Members Section
John Thornett (49)
But what about the Woodies!!!
dont say it
dont say it
dont say it
.
.
.
.
.
Did ed craig play well?
But what about the Woodies!!!
He fluffed his first two lineout throws, otherwise okay, subbed at half-time or thereabouts.Did ed craig play well?
The way Lolesio is playing for the Brums I expect to hear any day he’s going to Japan.
It will piss me off to no end if I then see Bowen playing for them but it’s the exact thing ACT have proven to be so good at
Yes! He needs a go at 12. This way we can bring in Bowen and if Goddard heads over to the brumbies Wilson gets pushed up. There is no benefit for Edmed to stay at the tahs and play fly-half when he's already competed with Donaldson and lost (in terms of selections).I reckon Edmed could be a good shout to brums or rebs to play 12
Um, I think Edmed's had the first go at 10 for the Tahs every time he's been available - he's been injured since about Round 3 this year, and the likelihood he re-takes the 10 spot on his return has only improved each week...Yes! He needs a go at 12. This way we can bring in Bowen and if Goddard heads over to the brumbies Wilson gets pushed up. There is no benefit for Edmed to stay at the tahs and play fly-half when he's already competed with Donaldson and lost (in terms of selections).
He started at 10 because Donaldson was at full-back (beale situation) and Jorgensen hadn't yet moved to full-back until Edmed got injured. Aside from that, Donaldson also got selected for the wallabies squad over Edmed last year. Also, my point still stands? It's clear that Bowen is eventually going to start playing fly-half for more games over the next year so why would we want to keep Donaldson, Edmed and Bowen?Um, I think Edmed's had the first go at 10 for the Tahs every time he's been available - he's been injured since about Round 3 this year, and the likelihood he re-takes the 10 spot on his return has only improved each week...
Don't forget HarrisonHe started at 10 because Donaldson was at full-back (beale situation) and Jorgensen hadn't yet moved to full-back until Edmed got injured. Aside from that, Donaldson also got selected for the wallabies squad over Edmed last year. Also, my point still stands? It's clear that Bowen is eventually going to start playing fly-half for more games over the next year so why would we want to keep Donaldson, Edmed and Bowen?
True, i actually haven't seen him play at 10 but i've heard that he was above both Edmed and Donaldson. He can play other positions like Full-back right?Don't forget Harrison
So they say. He looks a bit on the small side to me.True, i actually haven't seen him play at 10 but i've heard that he was above both Edmed and Donaldson. He can play other positions like Full-back right?
Does Sua'ali'i really affect the fly-half position? Seems to me that Perese or Pietch has to look at other options, which is pretty sad as they have both been performing great in recent games.Harrison won't be back. Done his knee again poor bloke and unlikely to get a renewal I would think.
Tahs need to bite the bullet and move on Donaldson or Edmed. Especially if Sua'ali'i becomes available.
Bowen to be a starter next year I reckon.
Maybe but Harrison is a better player than both Edmed and Donaldson. The smart decision would be to try and re-sign him on an unders deal let him rehab and see what happens. Edmed still looks more like a 12 to me. It is kicking the can down the road another year (in terms of making a decision) but that also gives all players time to develop.Harrison won't be back. Done his knee again poor bloke and unlikely to get a renewal I would think.
Tahs need to bite the bullet and move on Donaldson or Edmed. Especially if Sua'ali'i becomes available.
Bowen to be a starter next year I reckon.
Perese is so overhyped. Limited skillset and predictable. Granted hard to tackle but the play ends with him so often.Does Sua'ali'i really affect the fly-half position? Seems to me that Perese or Pietch has to look at other options, which is pretty sad as they have both been performing great in recent games.
I've always advocated for Sua'ali'i to play outside center. It's still absurd that all of his Schoolboy Rugby Union Highlights only included him in Year 9 and 10. Just imagine him in year 11 and 12 playing for kings, literally unstoppable.Perese is so overhyped. Limited skillset and predictable. Granted hard to tackle but the play ends with him so often.
Poor man’s LaumapePerese is so overhyped. Limited skillset and predictable. Granted hard to tackle but the play ends with him so often.
13 for me as well.I've always advocated for Sua'ali'i to play outside center. It's still absurd that all of his Schoolboy Rugby Union Highlights only included him in Year 9 and 10. Just imagine him in year 11 and 12 playing for kings, literally unstoppable.
Harrison won't be back. Done his knee again poor bloke and unlikely to get a renewal I would think.
Tahs need to bite the bullet and move on Donaldson or Edmed. Especially if Sua'ali'i becomes available.
Bowen to be a starter next year I reckon.