Scotland v Australia 12Nov16 Saturday
- Thread starter Kaz
- Start date
- Status
dru
Tim Horan (67)
Yes, actually astonishing.
Rugbynutter39
Michael Lynagh (62)
http://www.greenandgoldrugby.com/brian-smiths-analysis-back-to-the-future/#disqus_thread
Just read Brian Smith's analysis of Oz vs Scotland games. Really enjoy his blogs as learn so much more and also appreciate so much more the tactics and what some of the players put on the line which often miss in games.
Just read Brian Smith's analysis of Oz vs Scotland games. Really enjoy his blogs as learn so much more and also appreciate so much more the tactics and what some of the players put on the line which often miss in games.
ForceFan
Chilla Wilson (44)
High level of ruck involvements by Scotland’s Tight 5.
Wallabies missing Coleman’s contribution and Arnold well below his work rate from the Wales Test.
Wallabies Back Row showing their normal high work rate with good support from the Backs.
High level of involvement from Scotland’s Front Rowers including replacements.
Pocock and Hooper combined for 44% of Wallabies DRIs.
Scotland strongly committed to supporting own ball carriers and negating the impact of the Wallabies Back Row.
Wallabies standing off a large number of Defence Rucks.
Both sides reluctant to commit >1 player to Defence Rucks.
ForceFan
Chilla Wilson (44)
He clearly came on knowing what he had to do for the remaining 35 minutes.
His intercept tackle on the sideline was very impressive.
His 6 tackles in 35 mins places him with the Wallabies leading tacklers for this game.
R Gray was the only Lock who made any impact as a ball carrier.
ForceFan
Chilla Wilson (44)
Let's call it a "labour of love" because the Ruck Involvements are not available from anywhere else. Few of us have access to OPTA.
If anybody knows how to access this data for free would love to know about it.
The average test has 12 Scums, 24 Lineouts but 170 Rucks.
IMO, making calls on an individual player's performance, especially a Forward, without Ruck Data can be a bit problematic.
amirite
Chilla Wilson (44)
Do you have a pathway to making money with your analysis skill? I'm sure a Premier Grade coach would be happy to use your skills, from there who knows.
Hawko
Tony Shaw (54)
More to the point, about 70% of the game was played in the Scottish half. No good judge of a game of rugby would consider that stat to be a dominant performance by Scotland.
amirite
Chilla Wilson (44)
I think the Scotts have just really embraced 'the world is against us'.
In all fairness, plenty of Aussie fans do the same when the ABs beat us.
Rugbynutter39
Michael Lynagh (62)
Yes I don't think the scots are the only ones who play that game. Pi
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
ACT Crusader
Jim Lenehan (48)
No please not, I was really enjoying the riveting debate of whether it was 2 or 3 Hail Mary's that Folau threw. But most of all I never tire of hearing how Foley fails to do this and that, especially after a win
amirite
Chilla Wilson (44)
Foley isn't Dan Carter, and never will be, but it's funny to see how highly he's thought of in Europe and how poorly he's thought of in Aus.
Scotty
David Codey (61)
I don't think Foley is thought of poorly, just that he has some weaknesses that can be a problem in certain games. But he isn't the only one in the Wallabies.
As an aside DHP strikes me as a more natural 12 than Hodge, and could take a lot of pressure off Foley's kicking.
Also Hodges play at 12 is similar to Kerevi, so not sure why we could have a KK centre combo when he is back. Could be a scary prospect for opposition teams
As an aside DHP strikes me as a more natural 12 than Hodge, and could take a lot of pressure off Foley's kicking.
Also Hodges play at 12 is similar to Kerevi, so not sure why we could have a KK centre combo when he is back. Could be a scary prospect for opposition teams
amirite
Chilla Wilson (44)
DHP's strength is kick chase and Hodge's is kicking. I think they'd both get to do less of it if they switched roles.
I think it is the Steven Larkham effect, we seem to expect that every 10 should now chuck 15m miracle balls in each play.
PeterK
Alfred Walker (16)
Thanks to force fan I could work out total involvements.
Hooper’s work rate was down in the scotland game as it was in the Wales game.
Normally he is in the top 2 just behind Pocock.
Scotland game involvements of ball carries, tackles and rucks
Pocock – 70 (well ahead of anyone)
Simmons – 57
Hooper – 50 (just ahead of a hooker and behind a lock who played 8 mins less)
Moore – 47 (considering his scrum work load on top, this is very good).
Sio – 41
Timani – 39
Kepu – 37
Mumm – 36 (amazing for 35 mins work)
Arnold – 27
Adjusted to 83 mins (the lngth of the game) makes it worse for Hooper, just average involvements / workrate compared to the other forwards.
Mumm – 85
Pocock – 70
Simmons – 63
Timani – 53
Kepu – 50
Hooper – 50
Moore – 47
Sio – 47
Arnold – 47
It does seem like he needs a rest
Hooper’s work rate was down in the scotland game as it was in the Wales game.
Normally he is in the top 2 just behind Pocock.
Scotland game involvements of ball carries, tackles and rucks
Pocock – 70 (well ahead of anyone)
Simmons – 57
Hooper – 50 (just ahead of a hooker and behind a lock who played 8 mins less)
Moore – 47 (considering his scrum work load on top, this is very good).
Sio – 41
Timani – 39
Kepu – 37
Mumm – 36 (amazing for 35 mins work)
Arnold – 27
Adjusted to 83 mins (the lngth of the game) makes it worse for Hooper, just average involvements / workrate compared to the other forwards.
Mumm – 85
Pocock – 70
Simmons – 63
Timani – 53
Kepu – 50
Hooper – 50
Moore – 47
Sio – 47
Arnold – 47
It does seem like he needs a rest
formerflanker
Ken Catchpole (46)
Or the others have picked up their involvements and he doesn't have to carry the load himself.
There is also natural variation in terms of the sections of the field where play the majority of phases take place.
It seems like a good opportunity to give McMahon a crack against France though and freshen Hooper up for the last couple of tests.
It seems like a good opportunity to give McMahon a crack against France though and freshen Hooper up for the last couple of tests.
formerflanker
Ken Catchpole (46)
Agreed. Start Pocock at 7 to access his skills in that role. Hooper will have a big load in the last games on tour.
- Status