Wallaby 31 players for 2015 RWC

[john mcgomery]

He has an immense work rate, is bruising in defense and is a more than capable ball runner and operator at the back of the scrum. An argument can be made for him not being the first choice 8, but to claim it's impossible to think so is a fair way off the mark.

Bruising in defence and more than capable ball runner? Yeah rightio mate, don't know where you have been for the past 3-4 years where he has been completely ineffective.

 

[john mcgomery]

Actually, Michael Cheika hasn't selected Palu to play a test match yet. Connolly, Deans and McKenzie all did.

Let's hope he sticks with that through the RWC and we will more than likely have a successful campaign.

 

[john mcgomery]

However I would rather have Palu as our 'ball carrier' than Skelton

 

[Joeleee]

John: Only people with Tahs bias like Palu
Everyone: What about all these people with no Tahs bias
John: Let's hope no one selects him because he sucks!
Me: Palu is a very effective defender and capable ball runner
John: LOL, no way! He sucks!

I'm not sure who you're trying to convince but you're not doing a very good job of it.

 

[Viking]

If you say Palu should be first picked then your a "one-eyed waratahs" supporter.

And If you say Beale shouldn't be picked then your another unjustified "waratah basher".

What a load of crap. The overly defensive Tah supporters and the overly critical Tah bashing has got to stop.

 

[john mcgomery]

Great

John: Only people with Tahs bias like Palu
Everyone: What about all these people with no Tahs bias
John: Let's hope no one selects him because he sucks!
Me: Palu is a very effective defender and capable ball runner
John: LOL, no way! He sucks!

I'm not sure who you're trying to convince but you're not doing a very good job of it.

Great imitation bro!
Not trying to convince anyone just stating my opinion based on previous wallabies matches. A forum is used to debate opinion champ.

 

[Train Without a Station]

If you say Palu should be first picked then your a "one-eyed waratahs" supporter.

And If you say Beale shouldn't be picked then your another unjustified "waratah basher".

What a load of crap. The overly defensive Tah supporters and the overly critical Tah bashing has got to stop.

Perhaps the actual reality is somewhere in the middle?

 

[Gillys_ghost]

I think Palu should be picked but Beale shouldn't. Am I a one-eyed Waratah Supporter who hates the Tahs?

 

[Braveheart81]

Great

Great imitation bro!
Not trying to convince anyone just stating my opinion based on previous wallabies matches. A forum is used to debate opinion champ.

You posted your suggested team and asked for people's thoughts, people discussed that with you and someone else posted their suggested team in response.

You've then gone on a diatribe against Palu with little or no evidence to support your claims. Maybe you should try doing a little more debating of opinion than just dismissing every comment that you disagree with.

To provide a word of advice to a new poster, you should probably tone things back a little bit otherwise you're unlikely to be here long.

 

[Braveheart81]

I think Palu should be picked but Beale shouldn't. Am I a one-eyed Waratah Supporter who hates the Tahs?

It depends.

Where do you stand on Tom Carter?

 

[Gillys_ghost]

Surely even Tah supporters thought Tom Carter was a dick head?

 

[Braveheart81]

Surely even Tah supporters thought Tom Carter was a dick head?

He was our dickhead though.

And the hatred thrown at him from supporters from every other team more than compensated for that.

 

[Gillys_ghost]

The reds have a dickhead, ironically his name is dick. Hopefully he's not around too much longer though.

 

[fatprop]

Maybe you forgot that the national coach is also the coach of the waratahs! Better luck next time buddy!

Pretty sure Connelly, Link & Deans have thought the same

 

[Viking]

I don't support the inclusion of Beale either and I'd prefer to risk a returning-from-injury-Cooper over a fully-fit-Foley and I am frequently labelled a Tahs basher for it.

 

[john mcgomery]

Fair

You posted your suggested team and asked for people's thoughts, people discussed that with you and someone else posted their suggested team in response.

You've then gone on a diatribe against Palu with little or no evidence to support your claims. Maybe you should try doing a little more debating of opinion than just dismissing every comment that you disagree with.

To provide a word of advice to a new poster, you should probably tone things back a little bit otherwise you're unlikely to be here long.

Fair play just having a bit of fun you know.

What do you mean- 'won't be here long?' I'm not leaving

 

[USARugger]

Great

Great imitation bro!
Not trying to convince anyone just stating my opinion based on previous wallabies matches. A forum is used to debate opinion champ.

I'd start shopping for a new one, soon.

 

[Braveheart81]

Fair

Fair play just having a bit of fun you know.

What do you mean- 'won't be here long?' I'm not leaving

There is a long history of new forum members who come in with a flurry of posts that are pretty aggressive and adversarial and then end up getting banned by the moderators for not following the rules.

 

[Viking]

Fair

Fair play just having a bit of fun you know.

What do you mean- 'won't be here long?' I'm not leaving

A bit of light-hearted fun is always welcomed. But comments like "your a one eyed tah supporter if you pick Palu" won't go down well in this forum.

The tah hate/tah basher comments are getting very old and very un-welcomed here.

Even if they are only made as a joke, it's a joke we have heard 1000 times and ceases to be even the slightest bit funny any more.

Anyways. Welcome to the forum.

 

[Tomikin]

Jeez mate I think you are way off the mark with those selections

By the way, who is that new halfback ? Haven't heard anything at all about him

Plays for Randwicks last I heard.. ?