BoysfromtheBxW
2024 AAGPS Tipping Comp Winner
After today I would be taking Jorgensen out. He simply Can’t pass up to the standard that he should be at!!!
Wallabies 2024
- Thread starter rugbyAU
- Start date
BoysfromtheBxW
2024 AAGPS Tipping Comp Winner
Unsure of whether or not mahe from the tahs is eligible for the wallabies but I would put my money on him for the camp
Wilson
Phil Kearns (64)
He's got more claim to it at this stage, but he probably needs to show his form against some of the better sides first. Right now though it would be neither of them with Uru currently looking like the smokey for that spot. Otherwise I'd still have Hanigan, Wright and probably Harris ahead of the two of them. A lot of rugby to play yet though.
Brumby Runner
Jason Little (69)
That's a big call Wamb. CC clearly has a lot of skills and potential, but would it be a bit early this year?
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
So is Donaldson the no. 1 10 right now?
Noah no.2 with Lynagh just behind but not by much.
Gordon trying hard with glimpses but looks to be battling at bit.
Noah no.2 with Lynagh just behind but not by much.
Gordon trying hard with glimpses but looks to be battling at bit.
rugbyAU
Dick Tooth (41)
If we're picking a guy like Charlie Cale - guys too inexperienced and not god enough for test level then we won't have learned from last years WC
rugbyAU
Dick Tooth (41)
Donaldson has indeed been the form 10 and considering his better goal kicking than Carter might be a good shout
I'd have Gordon above of Lynagh
Hogan
Herbert Moran (7)
Still early days but the move west has certainly proved beneficial for Donaldson. He’s playing with so much confidence. He’s getting his hands on the ball a lot more with the Force’s expansive game plan which seems to suit his instinctive attacking style. He was a class above Lynagh tonight.
The_Brown_Hornet
John Eales (66)
Didn't think I'd be saying it, but Donaldson is firming for the 10 spot. He's showed an attacking acumen and a passing/support game that I don't think we saw from him at the Tahs.
Mr Pilfer
Dave Cowper (27)
Surely not Lynagh, Donaldson embarrassed him tonight, Lynagh’s defence was not great but also being at the game you notice the difference in the kicking game, Donaldson was getting 10-20 metres more off the boot and more accurate
eastman
John Solomon (38)
He’s always been a good supporting player but as a ball player he still stands too deep and looks to shovel. He does have an absolute cannon on him though.
I think Gordon is the most talented (and toughest) and plays the way we want our fly halves to by taking it to the line and looking for runners, however we’d have to accept that he comes with limitations and goal kicking would be jeopardized.
Hogan
Herbert Moran (7)
Disagree. Donaldson takes the ball flat to the line better and more often than any of our Aussie 10’s. Hardly a shoveller. I believe he leads the comp for try assists out of all our playmakers. The difference this year is that he is playing in a team that plays predominantly off 10 as opposed to the Waratahs who play mainly off Jake Gordon.
wamberal99
Jim Clark (26)
The Reds were totally off their game last night. Was it too hot?
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
I’m not putting him in the match day 23 being 3rd but his season work has been solid for a young 10.
dillyboy
Arch Winning (36)
Probably not much different to what we're used to in Brisbane....
I just think they couldn't maintain the intensity after a few massive weeks. Will be a good hard look at themselves moment & hopefully we bounce back well this weekend
upthereds#!
Peter Johnson (47)
May be completely irrelevant as I don't know if squad sizes are pre agreed upon for Spring series & Rugby Champs, but world cup limit is 33.
wamberal99
Jim Clark (26)
It can get a lot hotter in Perth. And they were playing in the sun. Got to be some reason, they were hopeless almost from the start.
wamberal99
Jim Clark (26)
There's still a few games to go. I think he offers a lot more versatility and athleticism. As for potential, he looks to have more than Gleeson in my opinion. I have seen a fair bit of Gleeson in the Shute Shield, and frankly I think he is overrated. Okay, he is very quick. What other attributes make him a Test match pick?
Tomikin
David Codey (61)
Well if you go by Australian team of the week it'd be Noah 1 Donaldson 2 .
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
Team of the week.
I just feel over the year Donaldson has looked good in a side that has struggled for the most part.
I like Noah and trust what he brings. I think Schmidt will place value in consistency and reliability especially with where the Wallabies currently sit. Foundations need building before you throw some darts and experiment.
I just feel over the year Donaldson has looked good in a side that has struggled for the most part.
I like Noah and trust what he brings. I think Schmidt will place value in consistency and reliability especially with where the Wallabies currently sit. Foundations need building before you throw some darts and experiment.