NSW AAGPS 2025 (banter and commentary)

[Mr. Speaker]

No idea about whether the Makasani rumour is true. he was at the game last week suited up - my understanding is it was due to a slight niggle. I'd be surprised if he doesn't play this weekend, however the new Director of Rugby, Ben Herring, is focused on building a strong rugby culture at the school after his predecessor really dropped the ball. So, it wouldn't entirely surprise if he made such a stand - there were a few games last season where the league kids in First XV picked and chose which games they appeared at which was really poor. It was exacerbated by the former DOR not handling it appropriately.

We will see soon. It would be a tragedy to 2nd grade players if he was playing there. Fairness is a key virtue within any AAGPS school.

 

[The Ruckman]

No idea about whether the Makasani rumour is true. he was at the game last week suited up - my understanding is it was due to a slight niggle. I'd be surprised if he doesn't play this weekend, however the new Director of Rugby, Ben Herring, is focused on building a strong rugby culture at the school after his predecessor really dropped the ball. So, it wouldn't entirely surprise if he made such a stand - there were a few games last season where the league kids in First XV picked and chose which games they appeared at which was really poor. It was exacerbated by the former DOR not handling it appropriately.

With further consideration the rumour could be true, I’ve been told that he didn’t even want to play for Newington this season whilst he focuses on league. This means we might see him playing less and less games for the school as the season goes on. Would be a huge loss for Newington if true as he’s a generational talent.

Thoughts?
Ruck’

 

[bomber06]

With further consideration the rumour could be true, I’ve been told that he didn’t even want to play for Newington this season whilst he focuses on league. This means we might see him playing less and less games for the school as the season goes on. Would be a huge loss for Newington if true as he’s a generational talent.

Thoughts?
Ruck’

That's pretty poor if true. And really disappointing. If he doesn't want to play, I wouldn't play him. I am sick of seeing League kids get given spots without having the level of commitment of other kids. To be brutally honest, not only would I stop him from playing, but I'd also not let him train. If he doesn't want to play, why should he have access to the program. And I say this as a parent of the school. Unfortunately, the last 5 or so years of Newington has seen the focus shift to shipping kids in who clearly aren't committed to the code or the school. I am genuinely excited by the arrival of the new DOR. He is a true and committed rugby man. Very hands on - was even helping the U13s prepare on Saturday - and very passionate about a rebirth of the rugby culture at the school. If the rumour is true as you have suggested, I have no doubt he would be driving the non-selection. But like I said, it's very much a rumour at the moment - normally that type of news filters through pretty quickly, but top this point I have heard nada, other than rumours on this forum.

 

[The 6 Seat]

Taylor from Kings at 10? If not GPS 1st XV maybe 2nds. He is definitely a fly half

He is very good. Played excellently on the weekend.

 

[Rugbynbeers]

Taylor from Kings at 10? If not GPS 1st XV maybe 2nds. He is definitely a fly half

sawyer at 15 for Kings Probbaly slot into that ten roll for a GPS side as he is more a natural 10

 

[The 6 Seat]

Team lists for tonights Rawson Cup - fair few old GPS lads

Thats nuts. Around half there that I can remember

 

[twister29]

With further consideration the rumour could be true, I’ve been told that he didn’t even want to play for Newington this season whilst he focuses on league. This means we might see him playing less and less games for the school as the season goes on. Would be a huge loss for Newington if true as he’s a generational talent.

Thoughts?
Ruck’

Really disappointing. Just starting to show the damage some of these league commitments are doing to the GPS...

Also disappointing because he is such a player to watch, I always enjoy a talented outside back who gets ball time and uses it well.

 

[PickandDriveThru80]

With further consideration the rumour could be true, I’ve been told that he didn’t even want to play for Newington this season whilst he focuses on league. This means we might see him playing less and less games for the school as the season goes on. Would be a huge loss for Newington if true as he’s a generational talent.

Thoughts?
Ruck’

If true, this will be yet another loss from gps’s rugby union to league. Disappointing stuff…

 

[Scrums'N'Bars]

With further consideration the rumour could be true, I’ve been told that he didn’t even want to play for Newington this season whilst he focuses on league. This means we might see him playing less and less games for the school as the season goes on. Would be a huge loss for Newington if true as he’s a generational talent.

Thoughts?
Ruck’

It is not true, Makasini begged Benji Marshall to let him play for Newington this year. He is indeed playing 2nds this week according to Newington team lists, only to make an example for future years.

-Scrums

 

[GottaLoveFooty]

Breaking news: Makasini is playing 2's this week

 

[Mr. Speaker]

Team lists for tonights Rawson Cup - fair few old GPS lads

Wow. Incredible GPS turnout I must say.

 

[Mr. Speaker]

Breaking news: Makasini is playing 2's this week

Insanity. Newington or Wests move? If Newington don't win in the 2nds this week there should and will be riots at Stanmore. Anyone got any news regarding any reactions to this ???

 

[hogieslammer]

Wow. Incredible GPS turnout I must say.

It's not really all that suprising considering the fees of USYD colleges. It's a bit like saying there's a lot of props in a pub. Cause and effect really.

 

[Joeys Super Fan!]

Breaking news out of the Newington Camp: Hemasi to play in 2nd XV this week

 

[scrumhalf]

Breaking news: Makasini is playing 2's this week

Thats mental, wouldn't want to be matching up against him as a young 2nds outside back.

 

[ThePassionatePilfGod22]

Thats mental, wouldn't want to be matching up against him as a young 2nds outside back.

@Finn Hannon

 

[CasualObserver]

After just one round, I’d say the selectors are already tossing around ideas for the GPS 1st XV—and I thought I’d have a crack at it too. I’ve left out anyone currently signed to league contracts, as they’re unlikely to play or may opt out, like Rodwell and Humphries from N last year.

1. Lavercome (K)
2. Smith (K)
3. Bloomfield (K)
4. Fonua (K)
5. Galligan (E)
6. Clout (E) or Dempsey (I)
7. Taumoepeau (J)
8. Lemoto (S)
9. Grover (I)
10. ???
11. Hart (J)
12. Gough (J)
13. Francis (E) or O'connor (J)
14. ???
15. Callaghan (E) (if back in time) or Grantham (N). He did say no last year I believe.

Help me fill it out gents.

Is the GPS XV, or Biggest Reputation XV?

 

[For Rucksake]

Breaking news: Makasini is playing 2's this week

Could be a rough weekend for Joeys outsides, looking to see how attitude will carry over.

 

[Backintheolddays]

Just remember we’re talking about a 17yo kid (Makasini) here. Regardless of your school or code affinity keep it on point.

 

[The Chairman]

Could be a rough weekend for Joeys outsides, looking to see how attitude will carry over.

If theres anyone that looks like they can stop him in the seconds camp, I would not put it past those Joeboys. Grit and they love to dig in. Best of luck to them.