Wallaby Player ratings V SA - 14/08/10

[Gnostic]

I said the same thing on the Nathan Sharpe dropping, us GAGR lot are a fickle bunch. Last week we were so behind Higginbotham to be our 8, an after one average performance (he had a solid game to be honest) we want to drop him for someone who didn't even do that much when he came on. C'mon guys

Speak for yourself.

I have been totally consistant with how I have rated players after each performance, and the comments I have made on the reasons why. You can track my posts back since I joined this site and whilst I can be accused of many things fickleness and inconsistancy is not one (or two of them) on this or any other subject I have posted about.

 

[The_Brown_Hornet]

I reckon he has been overplaying his hand.

Perhaps, but apparently he was seriously crook on the morning of the Bokke test.

 

[tigerland12]

Speak for yourself.

I have been totally consistant with how I have rated players after each performance, and the comments I have made on the reasons why. You can track my posts back since I joined this site and whilst I can be accused of many things fickleness and inconsistancy is not one (or two of them) on this or any other subject I have posted about.

I can't see how you think that was directed at you or any individual on this forum? I was saying the general opinion of the forum members seems to be that.

 

[barbarian]

I have been totally consistant with how I have rated players after each performance, and the comments I have made on the reasons why. You can track my posts back since I joined this site and whilst I can be accused of many things fickleness and inconsistancy is not one (or two of them) on this or any other subject I have posted about.

If someone actually does this I will chip in for the therapy...

 

[naza]

If someone actually does this I will chip in for the therapy...

Wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy/Giteau.