• Welcome to the Green and Gold Rugby forums. As you can see we've upgraded the forums to new software. Your old logon details should work, just click the 'Login' button in the top right.

The Totality of Tony McGahan's contribution to Wallabies' rugby - a report on the first year

Status
Not open for further replies.

Bruce Ross

Ken Catchpole (46)
When, back in March this year, the Irish Times scored a world scoop with the news that Casino John O'Neill had managed to lure Tony McGahan back to our shores the excitement was palpable. Somewhat worryingly for a man of my years, I can recall being in a state of tumescence for quite a few days after reading T McG's plans for our national team:

"I’ll run the whole training programme while the national side is in Test-match mode from June to December and also run the programme and the players back in their provinces from January through to June.
"So I’ll be dealing with the totality of the strength and conditioning, the medical, the rugby side of things, strategy, the review, preview of the game itself and also the individuals.

And the wonderful news is that Totality has delivered, so much so that Casino John has been able to go off to join in mock battle with Packer Mk III, secure in the knowledge that what he has done to Australian rugby will not soon be forgotten.

The only area where Totality has not ventured with the Wallabies is rhetoric or oratory. Robbie's soliloquies still retain their unique irrelevance and incomprehensibility.

So let's turn to the report card on Totality's first season. At the time when he responded to his nation's frantic appeal there was mass disillusionment with our performance levels and the boring nature of our play. We were demanding change and in the pubs of Sydney and Brisbane there was mass muttering along the lines of "Anything would be better than this." There is an old Chinese curse: "May your wishes be granted."

In the last year BT (before Totality), if we exclude the World Cup games against USA and Russia, the Wallabies played 12 Tests winning 8 of them. We scored 31 tries of which 24 were converted. We kicked 21 penalty goals and 3 drop goals. This means we averaged 2.6 tries per game and 2.0 three-point goals.

This year, our first experience of Totality Rugby, with the Wales Test still to be played, the Wallabies have played 13 Tests winning 8 of them. We have scored 14 tries of which 11 were converted. We have kicked 43 penalty goals and 1 drop goal. This means we have averaged 1.1 tries per game and 3.4 three-point goals.

It often takes someone who is distant from the action to perceive what needs to be done to solve a problem. Thus it was that from his exile in Ireland Totality could see how Australian Rugby could best respond to the threats to our dominance of the sporting landscape from Aussie Rules and Rugby League.

Kick-it-to-me fans love seeing goals being kicked; so we'll win them over by kicking more goals than they do. And the Mungoes are just focussed on scoring tries; so we'll differentiate our product by showing that you can have really exciting football without worrying about tries.

Actually I suspect that Totality has an even more transformational vision than that. Those with a love of rugby history will know that at the game's inception no points were awarded for a try. Grounding the ball over the line merely entitled a team to "try" for a goal. What better way to celebrate and commemorate our code's proud history than to completely de-emphasise try scoring.
.
 
T

TOCC

Guest
No better way to spend a Sunday afternoon then a bout of character assassination.. Can you really blame Tony for everything that has occurred?

I think its also safe to assume Tony is not a product of Sydney University...
 

It is what it is

John Solomon (38)
Couldn't pick the guy out of a 2 person line-up.
Noticed that when the cameras panned to the Wallaby coaching box, there was still no talkies amongst our coaching team.
Are there issues, or are the coaches just as speechless at the Wallabies performance as us fans?
 

vidiot

John Solomon (38)
Completely unfair on Totality Tony. Like that contract for an extended warranty on the last TV I purchased, his statement is carefully worded.

He has no responsibility for what happens on the park, just before, after and at camp wallaby, which I understand is a bondwood caravan Tony pulls around the boondocks with his 50th anniversary kingswood.

2009fires061.jpg
 

Hugh Jarse

Rocky Elsom (76)
Staff member
^^^^ That facility will never facilitate a National Team. There is no way it is big enough for the egos of Four Muppeteers.

It all fits together now.

I can see the TT Camp Wallabies Facility parked up at the Caravan park over the back of Rockdale Footy Clubs main oval for when the boys are in Olde Sydney Towne.
 

Inside Shoulder

Nathan Sharpe (72)
Bruce Ross this quote shows why he ought to cop the blame for everything:
So I’ll be dealing with the totality of the strength and conditioning, the medical,

S&C at the Tahs seems to have been something he was taking responsibility for, hence:
also run the programme and the players back in their provinces from January through to June

As has been pointed out many times here the Tahs fitness was to be seen in the last 10-15 of most of their s15 games this season. It was woeful.

Medical - he took the responsibility for that: perhaps he would care to explain the over crowding of the wards in team rehab? NSW health are thinking of using the Wallabies as the waiting list benchmark.

In other words, TOCC, if this big swinging d*ck wants to talk himself up the way he did in the quotes in Bruce's post its a bit hard to see how he can escape responsibility after the fact.

In fact given that he was overseeing them in their provinces he arguably bears more blame than Deans who only got them from June. i dont know the guy but I sniff a wanker.
 

ChargerWA

Mark Loane (55)
I think you're being a bit harsh on TT Bruce Ross . I heard he organised a bonza Melbourne Cup sweep at the ARU office. Nuci's horse came last so he got his money back but Big John's horse came 4th. His head swelled and went the colour of a beetroot. Tony, Robbie and Nuci giggled over that one for hours.
 

