RC4 - Australia v Argentina
- Thread starter Hawko
- Start date
- Status
Slim 293
Stirling Mortlock (74)
Pocock always makes a huge difference to the team..........
The others will be an improvement but I don't think they'll provide much dramatic change..........
In fact, I feel like Coleman's grip on being our first choice lock is tenuous at best.
Still, I'd return him to the starting lineup to partner with Arnold, and have Rodda come off the bench.
Anyways, if all fit I wouldn't make too many changes........ and although Cheika is going to rerun the Beale/To'omua combination I would reverse the jersey numbers.
Korobeite and Maddocks haven't been very good and I would give Banks his first start.
Tupou might be worth starting too.........
The others will be an improvement but I don't think they'll provide much dramatic change..........
In fact, I feel like Coleman's grip on being our first choice lock is tenuous at best.
Still, I'd return him to the starting lineup to partner with Arnold, and have Rodda come off the bench.
Anyways, if all fit I wouldn't make too many changes........ and although Cheika is going to rerun the Beale/To'omua combination I would reverse the jersey numbers.
Korobeite and Maddocks haven't been very good and I would give Banks his first start.
Tupou might be worth starting too.........
No room for Les Makin?
Slim 293
Stirling Mortlock (74)
Sure, he had a strong performance against the Rays on the weekend.......... but personally, I would lean towards Tupou and AAA.
Brumby Runner
David Wilson (68)
I think Tupou will be a doubtful starter against the Argies. Even if passed fit, I think he should be rested for this game to give his neck time to get over the pounding it took on the weekend.
Poey straight back in if fit, but the back row should then be Tui, Pocock, Samu (or Timu). And yes, that will be a significant improvement.
Poey straight back in if fit, but the back row should then be Tui, Pocock, Samu (or Timu). And yes, that will be a significant improvement.
Quick Hands
David Wilson (68)
Pocock aside, there are many on these threads who think our team is better with that half of the team out.
If fit, I'm sure that Pocock and Folau will come back in and most likely Coleman.
Who goes out and where people play (particularly in the backs) are slightly more difficult to predict.
Slim 293
Stirling Mortlock (74)
Scratch that..........
I just noticed you named him in the TOTW - get him into camp Wallaby stat!
Swain, JJH and Taliauli too............
A mutterer
Chilla Wilson (44)
Says a lot that the saffa thread is receiving more attention and posts than the upcoming bargies game on the weekend.
Derpus
George Gregan (70)
Strewthcobber
Mark Ella (57)
Hopefully the Argies have ditched the diving and histrionic part of their game which made this test match the one I look forward to least every year
I'm not sure there's that much to say in advance of the test.
I think the team will be largely the same except with Folau, Pocock and Coleman returning and Samu, Rodda and Maddocks dropping back to the bench.
Hanigan, Banks and Simmons to drop out of the 23.
Derpus
George Gregan (70)
If Tupou is fit he should start. He was crucial last match. He should have more than 20 minutes to make an impression.
Strewthcobber
Mark Ella (57)
35 mins on the weekend!
I don't mind the tactic we're starting to see where front row is replaced at 30-35 mins and then re-replaced at 70-75 mins so we have fresh players at the end of each half.
Goes against the spirit of the game - but if the rules allow it......
Was it entirely intentional though?
Didn't it mean that Joe Powell couldn't get on because we'd already made all our substitutions and we could only finish with 15 players because an HIA was needed at the end rather than an injury replacement?
Strewthcobber
Mark Ella (57)
Hodge replaced Koro at 75mins after TPN replaced FF (Folau Fainga'a) at 71 mins so there was at least an opportunity to get Powell on.
We made 10 substitutions in total including the HIAs (and blood?)
I'm guessing only the staff knows how genuine all of those replacements were.
I'd need to rewatch it to see the reasonings of the last two.
TPN replacing FF (Folau Fainga'a) would have counted as a substitution and then my thinking is that Hodge can't get back on for Koroibete or Hanigan for Arnold unless they were blood/HIA.
By that point Powell could have only got on for Genia if he'd had a blood/HIA issue.
I also think Phipps will be straight back in for Powell assuming his ribs are now right.
TPN could get swapped out but it would be surprising to see him miss the 23 seeing as he was brought back from the UK.
TPN could get swapped out but it would be surprising to see him miss the 23 seeing as he was brought back from the UK.
Strewthcobber
Mark Ella (57)
If Arnold came off again for an HIA after coming back on for Rodda at 68mins after his initial assessment, there's some serious questions that need to be asked......
Here's what I think it is.
1. 34' TPN off, FF (Folau Fainga'a) on
2. 42' Rodda off, Simmons on (Rodda stays off > 15 minutes with his dislocated finger so this is a permanent replacement, not blood)
3. 48' AAA off, Tupou on
HIA 59' Arnold off, Rodda on
4. 62' Maddocks off, Foley on
HIA return 68' Arnold on Rodda off
5. 69' Hodge off, Banks on
6. 70' Robertson on, Sio off
7. 72' FF (Folau Fainga'a) off, TPN on
8. 76' Koro off, Hodge on
9. Arnold off, Hanigan on (Arnold had a back or leg injury)
I genuinely can't work out how they were allowed to bring Hodge back on. Hodge going off certainly seemed tactical and you are only meant to be able to bring on a tactically replaced player for an HIA/blood/foul play injury and Koroibete didn't appear to be any of those.
- Status