scrumhead99
Fred Wood (13)
Agreed.
CAS Rugby 2024
- Thread starter rod skellet
- Start date
guntzinator
Stan Wickham (3)
Would make it more interesting for the weaker schools and give the school's that are playing lower division, more of a drive to succeed and make the "top division."
scrumhead99
Fred Wood (13)
Again I agree, Would allow for the competition to be competitive, and give teams a chance to prove themselves
Problem is 1. 100+ yrs of history, and 2. Rankings can change pretty quickly, and year groups can be very different.
(And 3. The GPS seemed pretty happy with it's 2 round comp this year - not sure if it will work as well in future years)
Personally think best case is a few trial games, then play the CAS and ISA comps in the remainder of Term 2.
Also means everyone has played each other before rep selections.
And then on the basis of those performances you have some kind of combined cup for Term 3.
(And 3. The GPS seemed pretty happy with it's 2 round comp this year - not sure if it will work as well in future years)
Personally think best case is a few trial games, then play the CAS and ISA comps in the remainder of Term 2.
Also means everyone has played each other before rep selections.
And then on the basis of those performances you have some kind of combined cup for Term 3.
046ballrunner
Peter Burge (5)
Predicted CAS 1s
1. Harper Strachan (Knox)
2. Seb Gynell (Knox)
3. Nick Hill (Barker)
4. ?
5. ?
6. Cam Mackenzie (Cranbrook)
7. Ollie Aboud (Waverley)
8. Heath Turner (Knox) (C)
9. Ollie Chandler Smith (Barker)
10. Tua Patea (Waverley)
11. Max Roach (Knox)
12. Riley Evans (Waverley)
13. Kahu Capper (Waverley)
14. Tye Jecks (Knox)
15. Charlie Poynton (Barker) (VC)
1. Harper Strachan (Knox)
2. Seb Gynell (Knox)
3. Nick Hill (Barker)
4. ?
5. ?
6. Cam Mackenzie (Cranbrook)
7. Ollie Aboud (Waverley)
8. Heath Turner (Knox) (C)
9. Ollie Chandler Smith (Barker)
10. Tua Patea (Waverley)
11. Max Roach (Knox)
12. Riley Evans (Waverley)
13. Kahu Capper (Waverley)
14. Tye Jecks (Knox)
15. Charlie Poynton (Barker) (VC)
Props are People too
Sydney Middleton (9)
Strong effort.
back row - has Nuilala from Trinity left? Thought he was only u17. same with max Meagher at 2 - he was in u16 last year.
- Dene from barker did will at 10 this year, coming in young. Will be tough to dislodge.
- the Cranbrook centre Tovio is class. Must be in the mix.
- presume Casswell and not Jecks at 14?
james richards
Allen Oxlade (6)
Don't forget Cameron Mackenzie he should be in that lineup
Props are People too
Sydney Middleton (9)
No chance of a change to the association games. GPS home and away worked well and CAS and ISA working OK, except for a couple of weaker teams falling away.
BUT, why not a revitalised waratah shield that everyone is in? Start it early and it replaces the trials. Can settle each year who the best first XV side really is.
Footy248
Peter Burge (5)
9. Chandler smith? Would be even be playing 1st 9 at barker
5. James finegan, yr 11 next year and just contributed to the CAS premiership for Waverley
Footy248
Peter Burge (5)
Yeah nuilala and meagher were both in yr12 just young for their yr so they are gone
046ballrunner
Peter Burge (5)
i said him mate
james richards
Allen Oxlade (6)
My bad i didn't see him
BRUMBIEJACK
Larry Dwyer (12)
Can I be a bit judgmental about both of you using the incorrect spelling of the word judgmental ?
james richards
Allen Oxlade (6)
can I be counter judgemental and tell you to check your spelling before trying to 'correct' people...cheers. nice try jack better juck next time
Halfbackenthusiast
Ted Fahey (11)
Barker predicted XV
1. Nick Hill (1st)
2. Ethan Kotarac (1st)
3. Keegan Daly(1st)
4. ?
5. ?
6. Thomas(1st)
7. Rous(1s/2s)
8. Talaileva (1sts)
9. Weaver (1sts)
10. Dene (1sts)
11. Chandler-Sullivan/Will Hargreaves
12.Chandler-Sullivan/Will Hargreaves
13. Matt Sentonaris (2nds)
14. Zander Ward(2nds)
15 Poynton
1. Nick Hill (1st)
2. Ethan Kotarac (1st)
3. Keegan Daly(1st)
4. ?
5. ?
6. Thomas(1st)
7. Rous(1s/2s)
8. Talaileva (1sts)
9. Weaver (1sts)
10. Dene (1sts)
11. Chandler-Sullivan/Will Hargreaves
12.Chandler-Sullivan/Will Hargreaves
13. Matt Sentonaris (2nds)
14. Zander Ward(2nds)
15 Poynton
Footy head
Ward Prentice (10)
dean and caswell would be in there as they did play in that team this year in year 10
Penriff_boy
Billy Sheehan (19)
Good on them, that's the best news I've heard for a while
Ziggy
Herbert Moran (7)
If you can't beat them, join them
JohnnyOhns
Peter Burge (5)
Cranbrook's 2nd XV 9 (Marchant, year 11) this year was outstanding, I think he was better than the 1st XV 9 for Cranbrook (which understandably sounds stupid), he may very well have a good shot at this, as well as Jed Smith, playing CAS 2's last year (out of his preferred position) and still putting up a solid performance. Tovio should be a given at 12 or 13, going into his 3rd year of 1st XV rugby next year.