KOB1987
Rod McCall (65)
Didn't want to quote the whole thing but great post Drew, well thought out.
Australian Rugby / RA
- Thread starter Dave Beat
- Start date
drewprint
John Solomon (38)
It’s such an important point. A mate of mine likens the NRL to a soap opera - there’s always drama, intrigue, constant content and developments, all drip fed basically daily. Which all creates a huge amount of fan engagement.
dru
Tim Horan (67)
Nice to see some clear thinking.
Look, I don't agree on the ANZAC linkage, nor do I agree on Super being the correct product. But we have apparently locked in a 10 year rugby sentence with Super. The proposal continues the top-down approach that has gotten us in this mess. I would actually prefer handing the keys to RA HQ to the SRU and say "go for it".
Better would be a National Comp with a local champion (a la Covid domestic series) would be far superior, followed by a shorter cross Tasman where the Aus teams go through a selection for say two teams (not unlike SOO). Have the Wallaby coaching team split and augmented with the National coaches for those rep teams. I guess that would be an Aus-centric pathway as who knows what impact in NZ.
If we are to follow more-or-less the current Super format, we are in trouble. It hasnt proven enough for funding 5 teams to success and shrinkage exacerbates the issue for the short term gain in quality and a dubious gain to the Wallabies. It is however fundamental that an on-going Super comp actively interupts the status quo to ensure a much less lop-sided comp. Talent availability and encouragement to move talent is key. Key to the comp. Perhaps not key to overall quality and the All Blacks. So good luck with imagining greatly improved behaviour from NZRU. But it is what we have.
It will shackle any domestic comp - even starting with the term "third tier" is a killer. Do they call the NRL "third tier"? It sits behind SOO and international afterall. Whether that comp is NRC-esq, or gives the SRU what they want with hangers-on, it really isnt logical to think it will truly flourish behind the "professional game" (Super) which likely wont be flourishing in Australia either.
Still, we appear locked -n and if no-one has the balls to put some TNT under Super, and a dose of
I would determinedly avoid any decisions that preclude or increase the difficulty of parting ways in the future or radically changing things in the future. SO I am not a supporter of independence of the comp. Additionally independence of the comp runs against centralisation within Australia.
FWIW From my POV any form of Super as the driving force to Australian rugby is another train hitting the previous train-wreck in slo mo. We have hit an inflection point, more of the same that got us here is, well insert your own adjective.
On a personal level, I really don't know where I now head with my rugby support. I am struggling to escape genuine indifference to the Wallabies and I'm highly unlikely to have a different view to any Super game involving a Kiwi team. If you genuinely support a Super product going forward you are going to be hoping there are few fans drifting this way. I am tempered a little but by a genuine interest in how Less Kiss goes at the Reds.
Three things have seriously impacted my support:
1. Shrink to greatness take #1
2. The Rennie European Tour (highlight Italy)
3. The EJ (Eddie Jones) RWC campaign
There is one common thread through that and one only - RA.
drewprint
John Solomon (38)
Thanks dru. Some really good points here, many of which I agree with too. Which is a contradiction isn’t it, given my lengthy original post? But it goes to show I don’t know the way forward either.
A big part of what I wrote goes forward on the premise at Super Rugby continues as been locked in. But like you I do wonder about what things would look like without it. I’ve been thinking a lot of about that too - burning everything down and starting again. Just have say 16 licenses, open 13 or them them up to the SRU and QPR clubs to pitch for, and enshrine Canberra, Melbourne, and Perth in it? Part of me does wonder whether this is best.
dru
Tim Horan (67)
It's not a contradiction at all, mate. I wouldn't be surprised right now, for genuine fans, that it is completely normal.
We are left as spectators of a sunk ship where the second rate officers have been replaced by the deck hands and baggage haulers. Nothing to do but sit back and wait out the next episode of #how to kill a code.
stillmissit
Chilla Wilson (44)
I read that McLennan is still banging his NRL player drum as of yesterday. Rich guys think they just have to throw good money after bad, even better if it's not theirs.Yeah, that'll do it.
The simplest thing to do would be to ensure the talented school kids are kept in the fold, at the moment we seem to have no idea who they are.
Last edited:
stillmissit
Chilla Wilson (44)
Interesting video on how France play like Eddie wanted us to with 3 phases and kick but he couldn't do it.
HooperPocockSmith
Bill Watson (15)
- We get dominated in the collisions
- Our accuracy at attacking breakdowns is woeful
- The kicking of our 9/10/15 leaves a lot to be desired
- Our set piece is hit-and-miss
- Worst discipline in World Rugby (not sure if the stats support this but it feels like it)
- We have very poor defensive structure(s)
Overall, I don't know if we have the discipline to play this type of rugby, and I'm not sure if the players know what the purpose of a strategy like this is. Also, we have blokes down in Coogee yelling from the top of Alison Rd that we need to play 'running rugby'. So, these tactics aren't taught /developed at lower levels.