Bruce Ross

Ken Catchpole (46)
Bruce Ross this quote shows why he ought to cop the blame for everything:

S&C at the Tahs seems to have been something he was taking responsibility for, hence:

As has been pointed out many times here the Tahs fitness was to be seen in the last 10-15 of most of their s15 games this season. It was woeful.

Medical - he took the responsibility for that: perhaps he would care to explain the over crowding of the wards in team rehab? NSW health are thinking of using the Wallabies as the waiting list benchmark.

In other words, TOCC, if this big swinging d*ck wants to talk himself up the way he did in the quotes in Bruce's post its a bit hard to see how he can escape responsibility after the fact.

In fact given that he was overseeing them in their provinces he arguably bears more blame than Deans who only got them from June. i dont know the guy but I sniff a wanker.

Slow down a bit, IS. Our man Totality only lobbed back in June, IIRC, so he can't really be held responsible for the S & C at the 'Tahs last season. In addition my mail is that the senior players there no longer have the option of saying they don't feel like doing hard graft in the off season.
.
 

No4918

John Hipwell (52)
Slow down a bit, IS. Our man Totality only lobbed back in June, IIRC, so he can't really be held responsible for the S & C at the 'Tahs last season. In addition my mail is that the senior players there no longer have the option of saying they don't feel like doing hard graft in the off season.
.

Not sure how wise that is. The excuses for underperforming are becoming more enjoyable by the season. If the players are actually fit I wonder what it will be next year.
 

Hugh Jarse

Rocky Elsom (76)
Staff member
Define "off season".

Unlike the old days when the "Off season" was actually that, and ran from when your mob were kicked out of the finals series (assuming that you made it in the first instance) until about Mid March when it was starting to get a bit chillsome at night.

The poor buggers nowdays get about 6 weeks "off season" if they are lucky. Others who want a longer "off season" find themselves in Suburban and "Church League" competitions.
 

Inside Shoulder

Nathan Sharpe (72)
Slow down a bit, IS. Our man Totality only lobbed back in June, IIRC, so he can't really be held responsible for the S & C at the 'Tahs last season. In addition my mail is that the senior players there no longer have the option of saying they don't feel like doing hard graft in the off season.
.
Oh, when was he speaking in your quote?
It's not like we/I needed another scapegoat for Tahs season 2012


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
T

TOCC

Guest
I guess we should be giving RD a break then... everything is obviously Tony's fault and the Wallabies were going fantastically until 2012...

For a while their i thought it was a synergy of efforts, ranging from under/non-funded development paths, lack of depth and poor coach selections..

nek minute
 

Bruce Ross

Ken Catchpole (46)
Oh, when was he speaking in your quote?
It's not like we/I needed another scapegoat for Tahs season 2012
He was quoted in the Irish Times in March, IS, while he was still coaching Munster. He still had to finish the season. I think he was caught unawares in the interview, not realising that some mischievous people would see the alliterative potential in associating the words, "Totality" and "Tony". I also think he was talking his role up for the good burghers of Munster, trying to make the point that it was more than just an assistant's role. Who knows what Casino John had told him about the job.

I guess we should be giving RD a break then. everything is obviously Tony's fault and the Wallabies were going fantastically until 2012.
TOCC, you seem to have missed the point that my initial post in this thread, as with a lot of other mentions of Totality Tony by me and others over the past few months, was meant to be taken ironically rather than literally.
.
 
T

TOCC

Guest
TOCC, you seem to have missed the point that my initial post in this thread, as with a lot of other mentions of Totality Tony by me and others over the past few months, was meant to be taken ironically rather than literally.
.

the art of a satirist is to offer constructive criticism in an ironic or sarcastic writing...
Whilst it may be ironic, the aim is still to ridicule the subject at hand...

I apologise if i have misinterpreted this...
 

Bruce Ross

Ken Catchpole (46)
the art of a satirist is to offer constructive criticism in an ironic or sarcastic writing.
Whilst it may be ironic, the aim is still to ridicule the subject at hand.

I apologise if i have misinterpreted this.
In my view, TOCC, it is very much a matter of judgement and purpose. When I use the term, "Casino John", I am writing sarcastically as it is my view that he has responsibility for much of what is wrong with Australian rugby.

By contrast, when I write about Tony McGahan I try to make what I write so absurd that people cannot possibly take it literally. I have no axe to grind with the man and know of nothing to his detriment. He merely left himself open with his "totality" quote. I console myself with the fact that I and other G&GR members have helped to elevate his public profile.

As for "offer[ing] constructive criticism in an ironic or sarcastic writing", I have never tried it. It may be possible, I suppose. When I want to offer constructive criticism I write seriously, although when I do so I usually find it is a dialogue of the deaf. No one listens.
.
 

KevinO

John Hipwell (52)
I have to agree that Tony McGahan is part of the problem, his record as a professional coach is not good enough to get him a role with a International team. He was useless at Munster and the records show that, I was glad to see him leave Munster although was very surprised that the Wallabies wanted him in their staff.

I don't think he would even get a gig with a Super Rugby team let alone a National side when his contract runs out with the Wallabies, he has never made any progression with sides he has had a leading role in for the last 4 years.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top