Wallabies 2023
- Thread starter RugbyReg
- Start date
Lightblue
Arch Winning (36)
Noah Lolesio 6.5? As our best.... I must have missed his good games.Interesting read from Rugby Pass on their Wallabies Player Ratings from the full test season.
Tight Five
Wallabies player ratings: Tight five struggled to excel during tough year
After a tough international campaign, not many players in Australia's tight five stood out - but that doesn't mean there are no positive ahead of a World Cup. Here's how the Wallabies' props, hookers and locks rated this year.www.rugbypass.com
Loose Forwards
Wallabies player ratings: No. 8 locks down jersey as loosie combination takes shape
The Wallabies didn't win as many Test matches as they deserved this year, but that doesn't players didn't stand out. Here's how the loose forwards rated this year.
Halfbacks and 10s
Wallabies player ratings: Clear first-choice halfback emerges during average year for halves
This week, RugbyPass is rating the Wallabies players' performances from the year that was. Today, we take a look at the halves.
Centres
Wallabies player ratings: Ikitau impresses during mixed year for Australian centres
Injuries plagued the Wallabies throughout a tough 2022 season, and this was felt in their midfield. But while players were ruled out, a rising star showed his class.
Outside Backs
Wallabies player ratings: Two outside back stars shine as World Cup bolter emerges
This week, RugbyPass will be reviewing and rating the Wallabies players’ performances throughout the 2022 campaign. First up, we take a look at how the outside backs performed this year.
PhilClinton
Geoff Shaw (53)
Kerevi and Ikitau standouts obviously, but Kerevi will be coming back from a long injury lay off.
After that, all the other centres are either coming back from injury or out of form. I wouldn't say centre is a position we are flooded with quality options that match what Kerevi and Ikitau give us.
stillmissit
Chilla Wilson (44)
We are in that situation in several positions, apart from locks. It is hard to imagine that all our ducks will line up and we can put all our best players into the RWC squad as injuries and availability may impact several of them. Not sure the rotation policy will protect all the players.
Marce
John Thornett (49)
Kerevi is the only top class ball-carrier who could be selected in any Top 5 nation
Tomthumb
Colin Windon (37)
Yet a lot of others who have struggled (Gordon, Holloway, Poreki, Paisami etc) all still get picked regardless
Anyone would be pissed with Rennie's coin toss selections
It's not a coin toss though. We've had issues at all the positions the guys you have listed play at whether it is form, injuries or both.
Meanwhile we've had Rob Valetini who plays the same position as Harry Wilson who has been available for pretty much every game and has been our best player this season.
It's not a mystery why Harry Wilson isn't getting to play more test rugby.
Derpus
George Gregan (70)
Gleeson over him in the squad? Wilson didn't get a shot in Aus A.
No mystery why he isnt starting 8. The rest of his treatment is a bit average though.
Wilson was unlucky not to go on the EOYT. He didn't get a shot for Australia A because he was part of the main squad, couldn't join the Australia A squad late because of COVID rules and then Gleeson was outstanding and took his spot on the EOYT.
I think that is definitely unlucky for Wilson but likewise, Gleeson took his chance and he deserved his spot on the EOYT. The logic for Wilson to go on the EOYT anyway despite him not really delivering each time he's had an opportunity didn't really hold up.
He was on the Australia A tour.
I can certainly understanding Rennie wanting to take a look based on that rather than sticking with a known quantity that he has consistently decided isn't playing at the level required.
Adam84
Nick Farr-Jones (63)
Disagree.
Adam84
Nick Farr-Jones (63)
Consistently? That’s a cop out. He never had consistent selection, was either played out of position or haphazard selection
a lot better than Wilson has shown
Derpus
George Gregan (70)
I dont really think it was.
Consistently as in Rennie has consistently dropped him pretty quickly each time he has played for the Wallabies.
I'm not weighing in on whether Rennie's view on Wilson is fair or not but it's become pretty clear that Wilson isn't delivering what he is looking for.
In that light it wasn't surprising he opted for Gleeson after his play for Australia A on the Japan tour.
What do you disagree on here? If you compare the number of players tried or rotated at 2, lock, 6, 9, 12 versus number 8 which Valetini has locked down as his spot with an outstanding season they are very different situations.
A mutterer
Chilla Wilson (44)
I suspected that wilson was told, again, to listen to what he has been asked to develop and demonstrate he has taken onboard the feedback.
He was asked to demonstrate footwork in contact. Against the AB's, he built up a head of steam to run deliberately at 2 of their largest units with a face full of rage.
Brumby Runner
David Wilson (68)
Harry Wilson's problem is that he is competing for the No 8 jersey when he is a much more effective No 6. He hasn't got the footwork to break the line or bend the gain line when trucking the ball up in centre field the way Rob Valetini does. And like it or not, that is the way Dave Rennie wants his No 8 to play.
Harry's skills with the ball are more in terms of offloading and putting supports away. A task he performed beautifully in the No 6 jersey at U20s in a team that very nearly won the Championship. He was a standout i that tournament, and I reckon he would still be at least in the squad if he was more able to show his running and support play down the blindside rather than be a battering ram in the middle. He doesn't have any defence issues and I seem to recall seeing him operating well in lineouts. He has the skills, but is playing the wrong position in Rennie's world.
Harry's skills with the ball are more in terms of offloading and putting supports away. A task he performed beautifully in the No 6 jersey at U20s in a team that very nearly won the Championship. He was a standout i that tournament, and I reckon he would still be at least in the squad if he was more able to show his running and support play down the blindside rather than be a battering ram in the middle. He doesn't have any defence issues and I seem to recall seeing him operating well in lineouts. He has the skills, but is playing the wrong position in Rennie's world.
wamberal
Phil Kearns (64)
Must be a Manly supporter.
Adam84
Nick Farr-Jones (63)
Your comments sounded like you were.
Rennies treatment towards Wilson is quite extraordinary compared to others in the squad who are rewarded with selection despite inconsistency or ill-discipline
I can’t fathom that guys like Gordon are rewarded weekly but Wilson is banished.
Last edited: