I believe you are talking about the Quinns RC while Ted is referring to the Pats RC.
Subbies 2023!
- Thread starter Pfitzy
- Start date
Pfitzy
George Gregan (70)
Ah right. My bad.
Pfitzy
George Gregan (70)
OK - now I'm looking at the right tackle - red card against Pats
Actions of black 5 make it messy, and will probably mitigate the outcome but black 13 still lifted and made it look bad. Blue player was low to the ground so yes definitely take your point.
Heavyd
Nev Cottrell (35)
First one is red for mine.
2nd one the player did lift and though he wasnt far from the ground the taclkers intent looked clear.
Waterloo_Ned
Herbert Moran (7)
I have looked at every card from the weekend to try to find comparisons for the tackle Ardi did in the Iggies match.
I found this travesty in Hills/Briars 2nd Grade. Why does the game not rub these players out? I think an unprovoked stomping/kick to the head like this should be 12-15 matches. There is no place for it. It was only given a yellow too.
I found this travesty in Hills/Briars 2nd Grade. Why does the game not rub these players out? I think an unprovoked stomping/kick to the head like this should be 12-15 matches. There is no place for it. It was only given a yellow too.
WoodyWoodsman
Sydney Middleton (9)
All three look bad. My order:
1. This Hills 10 stomp and kick to the head. Grub. This should be on Subbies and the judiciary's radar. Now!
2. St Pats spear. Definitely intent to use the player's head as a shovel.
3. Ryde Oval tackle. Stupid and silly.
Subbies have taken plenty from this forum without referencing it in the past. Time that they do it now. Pretty sure I've seen this guy from Hills do untoward shit on several occasions.
The Ghost of Raelene
Andrew Slack (58)
Has it been cited? If so, players like this should be kicked out of the comp.
Can’t tolerate that garbage.
Pfitzy
George Gregan (70)
Won't know until Thursday. Briars can cite the opposition player and provide video evidence.
Was Third Grade BTW.
We had someone who did this at our club years ago and we told them not to come back. There are far too many volunteers who work hard to uphold the standards of a club, without guys deliberately trying to bring your image down for no reason. The Hills player who received the RC should be stamped out for 12 months. If players are getting 4 weeks for high tackles/spear tackles (which in most cases are accidental), then a player who deliberately attacks a player, in this case blindsided and on the ground, should not see the footy field for a long time. Otherwise, expect it again.
Oldsoldier
Stan Wickham (3)
Anyone playing regularly against hills would know that isn’t out of character for that flyhalf
The Wombat
Herbert Moran (7)
Definitely a red. Even if it wasn’t intentional, there has to be zero tolerance. The potential consequences for a player are just too high.
21mm
Frank Nicholson (4)
This is an absolute disgrace. This bloke deserves the worst.
He will say he was going for his arm to release the ball. I say good luck and enjoy your time off.
Hills need to get rid of him to save face.
Denistone_Dennis
Chris McKivat (8)
21mm
Frank Nicholson (4)
Cool, nice paraphrasing my guy.
FYI quote was referring to players playing for two separate clubs, and no one wanted to name names. of which i agreed with.
This isnt really a witch hunt though is it, its on video clear as day. dude slippers someone in the head.
The Briars player lies down holding his head for 1 minute. He has no idea what has happened as he was looking down at the time when he was king hit.
LRUsoldier
Allen Oxlade (6)
3 year ban for Hills player IMO.
At least in the Briars fight they stood in front of each other. That shot was just cowardly and could have caused serious damage.
At least in the Briars fight they stood in front of each other. That shot was just cowardly and could have caused serious damage.
The ultimate ressie
Allen Oxlade (6)
A few bad eggs can really tarnish a clubs name
It’s quiet a shame
Not referring directly to the above incidents
Just in general
It’s quiet a shame
Not referring directly to the above incidents
Just in general
Eastcoast
Larry Dwyer (12)
3/4 in Div 1 this week. St Pats showing alot of character to win in tough circumstances. Unsure why there was such a focus on the time for the kick. Let him take 2 minutes if he wants to, knowing that you are going to play the kick off any way. This wont happen again for Colleagues, Im concerned that a loss like this will galvanise the group for the finals series ahead.
The other three games seem to follow the right script. Cant wait for the last 4 rounds.
Love the video evidence and chat above as well. Most people drop off this time of year, but this shows how invested people are in the game. Any news if the judicary are taking action on the kick to the head?
The other three games seem to follow the right script. Cant wait for the last 4 rounds.
Love the video evidence and chat above as well. Most people drop off this time of year, but this shows how invested people are in the game. Any news if the judicary are taking action on the kick to the head?
park footy enthusiast
Bob McCowan (2)
It's worth considering that match officials don't have the benefit of being able to check the tape or refer the decision to a TMO, and are only bound by what they and their referees assistants see (and only if they're qualified are they able to comment), with events often happening off the ball or in inconspicuous spaces. As a result you're always going to see some consistency issues across the park, to be cleaned up by the judiciary in time, but I think they've done a pretty good job this year as a whole. Was this spiel worth the favourable game treatment from the referee that paid me to write it? I'd say so.