Recent content by Dumbledore

So what would a Rebels team look like with some of the Force boys rolled in? 1. Smith 2. TPN 3. Lomax 4. Phillip 5. Coleman 6. McCalman 7. McMahon 8. Mafi 9. Stirzaker/Ruru 10. Lance 11. Koroibete 12. Hodge 13. English 14. Sefa 15. DHP 16. Hanson 17. Van Wyk 18. Ainsley 19. Timani 20...

Cheers mate. Someone needs to get Penney on the phone, his teams have always played a great brand of footy. All I really want to see is a team that's fast, physical, can pass the ball, and work to support. The Hurricanes have scored 85 tries this year to our 18, which is just mind-boggling...

Moore shouldn't be anywhere near the 23, let alone the squad. He's totally done, legs are gone. It was incredible watching him last week live, honestly can't remember the last time I saw a player who was so clearly not up to the level he was playing at. Cheika really should bring Latu in, even...

This is good news. Totally unable to build a team, or gameplan, that met the demands of the Soup. What's Rob Penney doing these days?

Why? He's a much better player than Hunt. When fit he'll be in the XV, either for Hunt or DHP, and the Wallabies will be better for it.

Seriously, the state of him. One guess as to why none of the Kiwi teams wanted him...

Sure, but there's no way to get into any rhythm early this way - especially since we'll be getting dicked every single week. Obviously you have to play them at some point, but balance and scheduling do make a huge difference. Totally agree on 0-5, mayybe 1-4. Very hard to come back from that to...

That start is an absolute buzzsaw. I wouldn't be surprised if we were 0-6, both byes down, after 8 weeks. Having both byes that early is jokeshop stuff, totally insane.

? He won the Rebels player of the year a couple of seasons ago I'm pretty sure. He's been consistently excellent on a per-game basis. Not overtly physical in the way that McMahon and Reid are, but a better footballer than either of them IMO.

I don't. Colby is close to the most underrated player in Australia. He's the most well-rounded 7 in the country, certainly has the best linking game. As good as Reid has been, he's still McMahon-lite at the moment. Would like to see him start adding some strings to his bow.

Anyone know what the deal with Izaia Perese is? Is he under contract, EPS, something like that? Was seriously impressed with him against Canberra yesterday - looks similar to a young JOC (James O'Connor). Edit - Just saw it's been covered above. Glad he's been signed up, he's the sort of kid who should be...

They're annoying losses, who's going to play fullback? A backline with Pau, Koroibete, and an in-shape Sefa, suddenly starts looking a bit explosive. If Quade can be tempted down it could be a lot of fun to watch.

Ignoring the conspiracy ravings, JOC (James O'Connor) had played an excellent pair of games at flyhalf for the Wallabies on the 2011 EOYT. He missed most of 2012 after being injured by Berrick Barnes, and was then playing 10 for the Rebels in 2013 (albeit badly.) Christ, this is all very deja vu. Think the...

Palu was a much quicker player than Timani at his peak. And a much better player. So while he's lost his pace, he's got a shitload of Test experience to help mitigate that. Timani would get horribly exposed at 8. Maybe playing blindside he'd be okay, but I wouldn't be banking on it.

Meehan played in the incredibly soft part of the schedule though. And he hasn't impressed off the bench recently. Stirzaker's in his worst form for years. He looks miles off the pace fitness-wise and it's cost him. Still doesn't look totally comfortable with his shoulder either. And I don't...