• Welcome to the Green and Gold Rugby forums. As you can see we've upgraded the forums to new software. Your old logon details should work, just click the 'Login' button in the top right.

Wallabies 2024

Tomthumb

Tomthumb

Colin Windon (37)
stillmissit said:
TT, so you have never seen him play? I think he is a solid prop who does all the work necessary and AAA gets worked over regularly. Pone = huge error, Zane is too light, not strong enough and young. At least Talakai can hold tighthead and I have not seen him worked over. I don't care who steps up but behind Tupoa is a hole.
Click to expand...
I've watched him play plenty, from back when he was struggling for the Reds. He's decent around the field, but very poor technically at scrum time, goes in on an angle far too much and exposes his ribs far too easily. I've seen him worked over plenty of times, he would have ended up struggling just as badly as Zane and Pone did

AAA isn't perfect, but he's in a different stratosphere from Sam Talakai
 
Derpus

Derpus

George Gregan (70)
stillmissit said:
Please stop making obvious assumptions it pisses me off. Everyone knows they didn't play. I was making an observation on the competition they would meet v France, Ireland, NZ, SA and England.
Click to expand...
But it doesn't really make any sense. They won't be playing for those other countries? To be test level you just have to be the best player for your country.
 
rugbyAU

rugbyAU

Nev Cottrell (35)
Tomthumb said:
I've watched him play plenty, from back when he was struggling for the Reds. He's decent around the field, but very poor technically at scrum time, goes in on an angle far too much and exposes his ribs far too easily. I've seen him worked over plenty of times, he would have ended up struggling just as badly as Zane and Pone did

AAA isn't perfect, but he's in a different stratosphere from Sam Talakai
Click to expand...
Or any other TH other than Tupou in Australia
 
Brumby Runner

Brumby Runner

David Wilson (68)
stillmissit said:
I want to see if Sam Talakai can step up as he looks good enough to me. Also he could backup Tupoa who is injury plagued atm.
Click to expand...
Injury is a real downer, isn't it. But at THP we are lucky to have Taniela Tupou back from injury to take Tupoa's place if needed.

When someone expresses an opinion that Sam Talakai is a better prop or prospect than Allan Ala'alatoa, then it's close to time to ignore that poster.
 
upthereds#!

upthereds#!

Ken Catchpole (46)
stillmissit said:
TT, so you have never seen him play? I think he is a solid prop who does all the work necessary and AAA gets worked over regularly. Pone = huge error, Zane is too light, not strong enough and young. At least Talakai can hold tighthead and I have not seen him worked over. I don't care who steps up but behind Tupoa is a hole.
Click to expand...
Agree that Talakai has been under utilised recently as a standard solid THP. Definitely more useful then Nonggoor at least.
Disagree that AAA has 'had his day'.

I see Bell and Tupou starting with Slipper and AAA on the bench for 2024 and 2025.
 
stillmissit

stillmissit

Chilla Wilson (44)
Brumby Runner said:
Injury is a real downer, isn't it. But at THP we are lucky to have Taniela Tupou back from injury to take Tupoa's place if needed.

When someone expresses an opinion that Sam Talakai is a better prop or prospect than Allan Ala'alatoa, then it's close to time to ignore that poster.
Click to expand...
I thought you did that months ago!!!!!

BTW I never expressed that opinion re AAA being poorer than him but I am of the opinion that Talaki could step up.
 
rodha

rodha

Dave Cowper (27)
stillmissit said:
We only have a short list of players ready for this level.
Bell
BobbyV
Tupoa (if fit)
Skelton
McDermott
Ikitau
Kellaway
Markymark

Possibles in 24 Gordon. Petaia, Liam Wright
Click to expand...
You forget Rodda who when fit is probably Australia's most effective lock at test level - see the SA wins back in 2021.

Remember he was out injured for 2020, 2022, 2023 seasons, and a massive chunk of 2021 as well.
 
Last edited:
LeCheese

LeCheese

Peter Johnson (47)
1699254774672.png
 
Braveheart81

Braveheart81

Will Genia (78)
Staff member
stillmissit said:
We only have a short list of players ready for this level.

McDermott
Click to expand...

I'd argue there are still big question marks over McDermott's ability at test level. He has some pretty substantial holes in his game and it is still a problematic position for the Wallabies.

He's got the inside track now with White fading but I don't think it's an obvious long term selection. If he is our long term starter then he needs to be consistently a fair bit better than he has been so far for it not to remain a position of concern going forward.
 
stillmissit

stillmissit

Chilla Wilson (44)
Braveheart81 said:
I'd argue there are still big question marks over McDermott's ability at test level. He has some pretty substantial holes in his game and it is still a problematic position for the Wallabies.

He's got the inside track now with White fading but I don't think it's an obvious long term selection. If he is our long term starter then he needs to be consistently a fair bit better than he has been so far for it not to remain a position of concern going forward.
Click to expand...
Agree, although he could also lift his passing game, as others have done, and become the 9 we need. At this time he is the best and plays well enough at the international level. I thought the young Force 9 showed a lot of promise and will be interesting to watch this coming season.
 
LeCheese

LeCheese

Peter Johnson (47)
stillmissit said:
Agree, although he could also lift his passing game, as others have done, and become the 9 we need. At this time he is the best and plays well enough at the international level. I thought the young Force 9 showed a lot of promise and will be interesting to watch this coming season.
Click to expand...
Issak Fines-Leleiwasa? He's 28 - three years older than Tate.

Agreed he was solid though - a shame that he'll no doubt end up benched for White
 
Derpus

Derpus

George Gregan (70)
Braveheart81 said:
I'd argue there are still big question marks over McDermott's ability at test level. He has some pretty substantial holes in his game and it is still a problematic position for the Wallabies.

He's got the inside track now with White fading but I don't think it's an obvious long term selection. If he is our long term starter then he needs to be consistently a fair bit better than he has been so far for it not to remain a position of concern going forward.
Click to expand...
More or less applies to everyone
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top