G'day ISA guys, I am a CAS Waves old boy/ Waves dad of 2 boys who just left/follower, etc (E) All the above in a multiple choice question
I have to say, i think you should listen a bit more to your wise DaShoomze colleague.
A weekend/ a few wins in a preseason doesn't mean a lot long term, nor does it mean a big statement about the immediate supremacy of the ISA comp over any other other comp. In fact, IMO what it does support is my current belief that both Auggies and Oakhill should be part of the CAS rugby comp.That will upset others in both comps, but sufficient time and results support this IMO.
Oakhill were clearly dominant against Knox on Sat, but had Auggies not converted a last play try against the Waves, and the Waves won, would the same be said. I could also be cheeky and say had that Waves side played more games together, it was their first game together this year, and it was played at Death Valley(Queens Park) I wonder! Irrelevant now, Auggies won, but fair to say, many Auggies posters probably thought they were done in this game and got a massive reality check.
None of which matters, what does matter is having a strong competition with games like this going forward.
I am quite sure that if this new comp was formed it would most certainly compete very strongly against the GPS rep teams come that time.
But again that's just bragging rights and a 1 off set of games what does matter is the quality of a competition.
I know an association means a lot more than just rugby, but hasn't the time come to separate Rugby from all other schools co-curricula activities? For a whole lot of reasons like competitiveness and safety!
I might sound crazy, but ha of course I can't see that.