• Welcome to the Green and Gold Rugby forums. As you can see we've upgraded the forums to new software. Your old logon details should work, just click the 'Login' button in the top right.

Search results

  1. noscrumnolife

    Australian Rugby / RA

    It is doubly frustrating because I do legitimately think that proper constitutional reform is the only path to professional rugby in this country thriving again. But the voices calling for it (such as the SOAR or the Hammer) seem to be absolute flogs of the highest order who I wouldn't trust to...
  2. noscrumnolife

    Wallabies 2024

    I will never stop banging the drum that not picking Skelton where possible is an incredibly low IQ thing to do. Yes you have to change some things about your pack to make it work. Yes he is also that good that you change things to accommodate him. I'd argue he is the best tight five forward...
  3. noscrumnolife

    Waratahs 2024

    https://www.theroar.com.au/2024/02/22/waratahs-star-rushed-to-hospital-following-training-mishap-ahead-of-season-opener/?fbclid=IwAR0CBkFNSjvoIoVfAuKkkC4ZuZ_tVBSzingVP5pg0iTW3y-izvUbEB9gWrE Doesn't sound very good.
  4. noscrumnolife

    Wallabies 2024

    Sorry this is absolute madness to me (mainly talking about Skelton). IMO as much as you can possibly pick him club commitments allowing, you play him. Test Rugby is not a development arena, despite what Eddie Jones made out. We need to win, and win soon, because further embarrassing losses will...
  5. noscrumnolife

    Waratahs 2024

    JS should play in the back three, his aerial ability is too good to not utilise and its one skill which should be pretty instantly transferable.
  6. noscrumnolife

    Melbourne Rebels 2024

    Hatchet job by who precisely? How does it suit RA to take over a club that can't pay its own bills? Why exactly would they want to diminish their Rugby presence in a state they clearly value, delivering them premium test matches year on year and reportedly a World Cup final? I don't want to...
  7. noscrumnolife

    Australian Rugby / RA

    I am someone who thinks we should make more of 7s than we do, and highlight our successes where they exist. But I think any discussion of that issue needs to account for the fact that as a format, it has not exactly captured the hearts and minds of rugby fans globally, not just in Aus. Outside...
  8. noscrumnolife

    The one and only Wallaby Coach thread

    I think Waugh (and if you are inclined to see things this way, Dan Herbert also) deserves a fair bit of credit amidst all of this. To come out of the shit-show that was the RWC and the McLennan fiasco afterwards and lock down Horne, Nucifora and Joe Schmidt is pretty good stuff. Horne was...
  9. noscrumnolife

    The one and only Wallaby Coach thread

    One of the big positives of having a Waugh-Horne-Nucifora-Schmidt power axis driving the game is that they are, to my eyes, all well aligned. Personality wise they all seem quite similar - pretty straight-forward types who aren't ones to over-egg the pudding. But also, quite tough and demanding...
  10. noscrumnolife

    Australian Rugby / RA

    I think in absence of a proper coordinated professional development program (ie productive academies) and an attractive pathway for juniors into Super (which they're obviously isn't at the moment, at least compared to NRL) it is not particularly positive for the sport of Rugby Union. However, if...
  11. noscrumnolife

    Australian Rugby / RA

    Well put by both you Phil and Ghost above. This is the essential conundrum that RA have tied themselves into. On the one hand, they have put all their chips into a successful Wallabies brand for years now - it is the golden goose that sustains the meagre professional game still surviving. Yet...
  12. noscrumnolife

    Australian Rugby / RA

    For once I agree with half. Yeah sure it's just one journo, I reckon the vast majority of journos also wouldn't include a rugby player if they did their list. Obviously on GAGR we are going to champion rugby players. The whataboutism is pretty pointless and emblematic of the head in the sand...
  13. noscrumnolife

    Australian Rugby / RA

    Agree with everything you say BH, MCG is 100% the best big event stadium in the country all factors considered (by a distance IMO) oval be damned. But there is something that just grates a little about having a World Cup final in a city (and most relevantly for me, a government) that has shown...
  14. noscrumnolife

    Australian Rugby / RA

    Lol calm down with your "Australian hero". He wrote a story about a bloke taking a job interview - which had already been reported in the Japanese press. Its not exactly Watergate or the Panama Papers.
  15. noscrumnolife

    Rugby 7s general chat

    Agreed. It's also a good carrot to dangle in front of talented youngsters - come and spend a year flying around the world playing for your country rather than treading water on a Super/NRL bench - seem to have taken this approach with Hadley Tonga which I like.
  16. noscrumnolife

    Wallabies 2024

    The whole building for the future thing also mistakes that, in my experience, the best way to win in the future is to win in the present. Its difficult to establish a winning environment when you are constantly losing. If you picked a team for 2027 in 2024 and played them for four years, they...
  17. noscrumnolife

    Wallabies 2024

    Sure, agree with the general sentiment. Would still maintain I've never seen him look like a dominant test backrower for any consistent period of time. Again, I do rate Valentini. Just think he still has a decent amount of development to do as a Wallaby. I also believe he can get there, but...
  18. noscrumnolife

    Wallabies 2024

    I don't understand why anyone would currently be calling for Gleeson > Valentini is a bit mad IMO. But also think Valentini is not on the level of Bell, Tupou or Skelton who are our best forwards (when fit). He looks very different in Brumby colours to when wearing Gold. I do think he is a good...
  19. noscrumnolife

    Waratahs 2024

    two blues
Top