Sunwolves lead was 19 to 13.

Garth April added a penalty goal to make the score 22 – 13. With the Rebels attacking five metres out Matt Philip was penalised for illegally taking a Sunwolf out at the ruck.  Half time Sunwolves were leading 22 – 13.

Second half

There was a high octane start to the second half. Rob Leota, To’omua, Meakes and Haylett-Petty were involved in spreading the ball to the right wing to Andrew Kellaway. Kellaway put in a chip and chase that looked dangerous for the Sunwolves. James Dargaville had other ideas, collecting the ball on the wing, being too quick for Cottrell and running 55 metres down the wing for another Sunwolves’ try. April added the extras to extend the lead to 29 – 13.

A good run from Reece Hodge saw the Rebels earn a penalty for the Sunwolves being off their feet in midfield 25 metres out. The Rebels earned another penalty when the Sunwolves collapsed the maul. From the second lineout, the Rebels were penalised for a truck and trailer at the maul.

The Sunwolves won a penalty at a scrum but didn’t find touch. Marika Koroibete put in his application to be a circus acrobat with a mid-air dive, catch and threw the ball back into play. Then a lovely short ball by To’omua put Koroibete through a gap and Koroibete gained 30 metres but Philip was penalised at the next breakdown for not releasing the ball.

Richard Hardwick did well to earn a penalty shortly after entering the game. Hodge kicked the ball touch in goal. The Rebels scrum earned a penalty so no harm done for the Rebels. Harwdick then knocked on after the lineout and the Sunwolves were awarded a penalty at the scrum. Sunwolves prop Jarred Adams made a good run from the lineout and the Sunwolves put some pressure on the Rebels but the Rebels defence withstood the pressure.

Mike Stolberg stole twenty metres from the Rebels with a good run and offload to Adams. Moriya put through an exquisite grubber kick and Kellaway was forced to take the ball back over the try line. Garth April blew through the Rebels defence after the resulting scrum and April added the extras to make the score 36 to 13.

The Rebels were then penalised for being in front of the kicker at the restart. A short time later the Rebels had another scrappy lineout. However, To’omua ran onto the loose ball with momentum, passing to Hodge. The ball then went from Hodge to Haylett-Petty and then to Kellaway. Kellaway then kicked the ball through, resulting in a 50 metre gain for the Rebels and Kellaway was able to get onto the ball and score what looked like his first try for the Rebels. The TMO checked the Haylett-Petty pass to Kellaway and adjudged that the ball went backwards out of the hands. I wouldn’t have been surprised if the try was disallowed. To’omua added the conversion to get the score back to 36 to 20 with 66 minutes gone.

After struggling to gain ground after twelve phases following a lineout on the Sunwolves’ 22, persistence paid off for the Rebels. A good run from Naisarani and offload to Hardwick resulted in Hardwick offloading to Andrew Deegan who scored his first Super Rugby try. Hodge drop kicked the extras to reduce the margin to 36 to 27 with less than five minutes left.

Haylett-Petty, Koroibete and Kellaway made good runs for the Rebels. However, they all amounted to nothing as the Rebels tried to push passes due to scoreboard pressure.

The Sunwolves recorded their first win over the Rebels in their history, winning 36 to 27.

The Game Changer

Shortly after half time, James Dargaville collected an Andrew Kellaway kick and ran 55 metres to extend the Sunwolves lead to 29 – 13.


The Sunwolves were very good as a team. There were no real standouts. Garth April, Rudy Paige, Mike Stolberg, Keisuke Moriya, Ben Te’o and Jada Bregvadze were among the better performers. I will lean towards Keisuke Moriya.

Wallaby Watch

Haylett-Petty and Naisarani were the best Wallabies. Haylett-Petty made a number of good runs. Naisarani also made some good runs and a couple of important defensive plays. John Eales’ medallist Marika Koroibete made his presence felt in the second half but was virtually invisible in the first half. Matt To’omua was involved in some good play but did not assert himself on the match enough and I would question if his best position is 10.

The Details

Score & Scorers

Sunwolves 36

Tries: Keisuke Moriya, Jaba Bregvadze, Tautalasi Tasi, James Dargaville, Garth April

Conversions: Garth April (4)

Penalties: Garth April

Rebels 27

Tries: Anaru Rangi, Dane Haylett-Petty, Andrew Kellaway, Andrew Deegan

Conversions: Matt To’omua, Reece Hodge

Penalties: Matt To’omua

Cards: None

  • Steve

    My initial feedback is ‘lol’.

    My more considered feedback is disappointment that the best atmosphere in Super rugby won’t be there next year, however we will still get the privilege of round-the-world travel to play in empty stadiums in bad time zones.

    • Jason

      To be fair relative to Europe our stadiums are only empty because they are so much bigger. Super Rugby averages around 15k to each game, the European Comps don’t average any more than that. Only difference is our stadiums hold 50,000 people.

      • Huw Tindall

        This is a good point. Easy to sell out Sandyford Park or Twickenham Stoop as they are like Leighchardt oval in size. Still, they charge through the nose even for a shit seat.

