• Welcome to the Green and Gold Rugby forums. As you can see we've upgraded the forums to new software. Your old logon details should work, just click the 'Login' button in the top right.

NSW AAGPS Rugby 2015

Who will win GPS 2015?


  • Total voters
    192
Status
Not open for further replies.

Beard

Allen Oxlade (6)
I suspect we'll see a few of those boys in firsts next year. Both wingers were big, athletic and fast and the 5/8 controlled the game very well, and in fact I'd struggle to find a weakness in the team anywhere.

QH, I think you're right the Yr11 boys that have played in this side will go onto much bigger things, as Lee Grant said Patmore is one to watch, McAlinden who played 2nds yesterday and the young fullback Adam Tse all just good young backs, but there are a couple of piggies in the pack that have been impressive. Crotti as 2 has been there all year and has come on in leaps and bounds, but for me Jack Spooner at 5 has been a revelation, been up in the Thirsties from the 4ths for a while now big, quiet Lurch style second rower, just old school and brutal.. I think he has really enjoyed his time beside a group of Yr12 brawlers.

All in all Joeys have just seen the benefits from another strong cohort in 2015, while the successful 3rds have had a litany of changes due to injuries above, they have benefitted from an undefeated 4th's 5ths and 6ths behind them & being lucky enough to keep their captain and the core of their leadership group together and on the field all year.

They are also very well coached, old school bash and bruise style which they have thrived on.

Best quote I've ever heard from a coach after the Armidale game... ' you know you've done your job when the boys are enjoying their rugby when they DON'T have the ball'
 

Lee Grant

John Eales (66)
Staff member
Anyone have a team list for Joeys 3rds ?

As per programme only:

1. J. Behringer, 2. A. Crotti, 3. D. Fusimalohi, 4. I. Warfield (c), 5. J. Spooner, 6. M. Johnston, 7. L. Gibbs, 8. J. Lyons, 9. L. Collins, 10. T. O'Connor, 11. J. Patmore, 12. S. Sia, 13. J. Ashurst, 14, L. Ford, 15. A. Tse.


The seconds was the best match of the afternoon as both sides ran the ball from everywhere and the lead changed throughout. At one point it looked as though goal-kicking was going to win it for Joeys, but Kings held a 22-21 lead for the last 10 minutes before scoring on the bell to win 27-21 (or 29-21 - didn't see if the conversion went over).

Kings fullback best on the field for me, scored 2 tries and set up another one and always troubled the Joeys defence as well as being rock solid in defence.

Luke Osborne was terrific - though a fullback he ran the ball a bit like Kennewell, the Newington centre, and with a SBW pass that was always on the money - when he needed to pass.

What year is he in ??
.
 

Azzuri

Trevor Allan (34)
As per programme only:

1. J. Behringer, 2. A. Crotti, 3. D. Fusimalohi, 4. I. Warfield (c), 5. J. Spooner, 6. M. Johnston, 7. L. Gibbs, 8. J. Lyons, 9. L. Collins, 10. T. O'Connor, 11. J. Patmore, 12. S. Sia, 13. J. Ashurst, 14, L. Ford, 15. A. Tse.




Luke Osborne was terrific - though a fullback he ran the ball a bit like Kennewell, the Newington centre, and with a SBW pass that was always on the money - when he needed to pass.

What year is he in ??
.

Osbourne is in Y11
 

Loose Carry

Peter Burge (5)
Very enjoyable afternoon up at Hunters Hill.

Only one way to describe Joeys 3rds - impressive, very impressive. 76-0 victory against a Kings side that never gave up despite Joeys being bigger, faster and more skilful. That Joeys 3rds side were good from 1-15 and would beat most schools seconds teams (including their own I suspect) and would also give a few 1sts teams some trouble (across the 3 associations). I should add that Joeys played the last 20 minutes with 13 players - they took players off as the score mounted in some sort of unofficial mercy rule and still dominated.


I know that there are some big supporters of the 3rd XV competition here which is great. Having been able to watch all three grades for the last couple of weeks (something that is unfortunately too rare of an opportunity) one thing that is clear is the big difference between the grades. The step up from 2nds to 1sts is significant, especially the physicality and speed of the games. The step up from 3rds to 2nds is just as big, possibly bigger. Success in a 3rds comp (where the quality of opposition is reduced radically by lack of depth at some schools) does not guarantee success of a 3rds team at the 2nds level. To try and compare teams playing in these very different quality comps is probably missing the mark.
 

