QLD GPS Rugby 2017
- Thread starter Hilltop View
- Start date
- Status
John Locke
Bob McCowan (2)
NC Team list - Might have wrong numbers i.e. second rowers wrong way round or wingers
1. Harry Vella
2. Tom Forde
3. Phransis Siasiola
4. Cayle Manu
5. Matt Englebrecht
6. Ethan Bullemore
7. Hayden Mosely
8. Bailey Tautau
9. Phoenix Hunt (c)
10. Reesjan Pasitoa
11. Ryan Shepherd
12. Joe Small
13. Tom Blackmore
14. Ethan Robbins
15. Jangala Bennett
1. Harry Vella
2. Tom Forde
3. Phransis Siasiola
4. Cayle Manu
5. Matt Englebrecht
6. Ethan Bullemore
7. Hayden Mosely
8. Bailey Tautau
9. Phoenix Hunt (c)
10. Reesjan Pasitoa
11. Ryan Shepherd
12. Joe Small
13. Tom Blackmore
14. Ethan Robbins
15. Jangala Bennett
fairplay
Johnnie Wallace (23)
Best game this year
Oracle83
Ron Walden (29)
Enjoyable game in difficult conditions - congrats to NC always know how to grind out a victory - BBC dearly miss not having a goal kicker which was the difference in both this match and the TSS one having scored more tries but conceding a loss.
BBC won 12A / 13A / 14A & 15A against undoubted the strongest GPS school - great effort indeed.
John Locke
Bob McCowan (2)
Once again, Nudgee had a few tough calls in the 1st XV, particularly with the 1st try. If you watch the replay, the ball boy gives the ball to the hooker, and then they take a quick line out. This is against the rules as there must be no interference in a quick line out. It's in the rule 19.2 c, which reads, "For a quick throw-in, the player must use the ball that went into touch. A quick throw-in is not permitted if another person has touched the ball apart from the player throwing it in and an opponent who carried it into touch. The same team throws into the line out."
Just Watching
Bob McCowan (2)
Yes, very dominant in the line out except for the very last line out when it mattered. BBC mess of it.
Why didn't they take the 3 penalty kick opportunities instead of the line out?
Just Watching
Bob McCowan (2)
Just Watching
Bob McCowan (2)
Correct! Had a discussion with a parent on the sideline about the same rule.
Also, BBC 3rd try, the wingers foot was out before he placed the ball over the line. Come on touches, open your eyes and learn the rules!
Oracle83
Ron Walden (29)
Try opening your other eye and show some dignity at the same time
Just Watching
Bob McCowan (2)
That will work too
I play wing
Chris McKivat (8)
A quick lineout is not a quick throw-in! Very big difference between the two.
In the case of a quick lineout you can use whatever ball you want.
In the case of a quick throw-in (which is in reference to a quick pass-in when somebody [usually a winger] passes it back into play) you can't.
Blue & white
Billy Sheehan (19)
Whoops! NC lucky to get away with that one.
None of us on the hill could work out why:
1) BBC knock back 2 easy penalties-1right in front;
2)You have three 5 mtr scrums & big number 8 does not run once;
3) last lineout of the match & you throw to back of lineout ??-when your 2 was winning all day
NC defence magnificent.NC 7 my MOM -outplayed his Aussie A counterpart
None of us on the hill could work out why:
1) BBC knock back 2 easy penalties-1right in front;
2)You have three 5 mtr scrums & big number 8 does not run once;
3) last lineout of the match & you throw to back of lineout ??-when your 2 was winning all day
NC defence magnificent.NC 7 my MOM -outplayed his Aussie A counterpart
John Locke
Bob McCowan (2)
For a line out to form, there must be two people from each team. There was no way it could possibly be a line out, therefore, it is a throw in.
Digby2016
Ward Prentice (10)
Yes-Parents on sideline always know more than a super 15 referee.What a crock
- Status