EDIT: We also don't get anywhere near the same level of analysis on our broadcast. Hence, there's no challenge to the hegemonic tactics that pervade Australian rugby.
John S
Chilla Wilson (44)
For those getting a hard on about Campo coming back, here it is: https://www.smh.com.au/sport/rugby-...-must-be-held-to-account-20230927-p5e84s.html
There's a lot of "I have....." statements in there, a long with a "Rugby Australia has cancelled me" claim.
There's a lot of "I have....." statements in there, a long with a "Rugby Australia has cancelled me" claim.
Wilson
Michael Lynagh (62)
If they did it's one of the few things they've gotten right.
LeCheese
Peter Johnson (47)
From the rhetoric that's come out from ex-players still broadly aligned with RA following Campo's comments around Eddie, there is absolutely no chance he has even been considered. Thankfully.
John S
Chilla Wilson (44)
The thing that gets me - and the reason he can just make like a sheep and get the flock out of here - is that in that whole rant, there's a lot about "accountability" and saying people need to leave, and not very much other substance. Yeah, accountability is good in and of itself, but how do you manage it? What's the plan to actually move forward other than just kicking people out while we're down?
There's no plan, no solution. No wonder RA have at the least given him a cold shoulder. He's got to learn he needs to be in the tent pissing out, not outside the tent pissing into it.
Maybe he's presented a plan, and maybe RA haven't liked it - so stop whinging and saying they aren't listening - change/adapt. But he's too set in his tracks.
There's no plan, no solution. No wonder RA have at the least given him a cold shoulder. He's got to learn he needs to be in the tent pissing out, not outside the tent pissing into it.
Maybe he's presented a plan, and maybe RA haven't liked it - so stop whinging and saying they aren't listening - change/adapt. But he's too set in his tracks.
This is a good summary of where he's been for the last 20 years.
He's shown almost no interest at being inside the tent.
A couple of years ago he thought they should make him head coach of the Waratahs despite no involvement in anything over a long period of time and no relevant experience.
His MO for years has just been to have a dig when things aren't going well but offering absolutely nothing constructive to help solve the problems at hand.
noscrumnolife
Jimmy Flynn (14)
'Semi pro sport at best': Ex-Ireland HP manager's scathing critique of Aussie rugby, and dire warning for its future
The man who set up the high-performance systems in Scotland and Ireland has delivered a scathing critique of the apathy and factional landscape currently…
www.theroar.com.au
Great article. Both Byrne and Anderson have same thoughts re Super teams - not necessary to cut one. They (and other commentators) have changed my mind and I don't see it as necessary either. I think we are starting to see fruits from the Melbourne pathway, and I think it would be a mistake to exit WA. The NRL is looking to expand to 20 teams in the next 10 years. One thing is for certain - if there is no Force, there will 100% be a Perth NRL team.
It is borderline criminal how much Rugby IP we have let walk out of our doors and not listened to over the last twenty years.
Pfitzy
George Gregan (70)
Bernie probably has a more rounded view of how things should work in order to improve onfield performance.
All the adminstrators see is threats and job losses.
HooperPocockSmith
Bill Watson (15)
I'd love to see who actually got an interview for the position.'Semi pro sport at best': Ex-Ireland HP manager's scathing critique of Aussie rugby, and dire warning for its future
The man who set up the high-performance systems in Scotland and Ireland has delivered a scathing critique of the apathy and factional landscape currently…www.theroar.com.au
Great article. Both Byrne and Anderson have same thoughts re Super teams - not necessary to cut one. They (and other commentators) have changed my mind and I don't see it as necessary either. I think we are starting to see fruits from the Melbourne pathway, and I think it would be a mistake to exit WA. The NRL is looking to expand to 20 teams in the next 10 years. One thing is for certain - if there is no Force, there will 100% be a Perth NRL team.
It is borderline criminal how much Rugby IP we have let walk out of our doors and not listened to over the last twenty years.
Goosestep
Syd Malcolm (24)
'Semi pro sport at best': Ex-Ireland HP manager's scathing critique of Aussie rugby, and dire warning for its future
The man who set up the high-performance systems in Scotland and Ireland has delivered a scathing critique of the apathy and factional landscape currently…www.theroar.com.au
“I still think the answer in that underbelly lies within our current club structures where they have all their traditions and cultures and all that sort of stuff in place.”
Wilson
Michael Lynagh (62)
Take them off the invite list for the old boys dinners?