Wallabies 2023
- Thread starter RugbyReg
- Start date
Mr Pilfer
Bob Loudon (25)
Just for a laugh this is how we could run a 7-1 bench against the saffas in a World Cup semi for example
16 - Matt Faesler
17 - James Slipper
18 - Pone
19 - Matt Phillip
20 - Rob Leota
21 - Langi Gleeson
22 - Josh Kemeny
23 - Isaac Fines-Leleiwasa
Actually don’t mind it
16 - Matt Faesler
17 - James Slipper
18 - Pone
19 - Matt Phillip
20 - Rob Leota
21 - Langi Gleeson
22 - Josh Kemeny
23 - Isaac Fines-Leleiwasa
Actually don’t mind it
Squidge seems good at deciphering attacking patterns. I find it impossible from watching TV in real time since the camera never gives you a full picture of the field. And I'm not rewinding and watching a game 5x.
Less so in terms of individual players, defense, set piece, how a plan fits with personnel, officiating etc.
There's so little rugby media that it's way better than nothing. I find his "narrative" and one reason explanations as to why XYZ won/lost to be a bit simplistic though and I avoid watching him to avoid adopting this overly narrow perspective.
Less so in terms of individual players, defense, set piece, how a plan fits with personnel, officiating etc.
There's so little rugby media that it's way better than nothing. I find his "narrative" and one reason explanations as to why XYZ won/lost to be a bit simplistic though and I avoid watching him to avoid adopting this overly narrow perspective.
That's basically my main critique of EJ (Eddie Jones). Seems like he said ah screw the 23 RWC I'll bleed all the young guys at once.
I have no problem with T.Hooper, Tate, Vunivalu, Gordon, Donaldson, McReight getting opportunity, but it seems like overkill. And not a recipe for being successful this RWC.
Adam84
Nick Farr-Jones (63)
Is Tate really an example of “bleed all the young guys at once”?
He is as a surefire starter currently and I believe he was even co-captain. So it is a rung higher than I think he should be. I'd have Nic White as the starter and Tate as the reserve 9.
He obviously had played for the Wallabies before Jones, but his role wasn't nearly as prominent.
I'd say the same thing about T.Hooper. Have him in the squad, sure, but he shouldn't be starting the big matches unless he knocks the house down. Which he hasn't.
Tomthumb
Colin Windon (37)
Tom Hooper has knocked the house down more than any other 6 we have had in the last 3 years
Awful take. Very silly.
We'll see how it goes. The current approach is 0-5. There's a reason most teams don't start completely inexperienced players in the RWC.
I think posters here are judging many of the young players through the lens of "for a young player" not "for a RWC starter."
Which is only fair to those players, but not an objective evaluation.
And I do think most the young guys identified by Jones are the future, I just don't think they are the best options for the present, at least not in the roles they've been given.
The Phoenix
Sydney Middleton (9)
Huge risk. I vaguely remember a game a few years ago when Michael Hooper had to play in the centres because of injuries during the match. If anyone would be suited to centres it would be Hooper you would think but it was a disaster because his positioning in defence was terrible. That is the biggest problem for a forward in the backs, not attack, but defence.
Tomthumb
Colin Windon (37)
No, posters here are judging players off the other options avaliable
If we had a Jerome Kaino, we wouldn't be playing Tom Hooper
If we had a Fourie Du Preez, we wouldn't be playing Tate McDermott
SouthernX
Peter Johnson (47)
Interesting to see Seru Uru is for a second week in a row playing #7 for the barbarians
Is there any rugby australia directive about what positions player play for barbarians?
If so - you can bank on Uru being one of the first forwards being drafted into wallabies should injury strike…
Very versatile lineout option 4, 5, 6, 7, 8
Is there any rugby australia directive about what positions player play for barbarians?
If so - you can bank on Uru being one of the first forwards being drafted into wallabies should injury strike…
Very versatile lineout option 4, 5, 6, 7, 8
Derpus
George Gregan (70)
I really rate him but it'll be dire times if Uru is lining up in the second row at any point for the Wallabies. He was serviceable at best when forced there for the Reds.
He's much better playing loose.
They do have Nic White and Holloway.
You don't need to be Kaino or Dupont to be better than current versions of T.Hooper/Tate. And I quite like both players. I just don't think they should be starting or at minimum the starting 15 should not have quite so many inexperienced players.
But hey I hope I'm wrong and we'll know soon enough.
Tomthumb
Colin Windon (37)
Stop this, the man has never played a good test match
griffins
Bill Watson (15)
Holloway played some decent games at the end of last year I thought, but he has certainly never played a test match anywhere near as good as T Hooper in Dunedin last month.
rodha
Dave Cowper (27)
Eddie is going down the youth path, a pretty concerning approach to take leading into a world cup, cleaning out the experienced heads & stronger personalities, just as Robbie did going into 2011, and the team subsequently fizzled under the weight of pressure, Genia 23, Cooper 23, Ioane 24, Pocock 22, McCabe 23, Fainga'a 24, Beale 22, Bieber 21 - they would've stood a better chance with mentally strong seasoned veterans Giteau and G.Smith starting at 12 and 7, two of Australia's greatest ever, and Robbie sent them packing, in their prime, aged 28! They should've finished up as the two most capped Wallabies ever. An outright national travesty that should never have allowed to happen.
Last edited: