1. Welcome to the Green and Gold Rugby forums. As you can see we've upgraded the forums to new software. Your old logon details should work, just click the 'Login' button in the top right.

Super Rugby AU - Semi Final - Reds v Reb

Discussion in 'Rugby Matches' started by KevinO, Sep 8, 2020.

  1. Bobby Sands Banned

    Likes Received:
    It's very silly logic, an Louie doesn't want to play the Reds.
  2. Rebel man Alfred Walker (16)

    Likes Received:
    So over the Rebels kicking the ball away all the time. Does my head in, I agree with the criticism of Toomua. While I liked the width we played with early he over played his hand by going again and again and it cost the intercept. While I liked them being more expansive and looking to spread the ball you have to mix it up. Hit some forward runners through the middle so you are not so predictable to the defenders
    Highkicks and Derpus like this.
  3. Derpus David Codey (61)

    Likes Received:
    The Rebels didn't look too hard to defend against. Of the Rebels i thought MK and Naisarani were their only dangerous players.

    Meakes was horrid. Been saying it all year but they should have run out with 10. Deegan 12. Toomua.

    Paisami is an absolute gun. Apparently his defence isn't up to scratch at 13, which is a shame as otherwise he'd be right behind Petaia for Wallaby 13.
    Highkicks likes this.
  4. Highkicks Herbert Moran (7)

    Likes Received:
    May have been a bit much saying Hardwick outplayed him but I think Wilkin definitely did. Hate to parrot the commentators, especially Kearns but Wilkin's work in the lead up to the try was very good and I thought he had more impact in contact and pressured the ruck well. Like I said, I don't mean to be too harsh on Wright, he is a good player and will certainly be in the mix for a Wallaby spot, just think he might be a bit overrated in his general play. Honestly his lineout work alone makes him a pretty tempting option.

    With Kuridrani's effort last week and lack of game time before that he may just get a look in despite the missed tackles. He can certainly hit and was not missing so many earlier on in the year, so fingers crossed he can rectify it.
  5. Bobby Sands Banned

    Likes Received:
    Wilkin is a gun, and better than Hardwick at 7 to my mind, but he isn't a 6. I think Wright easily matched them both around the ground, and his lineout play is what makes him such a standout at 6, rather than an afterthought skill.

    So are you saying Wilkin is a better 7 than Wright, or a better 6?

    Or are you saying it doesn't matter?
  6. Up the Guts Mark Ella (57)

    Likes Received:
    Wilkin was perhaps involved in more of the big moments for the Rebels last night but I suspect watching the tape all the subtleties of Wright's game would add up. I think there were at least two maul turnovers generated by Liam that weren't called out on commentary.
  7. Sully John Eales (66)

    Likes Received:
    As I watch the Rebels warm up last night I commented to the missus that the Rebels didn't look like they had changed anything for the Reds and were going with the same game plan as the last two games. Hoping for third time lucky I guess.
    Bu the twenty minute mark I could see I was right and grew more confident as the game went on.
    mst and TSR like this.
  8. spikhaza Arch Winning (36)

    Likes Received:
    Meakes seems to dawdle a lot, crab and not commit defenders, giving opposition defensive lines time to slide left or right
  9. Highkicks Herbert Moran (7)

    Likes Received:
    I guess we will have to disagree. I'd have picked Wright ahead of the other two for the Wallabies as well, in either position, just thought last night they probably got up on him. I'd have to watch them all again specifically, just my initial take. So I don't think Wilkin is better at either position at this stage.

    The positional question is pretty interesting, It's so open as to what people value in their back rowers, I think ideally I'd want someone in the Pieter-Steph du toit, Kano or Courtney Lawes mould at 6. Tall, hard players who are also athletic and good in the lineout. Unfortunately I don't think we have anyone like that outside maybe LSL. Wright is hard to grasp as he doesn't fit neatly into any of the traditional ideas of a 7 or a 6. Reminds me of a traditional 7 around the park while also being a bit taller and good in the lineout. Rennie seems to think the same but we will have to wait and see.
  10. TSR John Thornett (49)

    Likes Received:
    That’s always the problem Highkicks - if we had a Kaino, I don’t think you’d get much argument from anyone on here about them being selected.
  11. kiap Mark Ella (57)

    Likes Received:
    Kaino definitely world-class No. 6 and best in his time but not especially tall.

    Billed at 6'5" but really 2 inches under that mark. Harder than Wright but not taller.
  12. Tex Peter Johnson (47)

    Likes Received:
    The one thing I took away was a positivity about the game here in Aus. Maybe it's because the fucken kiwis haven't battered it out of me this year, but there's been some exciting rugby played, young blokes coming through the pathways and while Rebs didn't get the bickies, they gave it a crack and fell short in a fair contest.

