• Welcome to the Green and Gold Rugby forums. As you can see we've upgraded the forums to new software. Your old logon details should work, just click the 'Login' button in the top right.

NSW AAGPS Rugby 2016

Status
Not open for further replies.

Troy Dickson

Herbert Moran (7)
Superb stepping by sheldon to set up the try. Massive talent.

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

All this talk about Sheldon.... and then I watch a 45 second video where he touches the ball once and makes 5 strides for a 6 metre gain , big deal ! If the two players not pushing up forward on the inside the play goes no where.

They way some of the people on here been giving Sheldon the accolades I thought he must have made a 50 metre gain or ran the entire field and stepped half the opposing team, but if that is it, if that is all the highlights you are referring well pfft..... Put the highlights up here for what Williams and Wilkinson did in the second half and lets compare ???

That is no disrespect to Sheldon just an observation.

Sheldon is like many good players this year, I follow Joeys so I will mention their names Blaise Barnes (ACL), Sam Abbey (ACL) and Triston Reilly (Fractured cheekbone), has been subjected to injury which will stall their progression, however the kids can not dwell on that and I am sure they will not, unlike some adults on this forum. I hope the kids undertake their rehab, train hard and get back into it.
 

bigmac

Billy Sheehan (19)
^^^^^^Sheldon gets accolades cos he is a standout player in a lower profile team.
Joeys and other centres of excellence produce excellent players en masse so it is harder for a star to shine. Joeys no 13 stands out in an excellent backline.

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk
 

Brainstrust

Watty Friend (18)
No no, he had to choose between following league or union. He had to decide now and decided to go with league because he didn't plan to get an atar and thought he'd better off develop if he went to league now and solely focus on sport
That's exactly right. He had a choice between both codes, with league very keen to get him into a full time development environment. Not chasing an atar and doing tafe, made it a pretty obvious choice for him. The selectors have the right to make a choice ( a wrong choice in my opinion) , and respectfully the boy also has the same right to make his choice, some will think wrong and others right. That's the beauty of living in democracy, you get to choose what's right for you, not what's right for others. I say good on him for having the courage to do what he wants to do for himself, even knowing there would be many in the other camp.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Not in straight

Vay Wilson (31)
That's exactly right. He had a choice between both codes, with league very keen to get him into a full time development environment. Not chasing an atar and doing tafe, made it a pretty obvious choice for him. The selectors have the right to make a choice ( a wrong choice in my opinion) , and respectfully the boy also has the same right to make his choice, some will think wrong and others right. That's the beauty of living in democracy, you get to choose what's right for you, not what's right for others. I say good on him for having the courage to do what he wants to do for himself, even knowing there would be many in the other camp.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Hopefully we see him back on the right side of the fence one day.

A loss for the GPS & a loss for Newington & rubgy
 

Rugby Mum 2

Bill Watson (15)
Now, injury update on Fenn - another one of my standouts - hope it is just a knock. And what about the concussion (that we know about) to Breen? Friday is a big day for selection.
 

Armchair Selector

Johnnie Wallace (23)
Who cares,it's certainly none of your business.

I don't know why but I am forever amazed how this forums heats up at this time of the year.

No doubt the mods will be busy filtering the parents and players who have thrown the "toys out of the cot"

Just remember that what is posted is your legacy and on reflection some may wish they hadn't "posted" that.

All our sons hopefully will have a long future in the sport and some of the banter hasn't been edifying.

For those not selected. Heads up refocus and learn from the experience to be the best you can be. For those in rehab, work hard and get well.

Like preparing for the HSC, the adversity and trauma will disappear in time.
 

Donald Drumph

Stan Wickham (3)
Both games yesterday were entertaining and i don't think the scoreline in both the 1sts and 2nds reflects the games that were played.

In the 2nds I thought the GPS team were a little flattered by the final scoreline. GPS didn't turn up to play for the first 15 mins and CAS took their opportunities and deserved the win. It was really only late in the second half when GPS woke up and started to play, almost snatching an unlikely draw.

The CAS forwards were strong and probably got the points over GPS, while some of the GPS backs were definitely not at their best on the day (Orpen the exception). The CAS backs looked slick and took their chances - the quick 16yo winger certainly has some toe.

In the 1sts CAS were right in the game for about 50 mins but some mistakes and the class of Wilkinson and Jaffer-Williams took over late in the game and made the scoreline look a lot more lopsided than the game reflected.

As a selection trial - I thought the GPS front row got the points over their counterparts, but the locks battle went to CAS's Frost and Rasch. The back row battle was closer with a couple of players cancelling each other out, possibly CAS but "marginal" (pardon the pun).

The halfbacks were both good, while Wilkinson/Sheldon seemed to have the edge on their opponent. Orpen (GPS) when he came on and Armstrong (CAS) were the pick of the centres, with Mohi (CAS) and Jaffer-Williams (GPS) the pick of the wings. And was split between the two 15's performances.

Good luck to all the lads in their next games. I hope those that took injuries recover quickly.
This is the most accurate summary of the matches yesterday.
Most of the other reports were written by people with other agendas and wearing blinkers.
Good to have an unbiased view instead of the usual rubbish.
 

