• Welcome to the Green and Gold Rugby forums. As you can see we've upgraded the forums to new software. Your old logon details should work, just click the 'Login' button in the top right.

NSW AAGPS 2023

Status
Not open for further replies.
M

moa999

Jimmy Flynn (14)
Yep. Been an even comp. Lots of draws. And well done to Joeys recovering from its 0-2-3 start.

I think the challenge to the format will be if a team goes 0-0-5, the second half of the season is going to be very long.

I'm sure over in the CAS comp, SAC is glad there wasn't a 2nd round, particularly with the -250 points difference.
 
D

Double Badger

Stan Wickham (3)
Frostiesview said:
How can you compare teams who play a 10 round competition and a 5 round competition?

it’s just not possible, the next years will show this. Teams will struggle especially in rugby to go 10-0

tbf in sports like basketball newo we’re able to go undefeated so it shows it is possible.
Click to expand...
A lot of the teams thrown up there for best in last 40 years were predominantly from the era when High and Grammar were still competitive and playing in the 1's comp. I think most mentioned went 7-0.
 
Game_Day_Ritual

Game_Day_Ritual

Sydney Middleton (9)
moa999 said:
Yep. Been an even comp. Lots of draws. And well done to Joeys recovering from its 0-2-3 start.

I think the challenge to the format will be if a team goes 0-0-5, the second half of the season is going to be very long.

I'm sure over in the CAS comp, SAC is glad there wasn't a 2nd round, particularly with the -250 points difference.
Click to expand...
In fairness I think SAC maybe should go down the path of High or Grammar play other schools B/C and make it competitive it will be better for all round. SAC have been weak even way wat back in the early 1990's nothing has changed.
 
A

amazingadelaide

Bob McCowan (2)
moa999 said:
Yep. Been an even comp. Lots of draws. And well done to Joeys recovering from its 0-2-3 start.

I think the challenge to the format will be if a team goes 0-0-5, the second half of the season is going to be very long.

I'm sure over in the CAS comp, SAC is glad there wasn't a 2nd round, particularly with the -250 points difference.
Click to expand...

You have to feel for SAC and its players who don't get the same monetary support as other schoolboy rugby programs, instead focusing on trying to rise in HSC ranks.
 
B

bullocks

Ward Prentice (10)
Home and Away is great.
May the best team and program win. For the players, get to play at every 1st oval at least once which is special. Supporters get to sample the food and atmosphere at different venues. Pre season prep is vital whether it's internal or trial games. Injury is a problem as it's a long season and it will test depth which imo is a true reflection of a school's rugby program. Keep it going AAGPS
 
G

GPSlads

Chris McKivat (8)
bullocks said:
Home and Away is great.
May the best team and program win. For the players, get to play at every 1st oval at least once which is special. Supporters get to sample the food and atmosphere at different venues. Pre season prep is vital whether it's internal or trial games. Injury is a problem as it's a long season and it will test depth which imo is a true reflection of a school's rugby program. Keep it going AAGPS
Click to expand...
Feels like a proper comp …
 
AroundTheAnkles

AroundTheAnkles

Dave Cowper (27)
A question for the historians. With 1 round to go, there have been 3 draws this season. Joeys V Scots, Joeys V Shore and Kings V Scots. 2 teams had 2 draws each (20% of their matches, crazy right). Has there ever been so many draws in the 1st XV comp? Kings have been dominant, View excelled, Shore beat View. Probably only New fell short of potential but even then they played some great football. The best thing about the GPS '23 comp is that it has been very close, the comp is healthy and clearly the most competitive schoolboy sporting comp of any kind or code in the country. The season should run longer!
 
Homer

Homer

Ted Fahey (11)
Home and away works, in CAS Knox averaged over 40 points per game, won everything but one game, and lost the whole season. How good would a second round decider be! I know Cranbrook would sell the house to play Barker again.
H&A only promotes better programs and depth, add a school champs point system to it for all A and B teams, and GPS rugby will go from strength to strength.
 
