• Welcome to the forums of Green & Gold Rugby.
    We have recently made some changes to the amount of discussions boards on the forum.
    Over the coming months we will continue to make more changes to make the forum more user friendly for all to use.
    Thanks, Admin.

JRugby2's latest activity

  • JRugby2
    JRugby2 replied to the thread Refereeing decisions.
    It would be if the law included the phrase "in the act of", but it doesn't - or "while" or anything that would infer that a player who...
  • JRugby2
    JRugby2 replied to the thread Refereeing decisions.
    Its very likely that you could throw this up to a round table of professionals and get 2 or more distinct views.
  • JRugby2
    JRugby2 reacted to Braveheart81's post in the thread Refereeing decisions with Like Like.
    I think it comes down to whether the player went to ground to regather the ball or were they on the ground already and then regathered...
  • JRugby2
    JRugby2 replied to the thread Refereeing decisions.
    Exactly, so there is no reason to judge either way. A player's intention is for better or worse, completely irrelevant. You make a...
  • JRugby2
    JRugby2 replied to the thread Queensland Reds 2025.
    I disagree re club level - he was a beast for GPS on numerous occasions. Just struggled with the limited minutes he got for the Reds
  • JRugby2
    JRugby2 reacted to Strewthcobber's post in the thread Refereeing decisions with Like Like.
    My take on law 13.1 is this is an instruction to players on what they have to do once they gather the ball. The important part is he...
  • JRugby2
    JRugby2 replied to the thread Refereeing decisions.
    The reason I disagree with that is because there is no way to prove his intent was to only make a tackle, and nothing else - you can...
  • JRugby2
    JRugby2 replied to the thread Refereeing decisions.
    Yes
  • JRugby2
    JRugby2 replied to the thread Refereeing decisions.
    13.1
  • JRugby2
    JRugby2 reacted to Derpus's post in the thread Broadcast options for Australian Rugby with Like Like.
    Need to get Hooper to re-retire and come back. He is also quality IMO.
  • JRugby2
    JRugby2 replied to the thread Refereeing decisions.
    Has everything to do with the timing of events rather than how he fell, where he fell etc. Provided he was on his feet when the reds...
  • JRugby2
    JRugby2 replied to the thread Refereeing decisions.
    Ok, I'll change my mind. I agree with this. He's on his feet, albeit stumbling when the ball comes loose (no reds player is in the...
  • JRugby2
    JRugby2 reacted to Braveheart81's post in the thread Refereeing decisions with Like Like.
    Really? I think he's off his feet from the moment he makes the tackle and should get back on his feet before playing the ball.
  • JRugby2
    JRugby2 replied to the thread Refereeing decisions.
    I think side by side neither pass the pub test. Adds to the narrative of inconsistent refereeing
  • JRugby2
    JRugby2 reacted to Strewthcobber's post in the thread Refereeing decisions with Like Like.
    Jumping over the tackle X 2 this week 3:08 - try stands for Moana Try disallowed for Wales
Show older items
Top