Cash

Sydney Middleton (9)
Is he still at the school? Heard he'd pulled out of the team and the school so he could play for the Bulldogs.
No no, he had to choose between following league or union. He had to decide now and decided to go with league because he didn't plan to get an atar and thought he'd better off develop if he went to league now and solely focus on sport
Shame to see him go, but I trust he made the right choice. Makes me think of Cameron Murray, who last year somehow managed to miraculously balance league, union and his studies on top of that (and still perform impressively in all three!). Huge loss for New.
 

Gary Owen III

Syd Malcolm (24)
AAGPS website has just listed GPS teams to play CHS Friday 24 June at Curagul Fields Bobbin Head Rd North Turramurra (changes highlighted)

GPS 1st XV
D Breen (S); C Jeavons-Fellows (S); O Helu (N); N Brown (K); S Ridley (S); C Rorke (I); D Pietsch (K); M Fenn (I); W Haskins (E); N Wilkinson (J); T Taukamo (N); M Orpen (K); W Terry (I); Y Jaffer-Williams (J); L Osborne (K)

GPS 2nd XV
T Osborne (I); H Todd (S); F Cutler (I); R Suttor (E); T Silk (I); G Miller (S); H Green (S); T Serhon (N);; K Brown (K ); B Kuenzle (N); M Sinclair (E); L Day (J); R Millar (K); O Smeallie (I); M Mc Taggart (J); N Lawson (N) – (16)
 

Gary Owen III

Syd Malcolm (24)
GPS teams to play CJRU U/18s & SJRU U/18s at Boronia Park Thursday 23 June at 5.30 & 6.45 p.m. (changes highlighted)

GPS BLUE v SJRU at 6.45 p.m.
L Edwards (E); J Lynch (K); D Lombardi (K); G Finlayson (S); J Spooner (J) J Smith (G); C Scott (I); C Crawford (S); B Miller (S); N Shannon (S); S Jackson-Bolton (A); J Turner (N) ; A Gavin (S); E Gregory (E); L Rixon (E)

GPS WHITE v CJRU at 5.30 p.m. D Hicks (K); I Halaufia (N); J Yates (J); M Williams (K); J Petterson (I); C Poidevin (N); C Ryan (K); R Allen (E); D Dowling (J); C Steele Park (K); A Tse (J); (S); R Angles-Court (J) ;W Douglas (K) ; B Duckworth (K); W Mallet (G)

Reserves D Cheung (G); B Furby (E); E Collard (E); S Williams (I); J Kingham (A); T Chadwick (G); P Dalton (J); W Grant (I);
 

Boxhead

Bob McCowan (2)
This is the most accurate summary of the matches yesterday.
Most of the other reports were written by people with other agendas and wearing blinkers.
Good to have an unbiased view instead of the usual rubbish.
Unfortunately every report on this forum is written with some bias in the viewpoint. Usually a dad or mum trying to push their son. Hard to believe there could have been any bad players in a GPS side that beat a quality CAS side by such a margin
 

Not in straight

Vay Wilson (31)
Unfortunately every report on this forum is written with some bias in the viewpoint. Usually a dad or mum trying to push their son. Hard to believe there could have been any bad players in a GPS side that beat a quality CAS side by such a margin



If you were not aware of Lee's "Official" Match report which is very balanced very well written and complete with some great pics. Click on the link below.

 

HFTH

Chris McKivat (8)
AAGPS website has just listed GPS teams to play CHS Friday 24 June at Curagul Fields Bobbin Head Rd North Turramurra (changes highlighted)

GPS 1st XV
D Breen (S); C Jeavons-Fellows (S); O Helu (N); N Brown (K); S Ridley (S); C Rorke (I); D Pietsch (K); M Fenn (I); W Haskins (E); N Wilkinson (J); T Taukamo (N); M Orpen (K); W Terry (I); Y Jaffer-Williams (J); L Osborne (K)

GPS 2nd XV
T Osborne (I); H Todd (S); F Cutler (I); R Suttor (E); T Silk (I); G Miller (S); H Green (S); T Serhon (N);; K Brown (K ); B Kuenzle (N); M Sinclair (E); L Day (J); R Millar (K); O Smeallie (I); M Mc Taggart (J); N Lawson (N) – (16)

11/16 forwards in 1's and 2's are from S and I


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

William88

Syd Malcolm (24)
If you were not aware of Lee's "Official" Match report which is very balanced very well written and complete with some great pics. Click on the link below.


Very balanced, especially in the heading.

"GPS win well against CAS."

It was a victory to each side 1 to CAS and 1 to GPS.

And if not for Jaffer-Williams quick hat trick that showed his class and reps for schoolboys, it was a very even game.
 

HFTH

Chris McKivat (8)
The good people at "K" would be scratching their heads as to why their Piggies didn't get at least 1 more in


Great to see Max Sinclair given an opportunity in the 2nds. Well deserved.

Excluding the 4,5,8, the K forwards are short. No disrespect because they are awesome footballers and they work well as a pack. I stood next to them last sat.

Size isn't everything (for eg the S hooker is awesome) but when the selectors consider who is going to play after school at rep level, height is something I'm sure they consider. They can fill out but rarely get taller and even the shortest props are close to 6' these days.

Having said all that I hope the K forwards punch above their height and smash V and S. Sounds like Shore piggies dug in last week in some parts.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top