TYS Wallaby Player of the Year: v Boks

[RugbyReg]

Tough one for mine.

3 Robinson
2 Smith
1 Horwill

Am over Brown now. Not far behind with Burgo.

The bench were fantastic for us.

We just aren't good enough at the moment.

 

[louie]

3. Smith
2. Mum
1. Mitchell or O'Connor
mentions:
AAC (Adam Ashley-Cooper), Genia, Alexander, Robinson, Pocock


points taken away:
Burgo
Palu - we need someone with more of a skill set, ie hollies type
Sharpe
Turner - you made one good tackle other then that i didn't see you
Gits
Barnes - i don't think we need two play makers anymore.

 

[Spook]

Noddy, how on earth can you give any points to Horwill? The bloke has regressed since last year.

 

[RugbyReg]

I though kev did some fantastic stuff in tight around the ruck. He was best Wallaby on ground, for mine, in the first half. The fact that he was crook just heightened it.

 

[Spook]

Fair enough but I don't see it that way. I think he has made little impact. Doesn't seem to be the enforcer he was.

 

[waratahjesus]

3 - ben robinson
2 - smith
1 - burgess (i actually think he played well, the hate from his bad game has carried over, but he deserves better than that for what he did in hard circumstances this week, his passing was better by a mile.)

still think the bench love needs to be messured out by the fact the springboks had started to defend there lead as opposed to the players who played the first 50 having little ball. the subs didnt win us that much ball, they were gifted it by a team tired by three weeks straght of test matches. still good to see the bench on there.

 

[fatprop]

1 Robinson
2 Moore
3 Baxter

 

[disco]

3. Benn Robinson
2. George Smith
1.James O'Conner

Special mention AAC (Adam Ashley-Cooper), TPN & Genia

 

[RugbyReg]

Fatprop, so Robbo you're best Wallaby?

And I'm not usually one to question others picks, but Baxter? Really?

 

[Henry]

3. Smith
2. Robinson
1. Mitchell

Mention to O'Connor and Pocock

 

[TOCC]

i was blind drunk and may have fallen asleep for 20min in the second half, i will reserve my opinion until i see a replay

 

[disco]

i was blind drunk and may have fallen asleep for 20min in the second half, i will reserve my opinion until i see a replay

Your a sucker for punishement but so am I. I'll still watch it again even though only two words come to mind when I think of the wallabies "Bumbling Idiots".

 

[naza]

3 Moore
2 Mitchell
1 Burgess

Based on who kept us in it in the first half when others wilted.

Couldn't give points to Smith, who was outdone by Broussow, and Benn Robinson's scrummaging was terrific but his workrate in the first half was atrocious.

 

[cheezel]

3 Robinson
2 Smith
1 Ashley-Cooper

 

[Moses]

3. Benn Robinson
2. George Smith
1. TPN

 

[cyclopath]

3 Robbo
2 Smith - but more for work other than pilfering where Brussouw owned him
1 Mitchell - tried well, good effort.

 

[louie]

was interesting watching Brussouw last night as i didn't see the game last week.
don't think he would have been so great if he didn't have a big smashing pack with him.
on his own i think he'd be quite overrated.

 

[fatprop]

Fatprop, so Robbo you're best Wallaby?

And I'm not usually one to question others picks, but Baxter? Really?

The front row was the only shining light for 80 mins, Beast has given many quality THPs this year a hard time, Baxter deserves the point for managing him from scrum 2 onwards.

 

[disco]

Fatprop, so Robbo you're best Wallaby?

Fatprop,
I think Noddy asked if you want 3points for Benn Robinson or 3 points for Baxter? You have Benn Robinson at the top of your list with a 1 next to him.

Remember it's a 3 2 1 point scoring system were the most points wins.

 

[fatprop]

Fatprop, so Robbo you're best Wallaby?

Fatprop,
I think Noddy asked if you want 3points for Benn Robinson or 3 points for Baxter? You have Benn Robinson at the top of your list with a 1 next to him.

Remember it's a 3 2 1 point scoring system were the most points wins.

3 Robinson
2 Moore
1 Baxter

Sorry Nod ...............................................................