Quick Hands

David Wilson (68)
I know that there are some big supporters of the 3rd XV competition here which is great. Having been able to watch all three grades for the last couple of weeks (something that is unfortunately too rare of an opportunity) one thing that is clear is the big difference between the grades. The step up from 2nds to 1sts is significant, especially the physicality and speed of the games. The step up from 3rds to 2nds is just as big, possibly bigger. Success in a 3rds comp (where the quality of opposition is reduced radically by lack of depth at some schools) does not guarantee success of a 3rds team at the 2nds level. To try and compare teams playing in these very different quality comps is probably missing the mark.
Normally I would agree with you, but I suspect these guys are a grade above their opponents - as evidenced by the for and against.

Noting also that they have already beaten the 1st XV of three schools, and would easily account for Pius, and Gregs in ISA. Suspect they would also trouble the bottom couple of CAS schools.
 

Will Cooper

Bob McCowan (2)
The Scots vs View game did not disappoint! the comeback kids were, in my mind, not in doubt of loosing. There was no way the likes of Girlder, Smith, Strang, Woods and other year 12 veterans were going to let go of their 2nd potential premiership. Young guns Nic Shannon was on fire with the boot and ball scoring a remarkable try under the sticks and Harry Todd took 2 or 3 missed tackles to get into the game but when he did he surely made up for it! Cant wait to see the boys in Gold continue their unstoppable form into the last round and in future seasons.
 

Cash

Sydney Middleton (9)
Normally I would agree with you, but I suspect these guys are a grade above their opponents - as evidenced by the for and against.

Noting also that they have already beaten the 1st XV of three schools, and would easily account for Pius, and Gregs in ISA. Suspect they would also trouble the bottom couple of CAS schools.

You might be understating it a little, especially given the strength of the GPS comparatively. I'd back the Joeys 3rds to beat every single CAS school (except maybe possibly Knox), given that they were able to beat Grammar, who won against Trinity earlier in the year, and lost closely to Cranbrook with an understrengthened side. As for the ISA, they'd be capable of beating Kinross, Gregs and Pius, very possibly Pats and even perhaps Stannies.
 

Beard

Allen Oxlade (6)
You might be understating it a little, especially given the strength of the GPS comparatively. I'd back the Joeys 3rds to beat every single CAS school (except maybe possibly Knox), given that they were able to beat Grammar, who won against Trinity earlier in the year, and lost closely to Cranbrook with an understrengthened side. As for the ISA, they'd be capable of beating Kinross, Gregs and Pius, very possibly Pats and even perhaps Stannies.

This current Joeys 3rds side did put 11 tries on Greg's 1st XV in a trial & did beat Pats 2nd's by 50+ the week they had the bye
 

Inside Shoulder

Nathan Sharpe (72)
Normally I would agree with you, but I suspect these guys are a grade above their opponents - as evidenced by the for and against.

Noting also that they have already beaten the 1st XV of three schools, and would easily account for Pius, and Gregs in ISA. Suspect they would also trouble the bottom couple of CAS schools.

Add to that the Grammar 1s beat Trinity 1s and were a lot closer to Cranbrook 1s than they were to SJC 3rds and you have the makings of a fair argument, IMO
 

Cash

Sydney Middleton (9)
Speaking of Grammar, they play High this week. One of the great rivalries in GPS sport. If anyone goes, I'd love to see the team lists.
 

Crackerjack

Bill Watson (15)
For Cash & Co...

Riverview vs Scots

A 'game played in two halves', if ever there was one. A 12-try "Festival of the Boot", 7 tries to 5.

T'was a scratchy start from both sides, with "dropsies" and offside penalties killing early momentum.

View settled first, and off early dominant displays in the set pieces, View scored twice including half Josh Noonan (9) going all 'Cool Hand Luke', using the Ref as a shield on a scrum base dart to the try line. (More clearly seen from the endzone rather than side-on, but Max Girdler should keep a copy of Sidesteppa's video of Noonan's try at Post#2545 on Page 128 to replay any time he needs to get himself fiiiiiired up!) 14-0 View lead, early.

Scots' dam-buster OC James Hawkins (13), crossed 20' in, and Scots had finally stirred up the scoreboard attendants.

