NSW AAGPS 2025 (banter and commentary)

[wisemaan]

Really? I heard it was 1-2 weeks max.

That's what I heard originally but it's worse than what they saw. He's still waiting to get the final prognosis.

 

[PROPaganda]

Galligan was the last picked as I couldn't think of another locl. Perhaps someone could suggest a more deserving second-rower or someone who can slot in if Galligan is injured.

 

[RuckReporter]

I believe it has been upgraded to a grade 3 syndesmosis tear - google tells me recovery is 6-12 weeks, but regardless a lot of ligament damage has been done

 

[The Ruckman]

Did Oliver Smith play for the U18 waratahs at the start of the year?

 

[Warnaaaa]

Shadforth (E) has been getting minutes in the 1sts in most games this year. However, it wouldn't be surprising if they move Reardon (E) back to the ones and slot Frape (E) into Galligan's position, as he has had experience there in the past.

 

[PROPaganda]

I believe A Yates and Sherrington are injured and Reardon has gone up to replace Galligan. Cowdry, Longes and Murdoch-Tilmouth will replace them in the 2nds. Robertson has been moved down to the 2nds as Callaghan returns and McLennan is returning from injury. So I assume Keeler and Mott will play Thirds.

Should look something like this:

1. C Armati
2. M Garner (C)
3. E Cowdry
4. Joyce
5. Shadforth
6. Squire
7. Murdoch-Tilmouth
8. Longes
9. Grieg
10. McLennan
11. Bremner
12. Robertson
13. Powell
14. Hawke
15. Quayle

 

[Bricknissey]

1. Harry Davies (N)
2. Charlie Ghattas (J)
3. Isaiah Sheck (N)
4. Isaac Fonua (K)
5. Daniel Muir/ Charlie Galligan (N/S)
6. Dylan Simmons (N)
7. Justice T (J)
8. Heinz L (K)
9. Angus Grover (I)
10. Jarred King (N)
11. Heamasi Makasini (N, League?)
12. Onitoni large
13. Rory (J)
14. Bailey R-L
15. Callum G (N)
What is everyones thoughts?

 

[Mannix Jorgenson]

No Lavercombe? No Bassingswaithe? No Hasani? Must i go on...

 

[RuckReporter]

Based on this my prediction for the 3s would be:
1. Sherridan
2. Yates
3. Hamilton
4. Z. Roberts
5. Paris
6. Le Maitre
7. Fulton
8. Mackellar
9. Brownie or T. Roberts
10. Glasson
11. Salis
12. OBrien
13. Shoemark
14. Lane
15. Warner

Although I did hear that Hamilton was moving into the back row so perhaps these would change around a bit

 

[For Rucksake]

Looking to see if McLennan (E) plays a full game, off his return from injury playing his 1st game back this week. Potential opportunity for Keeler (E) to stay in the team which I have heard he is playing half a game in the 3rds in order to reserve for the 2nds. Then rotate Quayle to half, after one half of footy.

 

[PROPaganda]

I think Scammell is at hooker and Yates will stay at 7. Also believe that Oliver "Hoggy" Gaden is getting the nod over Z Roberts.

 

[PickandDriveThru80]

I know Bassingthwaighte has been injured, but he dominated the GPS last year. If he plays any games before GPS selection I can't see him missing selection. Such a vital player for the SHORE team and played GPS last year. I can see where you are coming from but honestly leaving him out is ridiculouse in my opinion.

 

[RuckReporter]

I think Scammell is at hooker and Yates will stay at 7. Also believe that Oliver "Hoggy" Gaden is getting the nod over Z Roberts.

You are correct about Scammel and Yates, my mistake. I have heard wisperings about Gaden however I have only seen Roberts get an opportunity to run on in the previous few weeks, so my finalised prediction for the 3rds lineup is:

1. Sherridan
2. Scammel
3. Hamilton
4. Z. Roberts
5. Paris
6. Le Maitre
7. Yates
8. Mackellar
9. Brownie or T. Roberts
10. Glasson
11. Salis
12. OBrien
13. Shoemark
14. Lane
15. Warner

 

[Mannix Jorgenson]

Is Fin Shagforth the most likely replacement to slot into the row for injured Galligan?

 

[Here for the advice]

They have a few jumping options which have come on as subs or have performed well (sidwell and stock) but will be missed. Their set piece has been solid in all games. Open play and attack from set piece’s won needs work.

 

[Rog_the_outsidecenter1964]

Odds for this wkn?

SCRUM HARD

rog out

 

[TheRock]

Hi PROP, isn't Charlie Ghattas playing openside for Joeys this season (he looks pretty good there). He is still taking lineout throws in the 7 jersey,
however, I would have Oliver Smith ahead as an overall hooker (ball carry and scrummaging).

 

[TonyTackle01]

Really surprised to not see Armati in the 1sts, very underrated at the moment in my opinion.

 

[JoeBoar03]

If shore don’t lose by over 30 this weekend to New I’ll eat a slice of humble pie. I think News 3rds would give shores 1sts a run for their money at this point.

 

[Joker]

Pie....did someone say pie!!!!