The Ghost of Raelene

The Ghost of Raelene

Andrew Slack (58)
It’s the best method moving forward. I wasn’t a fan when it was initially done years ago but probably just man yelling at clouds.

I hated it when View played Joeys in a trial. Just felt like it diminished it to a degree. The loss didn’t matter…

2 rounds is here to stay as I hope as much as the CAS might hate it. They should adopt it and look at their team structures.

The boys are playing more meaningful games which is key for them. Say what you want but the trials are trials and no body talks about them now or cares. The team View was v Barker in their first game is completely different to that I watched through the season.
 
AroundTheAnkles

AroundTheAnkles

Dave Cowper (27)
The Ghost of Raelene said:
It’s the best method moving forward. I wasn’t a fan when it was initially done years ago but probably just man yelling at clouds.

I hated it when View played Joeys in a trial. Just felt like it diminished it to a degree. The loss didn’t matter…

2 rounds is here to stay as I hope as much as the CAS might hate it. They should adopt it and look at their team structures.

The boys are playing more meaningful games which is key for them. Say what you want but the trials are trials and no body talks about them now or cares. The team View was v Barker in their first game is completely different to that I watched through the season.
Click to expand...
Trials are just trials, they count for something but not much. I am all in favour of extending the season. You can't ever get a decent steak sambo at the cricket or basketball.
 
B

bullocks

Ward Prentice (10)
IF, and it's a big IF, you could get a GPS/CAS play off at the end of season. Reduce the trial games,have a GPS/CAS home and away comp and at the end have a semi final week and grand final week ie GPS 1 play CAS 2, CAS 1 V GPS 2, winners play GF, loses play for 3/4. Rest play for plate. GPS3 v CAS 4, GPS 4 v CAS 3 etc 2 more weeks of schooboy rugby and if you condensed the "meaningless" trial games at the beginning then you could fit this in and not take anything away from the athletics season. This would be exclusive to 1sts and 2nd Only therefore ensuring hopefully big crowds.Thoughts.
I know Water Polo do it. They have a GPS/CAS combined comp and then each school plays for their own premiership either GPS or CAS.
How good would it be to finally have a solution to the age old question : Which school is the best ?
This year it would be :
Kings v Trinity semi, View v Waverley semi in the 1sts
 
The Ghost of Raelene

The Ghost of Raelene

Andrew Slack (58)
Maybe…

Waterpolo do it because they had to when it started with not enough schools playing.

I think the number of meaningful games for the top boys pretty good right now. If you make a Gen Blue team you should get to 15-16 by the end of the year and Aus U18s 18-19.

If a combined concept was done you would have to consider Augustines and Oakhill on current program.
 
AroundTheAnkles

AroundTheAnkles

Dave Cowper (27)
The Ghost of Raelene said:
Maybe…

Waterpolo do it because they had to when it started with not enough schools playing.

I think the number of meaningful games for the top boys pretty good right now. If you make a Gen Blue team you should get to 15-16 by the end of the year and Aus U18s 18-19.

If a combined concept was done you would have to consider Augustines and Oakhill on current program.
Click to expand...
top boys in Europe are playing 20 plus before rep honours
 
B

bullocks

Ward Prentice (10)
Just saying, other sports seem to do it ok so why not Rugby. Bet if you asked the boys whether they wanted to be crowned GPS/CAS champions, they would say yes. How to included Auggies and Oakhill etc in ? Tough one.
 
F

Frostiesview

Peter Burge (5)
The Ghost of Raelene said:
I’d also say the Europeans nail the gap 18-20yrs in development because of the abundance of Professional programs.

Many of the Schools comps are over hyped through the UK IMO. They may have more schools at an OK level but not the talent density of Aussie ones.
Click to expand...

to put into perspective, at the end of 2019 kings sent over a group of 26 lads to Europe and went from my understanding 7 from 7 against uk/Europe teams.

all these boys were year 9-11
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top