    As always, support the underdogs so I'll be behind the young Reds tyros to take to and from the old stallions.
    The_Brown_Hornet likes this.
  13. Dctarget Tony Shaw (54)

    Likes Received:
    Watching Turinui on Rugby Ruckus Live breakdown some of the Rebels attack makes me feel a bit better about the Rebels and Wessels. Clearly a well drilled team just lacking the killer instinct. Actually think that Wessels has improved a few of his players' standings quite a lot.
    Derpus and Tex like this.
  14. Adam84 Peter Johnson (47)

    Likes Received:
    I think Wright brings a work rate and good technical ability, where this stood out to me on the weekend was in the lead up to the LSL try, prior to that JOC was tackled behind the gain line and Uelese was over the top ready to pounce on the ball, Wright managed to get back, come in through the gate and drive Uelese off the ruck and provide quick ball to attack the blind side. Uelese certainly isnt a slouch to shift off the ball, it was simply good technique at the ruck which enabled him to do that and secure quick ball.

    He had an involvement in the lead up to the Daugunu try as well, he did a nice clean out on Naisarani, it actually removed Naisarani as one of the pillars on the edge of the ruck and opened the space for Tupou to come through.
  15. Highkicks Herbert Moran (7)

    Likes Received:
    Out of curiosity I went back and watched the first half and wrote down both 6’s involvements. This isn’t for the sake of arguing either, I just honestly feel there are a lot of misconceptions around players and if I’m going to disagree with the consensus then I should back it up, rightly or wrongly. Also I love rugby and it was fun to do. My takeaways were that while Wilkin definitely had more of an impact in this half, especially ball in hand, neither player was a work horse and Wright’s contact work, rucks especially, is very far from dominant or even effective. I mean in general the ruck work bar 3 successful pilfers (Wilkin, McReight and Hardwick) was pretty poor, a lot of ineffective clean outs.

    Of note, they both had one lineout win and Wilkin disrupted 1 defensive lineout.

    Wright was involved in 9 rucks, 3-4 of which he was effective in, none of which were dominant, 1-2 were hand on the ruck, 1 was an air swing. Wilkin was involved in 7 rucks, 5-6 of which were effective, 1 dominant and 1 pilfer, 2 slowed down ball.

    Wright made 1 poor tackle all half, 2 if you include his hold up for a turnover, which upon reflection was dominant. Wilkin made 2 tackles, 1 poor and 1 dominant.

    Wright had 2 runs, one lost ground the other made a meter. Wilkin made 5 runs, broke 2 tackles, offloaded once, put the wing in space once and got over the ad line each time, excluding the quick pass to the wing.

    Obviously this is a very small sample size and no way to judge a player, really just wanted to see if what I said prior held any weight and even accounting for some inaccuracies on my end I think it does.

    Edit: there were some other things, Wright came through a maul, didn’t gain possession but forced the Rebels to pass (maybe). He was very slow to leave a scrum to cover the blindside, had no impact on the play though. He also seemed to be positioned mostly around the far wing/13 zone in general play, clearly his role but other back rowers cop some flack for the same thing.
  16. Derpus David Codey (61)

    Likes Received:
    I find your actual analysis of player performances personally insulting.
    The_Brown_Hornet and KOB1987 like this.
  17. Adam84 Peter Johnson (47)

    Likes Received:
    No note of the two involvements I spoke of in the lead up to the reds two tries?
  18. Up the Guts Mark Ella (57)

    Likes Received:
    Highkicks only analysed the first half.
  19. Braveheart81 Rocky Elsom (76)

    Likes Received:
    This was a cracking game. The Rebels certainly blew their opportunities in the first half and should have had a strong lead with the Reds chasing the game.

    I thought Koroibete put in an incredible performance in a losing side. He was everywhere. Not often a winger from each team could be fairly argued as the two best players on the park.
    TSR, Jimmy_Crouch, Penguin and 3 others like this.
  20. Highkicks Herbert Moran (7)

    Likes Received:
    It probably comes off a bit critical, of Wright especially. However it was just one half of one game, where his team wasn’t performing well. Not a fair assessment of him as a player. As Adam pointed out, he had at least 2 good contributions in the 2nd half and likely a lot more. I feel it did give me more insight into his play though and I still doubt him as a link player and probably have more doubts around his contact and ruck work than I did prior.

    If I do something similar in the future I can give more context around the involvements too. Sometimes making 1 meter in tight is a good dominant run etc.

Share This Page