View steadied again, and hooker Alex Hamilton (2), working in concert with locks Nicholas Tracy (4) and Michael Fenn (5), had the View lineout fairly 'humming' along. View were backing their set piece, declining kickable penalty shots, taking attacking lineouts deep in Scots' red zone, and setting up rolling-mauls to the line. View's blindside flanker Chris Scott (6) went in off one, and with only 4' to oranges, View repeated the dose with rake Hamilton (2) scoring.

View were up 26-7, Newington's spotters were busily texting across to Northbridge that the action at Lane Cove was not going according to script, and oddly, despite their team's healthy lead, the home crowd was pretty quiet. Even the Riverview bass drum was eerily silent. No-one willing to dare the upset to actually be 'on'?

On the stroke of halftime, Scots spread the Gilbert to John Eales-mimic, McCauley (5), who crossed wide out in heavy traffic, and Scots were still in this at oranges, down 26-12.

Scots have had a theme going most of this year of very strong 2nd halves, having been down at the half in recent weeks against top-shelf Newington and Joeys, but it was View that sprang from the blocks after the break, hammering Scots' line. Penalty shots declined; attacking lineouts; rolling mauls set up; pick and drives; a "held up" decision; and yet another 5m scrum, but View's first half dominant scrum had waned noticeably.

Scots clung on. Grimly and stoically. A sage nearby me observed "If Scots do win this, they can look back at their defensive effort right here on their line..." And he was not wrong.

Having wriggled out of their 22, the late great Wallabies Coach David Brockhoff would've enthused, "...like a shark through a school of mullet!", as OC Hawkins (13), Gilbert tucked under his wing, went in for his second.

Scots now had a sniff. Dylan Woods (2) and Charlie Smith (7) were everywhere, and with big Max Girdler (6) redeemed, running straight and hard, building platforms for more raiding.

In short order, Scots went from just having a sniff to cleaning house. In a devastating 10' spell, Scots scored in a thrice. Dan England (12) spinning like a whirling dervish on his way to the line. A clever Theo Strang (9) ball worked inside to flyhalf Dylan McLachlan (10) to go in, then Smith (7) popping another to ol' mate Girdler (6), who scored careening into the upright. Three quick tries, all converted by Nic Shannon (15), and Scots led 40-26, Coach Smith imploring his charges to "Stay on it!"

Indeed, they did. McLachlan's (10) toe ahead for Shannon (15) to fingertip regather at speed, like part of some Holden Precision Driving Team, smack between converging View defenders to score, and Scots went to safety, ahead 47-26. Still with 10' left, but this one was effectively 'dusted'.

View's replacement winger Malu Nona (16) (misspell that one and am sure you'll somehow get 'Jonah Lomu') ended the try-fest with a solo cameo down the left flank, converted, to give Scots a final scoreline, 47-33.

Full Time: Scots 47 def. Riverview 33

My 3, 2 and 1's will get posted later in Uncle Lee Grant's Schoolboy Rugby Blog, but this one was a tale of the two halves. Riverview living off their quality set pieces early, starving Scots of possession. But Scots never folding, digging in; the tide finally turning with their gutsy 5 minute long goal-line stand early in the second stanza, to then get clear air and run a bit amok on the scoreboard...

80 pts total in 70'... A Festival of the Boot, indeed.

Cheers to all the lads boys for putting on such a show.

(Am looking forward to watching Steppa's vid posted above. Will show me all the bits I missed!!)
 

Cash

Sydney Middleton (9)
Another 13 try game at Riverview, and just like last year they had a good lead at half-time, only for Scots to pull it all back.

Great work as usual Sidesteppa.

From the footage, Scots look like an unassailably coherent unit in attack, and some of their tries are absolutely gorgeous. Their forwards can act as distributors and their backs can act as ball runners; they're a team of skilled athletes. Prindiville and McGregor were noticeably absent, anyone know what's happened to either?
 

Not in straight

Vay Wilson (31)
You might be understating it a little, especially given the strength of the GPS comparatively. I'd back the Joeys 3rds to beat every single CAS school (except maybe possibly Knox), given that they were able to beat Grammar, who won against Trinity earlier in the year, and lost closely to Cranbrook with an understrengthened side. As for the ISA, they'd be capable of beating Kinross, Gregs and Pius, very possibly Pats and even perhaps Stannies.

Stannies?? NOT A CHANCE and Kinross, Very unlikely
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top