RedOrDead
Charlie Fox (21)
This would end up being a superior comp to the GPS.
CAS Rugby 2023
- Thread starter rod skellet
- Start date
This would end up being a superior comp to the GPS.
KentwellCup>ShuteShield
Jimmy Flynn (14)
As a GPS old boy I agree, maybe add in Randwick Boys High, Epping Boys High, plus a couple of other historically strong rugby public schools and the comp would be world class and would 100% boost rugby unions profile as a whole.
Halfbackenthusiast
Ted Fahey (11)
As was Archie Saunders.
Props are People too
Sydney Middleton (9)
Another list. Feels about right. Lists are fun.
The Ghost of Raelene
Andrew Slack (58)
I’m sure this isn’t going to result in a shit slinging conversation.
RedOrDead
Charlie Fox (21)
Don't think anyone is taking this list serious enough to descend into a real d*** measuring contest. After the top 6, it's like the bloke just picked schools at random from some really strange comps.
I posted this hahaha, definitely not a definitive rankings by any means. Hard to make rankings for the country when no one plays each other besides their own competition so couldn't follow a world rugby style rating system with each team given a number to show how strong they are, more so tried to rank teams based on their win/loss record and points difference giving some consideration to strength of their opposition. For example St Kevins won the VSRU comp undefeated with a 533 point difference, not saying they would beat any CAS or AAGPS team by any means.
RedOrDead
Charlie Fox (21)
Yeah ok fair enough. Well good work.
Jumping_jack
Ward Prentice (10)
Yes well done to Barker for finding these boys.
And well done to their schools which have been previously documented for developing these players before Barker found them. It’s a shame that the schools that developed them can’t recognise their talents as aus u18’s to celebrate the input they had on them.
Eg It would be great to Hills Sports HS to be able to celebrate Onitis achievement, or for Doug(Kinross )and Lachlan(Stannies) for their previous schools as well to celebrate the players success.
Last edited:
Jumping_jack
Ward Prentice (10)
It was a pretty stacked Barker team. How do they find these kids? They must go out to u16’s rep team games and find them. (Though Phillipson actually made his first XV debut for Kinross in year 9 in a trial game v Barker).
They are making the Waratahs job much easier centralising the talent.
It is interesting how close Knox and Waverley came to beating them though despite the team being as stacked as it is.
They are making the Waratahs job much easier centralising the talent.
It is interesting how close Knox and Waverley came to beating them though despite the team being as stacked as it is.
Last edited:
Jumping_jack
Ward Prentice (10)
Moving forward how does the competition stay competitive despite these big investments.
For example, Doug, Isaiya, Lachlan and Oniti are all year 12 borders. That’s an investment from the school of $200,000 to win the comp for just year 12 kids. (There is an abc doco on Isaiya that highlights this great opportunity)
Well with the Knox centenary just around the corner we can expect similar investments from them that is for sure.
For example, Doug, Isaiya, Lachlan and Oniti are all year 12 borders. That’s an investment from the school of $200,000 to win the comp for just year 12 kids. (There is an abc doco on Isaiya that highlights this great opportunity)
Well with the Knox centenary just around the corner we can expect similar investments from them that is for sure.
Last edited:
RedOrDead
Charlie Fox (21)
They were good players when they got there, they were great when they left.
RedOrDead
Charlie Fox (21)
Almost like all three schools do the same thing... not that there is anything wrong with it. Keep complaining. I promise you it doesn't just make you look salty.
RedOrDead
Charlie Fox (21)
Good. I hope Knox continues to invest money into rugby talent. It's only a positive for all involved.
JackJill
Sydney Middleton (9)
There's always 2 sides to these arguments.
1. You agree with scholarships as they give kids in the outer country or unable to pay the hefty fees of a CAS private school the opportunity to succeed and flourish not only in rugby, but academically as well.
2. You side with a no scholarship rule. This means, provided the right coaching, your son is able to grow their game and it keeps the rugby teams in their grade fluctuating as there is no freak kid coming in and taking his primary position for the rest of his schoolboy rugby career. Everyone gets a fair start.
I see people's point of view from both sides of the argument. Personally I support scholarships as they give kids who would've had no chance of playing at that elite level a pathway to become an incredible player.
1. You agree with scholarships as they give kids in the outer country or unable to pay the hefty fees of a CAS private school the opportunity to succeed and flourish not only in rugby, but academically as well.
2. You side with a no scholarship rule. This means, provided the right coaching, your son is able to grow their game and it keeps the rugby teams in their grade fluctuating as there is no freak kid coming in and taking his primary position for the rest of his schoolboy rugby career. Everyone gets a fair start.
I see people's point of view from both sides of the argument. Personally I support scholarships as they give kids who would've had no chance of playing at that elite level a pathway to become an incredible player.
RedOrDead
Charlie Fox (21)
If the school needs to import a kid in your son's position, I hate to sound harsh, but it's because your son is not good enough. However, this is not to say that your son will never be good enough. What makes an athlete great is that person can find inspiration through the tough times, not just the easy ones. Look at what Tom Davey (Knox 10 2022) did. Left Barker. He was never good enough to play fly-half for their A team, he put in work and made himself a quality player.
Jumping_jack
Ward Prentice (10)
These arguments don’t really work for the Barker efforts - most of these kids attend a different private school with the same opportunities.
And Katoa would not have had a chance at “playing at that elite level pathway to become an incredible player” without Barker?
I don’t think so.
Jumping_jack
Ward Prentice (10)
How many private school kids are the Knox and Waverley schools bringing in?
Jumping_jack
Ward Prentice (10)
Hooper was selected in gen blue as a year young
Phillipson was a year 9 first XV player.
Katoa was earmarked from year 6 as the next big thing in rugby league.
Oniti was the top ranked tight head as a 15 year old.
They were already great when they got there - that’s why they went there.
Last edited: