Mug Punter
Ward Prentice (10)
Wright is injured again which explains his non selection in at least the squad
Australia A - Back on the Cards
- Thread starter Tomikin
- Start date
He didn’t elaborate. Just not selected.
Maybe if you hadn't referred to him as a horse he'd have been more forthcoming 
liquor box
Greg Davis (50)
It would be interesting the see the teams selected initially with all players considered, then remove the injured players and put in the actual team that will be available.
This way we can see the real pecking order for players in the selectors eyes.
This way we can see the real pecking order for players in the selectors eyes.
qwerty51
Stirling Mortlock (74)
Not sure it would be that simple, I guess it depends on RA's goal for this team. Is it to win at all costs or more development style. Plus you'd assume a lot of rotation throughout the tournament.
D
DELETE ACCOUNT
Guest
selections are always contentious at all levels.
remember it is only the opinion of a few people at best based on what the coach is looking for or the style he / she wants to deliver.
Plenty of cases where an overlooked player has gone on to be a high performer in another arena.
PhilClinton
John Hipwell (52)
Is Gordon injured? He didn't play club rugby on the weekend - or at least wasn't named, but I missed the game.
Seems the answer to Wright's exclusion is injury, so maybe the same for others.
Members Section
John Thornett (49)
Its really strange, half the rebels have gone back to club footy & some are just still in Melbourne training
Drew
Bob Davidson (42)
No idea on Gordon, I was just using him as an example. It would be nice to know who wasn’t available and why, but either way I’d hope and think that probably players on the radar who missed selection would be made to understand what they have to work on the have a better chance of selection next time.
SouthernX
Peter Johnson (47)
Gordon posted on socials this past Saturday a photo of him and Matt To'omua about to hit the fairways at some golf course in Victoria.
Heres hoping he is back in clubland soon
D
DELETE ACCOUNT
Guest
still reckon the contracted players should play club rugby in the state they are contracted.
This will drive up the standard in Melb and Perth (and Canberra). Which in turn will create a bigger pool of selectable players.
Members Section
John Thornett (49)
Carter Gordan would go backwards at a rate of knots if he was to stroll out for Power House in the Dewar shield, we want him to be a wallaby not help bring up the standard of our club comp
new recruit_ brisbane
Jimmy Flynn (14)
100% agreed - this notion they have to play their club rugby in the state they are contracted is ridiculous.
D
DELETE ACCOUNT
Guest
so local lads working on improving their standing get punted sideways for a mercenary who showed no resolve to stay in qld even with all the support and help given to him? Where is a bit of loyalty?
I thought QPR was the breeding ground for Qld Rugby given that is where the revenue streams flow. Dont know how much effort or $$$ the Rebels contribute to the running of QPR?
You should complain to the QPR club that wants a starting Super Rugby player to play for them when available.
Slim 293
Stirling Mortlock (74)
The Brumbies requiring their players to be involved in the John I Dent Cup seem to indicate that you can have both...
D
DELETE ACCOUNT
Guest
I have had this discussion face to face with 3 club presidents
Were any of them from the club(s) that Rebels players play for?
SouthernX
Peter Johnson (47)
Not everyone is playing for a contract mate.
if someone is hell bent on this pathway and feels hipped by a returning super rugby player well then the grass is always greener at norths.
99% of players are at rugby clubs because of their friends or family. Stop looking at everything thru the prism of “talent finding”