Voldemort
Frank Row (1)
I am getting the same problem with cluch, but I was at the Kings V Shore game sitting in my car on the hill. Almost got bogged.
Play on,
Voldemort
NSW AAGPS 2022
- Thread starter Joker
- Start date
- Status
Play on,
Voldemort
O
Old High Boy
Guest
I have seen this error before, in the early trial rounds this season - knowing IT, the error states that its an access issue, which means that the permissions have not been set correctly (or have changed) for this video on the Cluch server; last time this occurred, it was fixed during the working week, so I assume the same will happen with this one.
If not, then we will know that the school(s) have asked for it not to be accessible to general Cluch subscribers, for whatever reason...
BringTheBiff
Peter Burge (5)
couldn't agree more, many dirty plays from kings against shore that must be reviewed!!
O
Old High Boy
Guest
We don't need another official - sitting with the cluch TV crew - checking foul play, etc
They can't even get that right on the International stage, so what hopes do we have for local schoolboy rugby?! And with only 1st XV having extra game time available, all games wouldn't finish until early evening...
The chance of this happening is - Buckleys...
What I believe should be implemented immediately is having the touchies/ ARs wired up to talk to the ref for 1st XV, and possibly 2nd XV matches. These specialised comms units have come down in price in recent years, but they can still be expensive, and do require looking after/ maintenance
Shute Shield, 1st Colts, Subbies Div 1 1st grade, and Subbies Div 2 1st grade matches all currently have the ARs wired up to chat to the referee - its time for the schools to do likewise..
Last edited by a moderator:
Alright.....let me step in here.
As one of the wise old owls in this tree I and others have all seen this before. Accusations made agaisnt a school can get out of hand and then you have another person jump in and then it is a free for all. There is a difference between slander and banter (which I know well)
slander
the action or crime of making a false spoken statement damaging to a person's reputation.
example. XXXXX are a bunch of filthy cheating players.
banter.
the playful and friendly exchange of teasing remarks.
example. XXXXX boys often find it hard to park daddy's Roll Royce in the staff car park.
If you don't wish to be banned and feel Cyclopaths wrath, for goodness sake let this go. Even if we see the video eventually, remember SCHOOLS will also be watching this. In the spirit of the AAGPS lets try to not start a flame war between schools. We are better then this.
Last edited:
StanniesLineout
Frank Row (1)
Can someone explain to me why Joeys No.7 does not shake hands at the start of the game. Very disrespectful to the opposition.
A question many would like answered. He does though shake hands at the end of the game and even help opposition players on the field at times. Only he can answer.
Shore people please move on. I saw the aggression from 1sts to 3rds from both sides and yes maybe some boys should have been carded (and some that were carded should not have been) BUT this is another example of probably a very small number of people from your school community not respecting the referees and the result of schoolboy sport.
Black & White
Vay Wilson (31)
My apologies Ace Ventura, but as New supporter, I was deeply appreciative of your kind and supportive comments.
As do we from you. Good karma came from this match for both schools. BTW.....Wyvern Boy has vanished. Any ideas? I was looking forward to reading his analysis of the game. We need talented people here to continue the discussion
Armchair Selector
Johnnie Wallace (23)
Oh dear! Please lets not go there. It is school sport. Not entertainment for OUR gratification.
Referees for 1st, 2nds and 3rds are appointed by NSW Referees on a merit system. They are coached, assessed and graded for future appointments. Referees want to put in a good performance too! Comments to the contrary are ill informed and ignorant and in fact do a disservice to all those referees who give up their time to give the players the best experience of the sport they are capable of facilitating.
If any school sports master feels aggrieved that an incident goes unpunished on the field, they are welcome to cite a player off video footage to the AAGPS for a judiciary hearing. It happens, key board warriors, they just dont tell the parents! Normally resolved amicably between sportsmasters. Any Red card is dealt with via the AAGPS Judiciary.
Can we also clear up a few other things that that the ill informed need to understand before posting.
Throw a punch that connects = red card (doesnt matter why)
If the punch misses, penalty (foul play) likely a yellow card and a stern warning.
There is no such thing as "accidental" in foul play. There are sanction RC, YC or penalty. A referee can only grade the sanction down by one level if there are extenuating circumstances contributed by the other player, (changing direction, falling etc). Poor technique isnt an excuse
You can have a head clash/injury where neither player is at fault. An injury to one player doesnt give a right to a penalty or sanction to another.
An AR/touch judge may not enter the field of play unless invited by the referee.
I would highly recommend those who are so keen to complain on this forum about refereeing take the time and do a few courses. You will enjoy the game a lot more and gain a much better understanding of what is going on. You also may get your step count up on a saturday and give back to the sport you are so passionate about and your school and community.
KOB1987
John Eales (66)
That is incorrect, the 3rds were refereed by a regular prominent referee, don’t know his name. The 6ths however were refereed by a Kings teacher in gum boots as the appointed referee did a no show.
Black & White
Vay Wilson (31)
Hello Joker
Good to see standards are being set. Several years ago, we had a number of nutters, who just wanted to talk crap and used Green & Gold. as a venue for their unbalanced agendas, against certain schools. Good to see those days are behind us.
RugbyWatcher.
Frank Row (1)
The 3rds referee is one of the two Sargents at the kings school, not exactly a teacher but still works for the school.
Greenwhiteblack
Banned
seriously? its a game of schoolboy rugby with nothing on the line except some bragging by rich old men who are struggling to let go of a school they went to for 6 years and left 30 years ago....
Goosestep
Jim Clark (26)
Can you explain why you care? …geez
Scrum.Doctor
Frank Row (1)
That may be the case. I think this discussion about the 3rd XV referee needs to stop. He made both right and wrong calls on both sides, as many refs do at this stage. Nonetheless, the Kings School team were dominant in this match. Well deserved win.
AroundTheAnkles
Banned
Who knows, however, given the way he plays (hard but fair) and ends the game (with a handshake and all the other normal respectful things) why does it matter?
Do you recall "Sportal".....that was the centre of all filth and slander. I left there in 2010 and found this place.
O
Old High Boy
Guest
Just adding the table for the 3rd XV, as it stands from the weekend results - there are many supporters for these schools and how they are going in this comp...
copied from here:
And many thanks to INP for his regular match updates, its greatly appreciated
Last edited by a moderator:
- Status