• Welcome to the Green and Gold Rugby forums. As you can see we've upgraded the forums to new software. Your old logon details should work, just click the 'Login' button in the top right.

Wallabies 2023

Braveheart81

Will Genia (78)
Staff member
This is why Rugby Australia should be have Aus A v Tonga/Samoa fixtures locked in.

14 July.


The question is how useful will that game be for the actual Wallabies. We play in South Africa on 8 July then Sydney on 15 July. Does the game in Tonga involve any players who went to South Africa and/or how big will the Wallabies squad be at that point. Are you releasing players from the Wallabies squad for the game or is it entirely the next group of players who realistically aren't any chance to go the RWC?
 

stillmissit

Chilla Wilson (44)
You would think Gordon would be getting a couple of 10-15 minutes at best this year unless the starting 10 breaks down.

It is RWC year
Fattie, the RWC is an opportunity to show that we cannot just go well against the top countries, Ireland and France being fine examples. To win we need to maximise the opportunities to win it. I am concerned that the most talked about 10's - Cooper and Foley are poor defensive players, although Cooper has improved somewhat. Gordon defends well and as a 22 year old should get some decent bench time in the pre-cup games as well as at this cup. Like everybody, I have my fingers crossed for Cooper and Kerevi.
 

The Ghost of Raelene

Andrew Slack (58)
Depending on rehab for some of the injured players it could be a chance to bring them back slower than the potential of just running them out at the WC.

I'd release players to play in it if they are genuine chance for the WC. Match fitness will be essential and we may end up with 3 Super Rugby teams not in the finals which can be a lot of down time. Yes I know Club Rugby exists but it's not the same for these guys..
 

stillmissit

Chilla Wilson (44)
14 July.


The question is how useful will that game be for the actual Wallabies. We play in South Africa on 8 July then Sydney on 15 July. Does the game in Tonga involve any players who went to South Africa and/or how big will the Wallabies squad be at that point. Are you releasing players from the Wallabies squad for the game or is it entirely the next group of players who realistically aren't any chance to go the RWC?
Great point. We gain nothing by letting non-cup players go to Tonga.
Sorry didn't realise the game was scheduled to happen, thought it was a discussion.
 
Last edited:

qwerty51

Stirling Mortlock (74)
14 July.


The question is how useful will that game be for the actual Wallabies. We play in South Africa on 8 July then Sydney on 15 July. Does the game in Tonga involve any players who went to South Africa and/or how big will the Wallabies squad be at that point. Are you releasing players from the Wallabies squad for the game or is it entirely the next group of players who realistically aren't any chance to go the RWC?
Zero will play from the 23s of either match. But that looks like a perfect spot for guys like Bell, Tupou, Leota and maybe Phillip & Rodda if they're not selected for Tests. Carter Gordon should play 10 in that. I'd assume 25/26 will go to SA and be kept for Sydney so we've probably still got a chunk of guys that could play in Tonga that who will go the RWC.

Interestingly that article also says Colby Fainga'a and Alex Mafi declined to play for Tonga, Mafi I get who will hold out for Aus selection you'd assume but wonder why Colby turned it down.
 

The Ghost of Raelene

Andrew Slack (58)
Zero will play from the 23s of either match. But that looks like a perfect spot for guys like Bell, Tupou, Leota. Carter Gordon should play 10 as well. I'd assume 25/26 will go to SA so we've probably still got a chunk of guys that could play that who will go the RWC.
I could see Wilson, Campbell, Perese, Gordon, Wilkin, Wright, Robertson all there as well.
 

stillmissit

Chilla Wilson (44)
Depending on rehab for some of the injured players it could be a chance to bring them back slower than the potential of just running them out at the WC.

I'd release players to play in it if they are genuine chance for the WC. Match fitness will be essential and we may end up with 3 Super Rugby teams not in the finals which can be a lot of down time. Yes I know Club Rugby exists but it's not the same for these guys..
Ghost, I think for several of our players match fitness will be an issue, some players can step back in pretty quickly and some take time. Tupou will be interesting and I suspect he is going to miss it but I hope not.
 

Braveheart81

Will Genia (78)
Staff member
Zero will play from the 23s of either match. But that looks like a perfect spot for guys like Bell, Tupou, Leota and maybe Phillip & Rodda if they're not selected for Tests. Carter Gordon should play 10 in that. I'd assume 25/26 will go to SA and be kept for Sydney so we've probably still got a chunk of guys that could play in Tonga that who will go the RWC.

It's tricky. I would assume we would normally take more than 25 or 26 players to South Africa particularly in a RWC year as I'd guess we would have a week of training there before the match.

Likewise when we get back, how much preparation does the Australia A side get? Do those in the main squad just miss a single training session because they fly out to Tonga on the Thursday?

I definitely think it is a good opportunity for the team rehab guys who might not be back in the best 23 then but are ready to play some rugby.
 

fatprop

George Gregan (70)
Staff member
Fattie, the RWC is an opportunity to show that we cannot just go well against the top countries, Ireland and France being fine examples. To win we need to maximise the opportunities to win it. I am concerned that the most talked about 10's - Cooper and Foley are poor defensive players, although Cooper has improved somewhat. Gordon defends well and as a 22 year old should get some decent bench time in the pre-cup games as well as at this cup. Like everybody, I have my fingers crossed for Cooper and Kerevi.
Foley and/or Cooper won't lose us these matches whilst Gordon will not win us these matches.

We have bigger problems, we have injured first choice props, no set hooker, no set locks, a champion 7 who isn't playing like a champion and questions across the whole back row (except for Valentini), we will lucky to win a 1/4 final
 
  • Like
Reactions: dru

qwerty51

Stirling Mortlock (74)
That's a pretty pessimistic view. Yes, our two best props are injured but our backups who will probably start are highly experienced and good players. Hooker is definitely our biggest issue. I'd argue Frost/Skelton is almost a certainty, at least in the 23 and are great players. Hooper won't be 7, lucky to even be in the squad. Holloway looks a certainty at 6 and his lineout and maul prowess is as good as ever. I think we should only be concerned about Tupou's fitness, hooker and who is going to play 7. Rest is fine.
 

fatprop

George Gregan (70)
Staff member
That's a pretty pessimistic view. Yes, our two best props are injured but our backups who will probably start are highly experienced and good players. Hooker is definitely our biggest issue. I'd argue Frost/Skelton is almost a certainty, at least in the 23 and are great players. Hooper won't be 7, lucky to even be in the squad. Holloway looks a certainty at 6 and his lineout and maul prowess is as good as ever. I think we should only be concerned about Tupou's fitness, hooker and who is going to play 7. Rest is fine.
I am relying on Ben Darwin's concept of cohesion, we don't have a settled side and the teams we will need to beat do
 

stillmissit

Chilla Wilson (44)
The pigs win or lose rugby matches, the backs just decide by how much
A perennial truism Fattie. I put my faith in how we went in Europe under Rennie. I thought our boys played very well whilst losing to France and Ireland. Note: I am trying to forget Italy...
If Eddie can get their heads right we should get through the 1/4's but beyond that is a dream we will struggle to live....
 

stillmissit

Chilla Wilson (44)
Foley and/or Cooper won't lose us these matches whilst Gordon will not win us these matches.

We have bigger problems, we have injured first choice props, no set hooker, no set locks, a champion 7 who isn't playing like a champion and questions across the whole back row (except for Valentini), we will lucky to win a 1/4 final
One guy can change a lot in a rugby match but that is too much to ask of Gordon. If he distributes well and defends in his channel I'd be happy with that.
 
Top