        • Jason

          I can’t comment on what they charge in the UK for their games. Interestingly, I was shocked to learn in NZ they charge less than half in many instances than an equivalent ticket in Australia (say a Reds or Waratahs game).

        • Huw Tindall

          28 quid for the nose bleeds so about 50 AUD a pop. Even I’d think twice about going to a Tahs game for 50 bucks if I was sitting in the bleachers.

  • idiot savant

    Its gonna be a long season for the Rebs. Their forward pack remains unconvincing. They can’t hold possession for long periods and control the tempo of the game. Some brilliant individuals but a side lacking cohesion. I couldn’t make sense of a game plan. Whatever it was, the Moondogs disrupted it and it was great to see the return of breakneck speed rugby from them again. Its their style and it will trouble slow packs (lookout Reds again). I was not impressed with Lomani and agree Toomua didn’t take charge. But then again, his forwards didnt give him the platform either. I fear last season’s capitulation has rattled Wessels confidence.

    • Jason

      The thing that frustrates me is they let Sam Talakai and Tetera Faulkner go, then bring in Ruan Smith, it’s like they think ‘we only need one good scrumager.’ and it’s obvious in their scrumaging.

      • idiot savant

        From a distance I ask how many of the Rebels pack would start at any of the other Australian franchises? Naisarani may but no one else. As I see it, they are a pack of journeymen. Now journeymen are good if they are additions to a pack of at least 4 Wallaby class forwards but if they are your leading men? I admire the aggressive attitude of Cottrell and Phillip but they’re both brain farters and as much as they try cant harness their attitude to the requisite physical dominance for 80 minutes. And they are the leaders of the pack. The Rebels have recruited arse about. You can have all the good looking backs you like but the higher you go in rugby the more you need ugly brutes up front who can win the ball and hold it for long periods.

        • Keith Butler

          Never more true was the old adage that forwards win matches not so sure with today’s game that the second bit, backs determine by how much, in necessarily true.

    • Brumby Runner

      IS you’ve nailed it again. The Rebels are playing without cohesion and there is no discernible game plan. Some individual good work at times, but not as part of a whole.

    • Keith Butler

      Mate our forward pack has always been unconvincing since I first supported the Rebs back in their pre SR days. To much emphasis paid on signing so called marquee three quarters. Who can forget the Three Amigos, Cipriani, Beale and O’Connor. Any decent forwards we had either went North or to other clubs.

  • Mortahs Incoming – custardtaht

    I know it is only one game, but I am going to make an early prediction…..stick a fork in the Rebel, they are done no finals for them.

    Will hold fire on the Tahs until they play against someone not as good as the Crusaders, but still better than above average.

    Brumbies and Reds will be 1 and 2 in the Aus Conference.

    • Jason

      Brumbies & Reds then daylight, then probably Waratahs, Sunwolves and Rebels. (I jest I do expect the Rebs to be third, but the Waratahs could surprise but I can’t see the Moondoggies finishing any better than 4th.)

  • Nicholas Wasiliev

    Well that was puss.

    I can see, on one hand, that Wessels is trying to tackle the Rebels clear issue with depth, with him being an assistant coach for the Rising squad in last year’s NRC and also stacking the trial squads with younger players to give them game time.

    But, at the same time, he should have given the first string team some time too. And then there’s the players: As much as it can take a long time to get back into the swing of things, when that season kicks off you should be ready.

    All up, pretty disappointing. This is a team capable of much better. They’re due for a finals berth and are more than capable of reaching it. It’s time they start to show it.

  • Tim

    Rebels played so well in some parts of the game but only for a few minutes. Then they went back to awful rugby. A lot of mistakes by the rebels. I thought Andrew Deegan played pretty well when he came on and should start at 10 next week

    • Scott Rea

      Tim, I liked Deegan’s play as well. Can’t see them abandoning To’omua at 10 after just one match.

      • Tim

        Should shift the midfeild. Put Reece on the wing shift Meakes to 13 and To’omua to 12

    • Jason

      I don’t know why they brought Deegan in to not play him at 10. Classic Rebels ‘get him so no one else can’ type signing, not thinking about how the parts fit together.

      Same as the signing of Ruwan Smith, fantastic scrummager… with two poor scrumagers in his front row unit. -_-

  • KwAussie Rugby Lover

    Thanks Scott a really detailed write up. The Rebels were quite poor to be honest. They didn’t seem to have any structure in attack and yet again Hodge demonstrated that he doesn’t have the distribution skills to be a 13 and I agree that 10 doesn’t appear to be Toomua’s best position.
    I think that unless they improve a lot in a number of areas they’ll struggle this year.

  • Nutta

    I said on Friday that the Scum have the ingredients for a good side but to not discount those who seem to have little to play for (Pingers). Both comments were true! I should have bought lottery tickets…

  • Huw Tindall

    Just ground hog day for the Rebels. Get a bloody pack together then worry about the backs.

Melbourne Rebels

More in Melbourne Rebels