• Welcome to the Green and Gold Rugby forums. As you can see we've upgraded the forums to new software. Your old logon details should work, just click the 'Login' button in the top right.

Scotland v Australia - Sunday 26 November 1:30am AEDT

Status
Not open for further replies.

chasmac

Dave Cowper (27)
Best team should be selected.
After all the work they did getting fit back in June, it would be a waste to select a mix and match team.
Plus they need some revenge on the Scots.
Full team and full gameplan.
 

Derpus

George Gregan (70)
I know Cheik loves the ball in hand. But in the rain and with Koro on the wing, why don't we just constantly up and under like the poms do?
 

Up the Guts

Steve Williams (59)
Because it’s not in foleys skill set

What I noticed in the absence of Foley when we played Japan was that Hodge could bomb it into the stratosphere, although his accuracy could use a little work at times, so he could make up for Foley's lack of skills. The only problem is that Hodge defends in the line and Foley drops back to receive kicks so it limits the chances Hodge has to bomb it off kick receipts. If we could sort this issue out it may give us a potent change up weapon on counter next year as you'd have the best guy in the air, Israel, under bombs from a guy with one of the largest boots in world rugby. It'd also be pretty shit to be standing under a high ball as you heard Koroibete violently tearing up the turf as he charged towards you.
 

Viking

Mark Ella (57)
What I noticed in the absence of Foley when we played Japan was that Hodge could bomb it into the stratosphere, although his accuracy could use a little work at times, so he could make up for Foley's lack of skills. The only problem is that Hodge defends in the line and Foley drops back to receive kicks so it limits the chances Hodge has to bomb it off kick receipts. If we could sort this issue out it may give us a potent change up weapon on counter next year as you'd have the best guy in the air, Israel, under bombs from a guy with one of the largest boots in world rugby. It'd also be pretty shit to be standing under a high ball as you heard Koroibete violently tearing up the turf as he charged towards you.

Koro is pretty great at timing his runs too.
 

lou75

Ron Walden (29)
Scotland are a much improved side and will be tough to beat at home. There could be plenty of pain headed our way.

agree and they played a close game to the AB too, so barring any obvious injuries from that - they have tasted blood and are ready for the kill
 

Joe Blow

Peter Sullivan (51)
By all accounts Tui is fit. Slide him in next to Simmons and I assume that McCalman will come into the back row.
A beefed up pack from the one that matched England.
 

fatprop

George Gregan (70)
Staff member
By all accounts Tui is fit. Slide him in next to Simmons and I assume that McCalman will come into the back row.
A beefed up pack from the one that matched England.
We need more balance in the locks, last week we had two technicians who do a job, just the same job

Sent from my Moto G (4) using Tapatalk
 

Derpus

George Gregan (70)
Koro is pretty great at timing his runs too.

Still learning what to do when he gets there though. Cooked that try against England and some of his tackling is 50/50 (edit: as in, borderline dangerous. His tackling is fantastic).
 

wamberal

Phil Kearns (64)
agree and they played a close game to the AB too, so barring any obvious injuries from that - they have tasted blood and are ready for the kill


They were very impressive against the Darkness, they will give us a heap of trouble. Their tactical kicking was fantastic. It will be a wet track, I assume, and our pathetic kicking options will be our achilles heel, I fear.


When will they ever learn, when will they e-e-ever learn?


BTW, I grew up absolutely hating kicking in our game, there used to be far too much of it. But now it is pretty obvious that good, clever, accurate kicking is an absolutely crucial attribute of any top side. It is as simple as this: unless we can get a whole lot better at kicking, we will never, ever be consistent winners against the best international teams.
 

Up the Guts

Steve Williams (59)
Still learning what to do when he gets there though. Cooked that try against England and some of his tackling is 50/50 (edit: as in, borderline dangerous. His tackling is fantastic).

I still feel it's a little harsh to say we would have scored had he dived on the ball. The ball basically bounces at 90 degrees to where he was which is why he only got a feather on it with his boot. If he'd try to dive directly on it, he may well have missed it altogether given the bounce. Without that bounce of the ball he probably toes it over the try line and scores and no one even considers it being the wrong option.
 

Derpus

George Gregan (70)
They were very impressive against the Darkness, they will give us a heap of trouble. Their tactical kicking was fantastic. It will be a wet track, I assume, and our pathetic kicking options will be our achilles heel, I fear.


When will they ever learn, when will they e-e-ever learn?


BTW, I grew up absolutely hating kicking in our game, there used to be far too much of it. But now it is pretty obvious that good, clever, accurate kicking is an absolutely crucial attribute of any top side. It is as simple as this: unless we can get a whole lot better at kicking, we will never, ever be consistent winners against the best international teams.

Kicking is so crucial now because the game has become defence oriented. Back when, there was space to throw the ball around. Now you just run into a 350kg wall of half man meat/half human growth hormone. It's a problem really because watching Foley and Beale turd up catches constantly (despite it being nearly impossible to contest now given the safety 'issues') is pretty rage inducing.
(edit: now that humans are on average 30% larger than 10 years ago, they should widen the field)
 

RugbyReg

Rocky Elsom (76)
Staff member
(edit: now that humans are on average 30% larger than 10 years ago, they should widen the field)

Do you think that is legitimately feasible? Knock down Twickenham, Suncorp, Eden Park, Cardiff Arms etc and widen the fields?
 
T

TOCC

Guest
Kicking is so crucial now because the game has become defence oriented. Back when, there was space to throw the ball around. Now you just run into a 350kg wall of half man meat/half human growth hormone. It's a problem really because watching Foley and Beale turd up catches constantly (despite it being nearly impossible to contest now given the safety 'issues') is pretty rage inducing.
(edit: now that humans are on average 30% larger than 10 years ago, they should widen the field)

with increased size has also come increased acceleration, speed and agility through improved S&C programs, I don't know whether the game has become more defence orientated, it seems to ebb and flow in that regard.. But certainly its become more calculated and precise in execution
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top