Welcome to the Green and Gold Rugby forums.
As you can see we've upgraded the forums to new software. Your old logon details should work, just click the 'Login' button in the top right.
far too often i see slipper popping up in the outside backs slowing the play down> at least alexanders runs are in tight and generally not more than one or two out from the ruck
drives me insane watching slipper take the ball on the wing in slow motion
it also leads to the situation we find ourselves in where we are picking our 6 because our 4 cant do his job and we are picking our 4 because our 1&3 cant do their job<> its simply not going to work
personally i feel robinson is a far superior scrumager to slipper however i understand your rational and it is why i believe we continue to persist with our current front row
one thing i feel people underestimate however is the attitude of every other nation playing rugby that picks their front...
the major issue for me is that this ploy of 'slightly inferior in the scrum to gain someone better around the park' has failed repeatedly for the last decade and has gained us a reputation for being so poor in the scrum that if refs are unsure they just assume we are the weaker scrum.
and its...
i think after that loss last week link realises he cant take risks this week and needs a W thats why hes not risking unmatchfit tpn
re simmons @ 6
here is a few 6s to compare with
rob simmons
Height: 2.00 m
Weight: 115 kg
jerome kaino
Height 1.96 m (6 ft 5 in)
Weight 113 kg (249 lb)
rocky...
ahh touche' bruce
happy to be corrected
but id like to hear your opinion on if you thought the fan forum was a success? and if you think this type of fan involvement and subsequent widespread media coverage of how hopeless and disconnected they were to their fan base is a good thing?
you live in...
oh come on mate that fan forum was a bloody disaster on almost any level imaginable- your drawing a long bow if your gunna link the tahs recent turn around to the fan forum- it was 2011 wasnt it?
the single person responsible for the tahs turn around is cheika 2013 and the main issue was the...
ok i think the lines have been blurred a bit here>
in terms of engaging with the fans, like what hes done while at the reds through social media - im all for it
i take issue with the idea of him justifying his position/decisions or including fans in the decision making process ie. the waratahs...
i was simply trying to point out to you that engaging the public in decision making is a fucking hopeless idea and just as stupid as a person in power justifying his position or decision making to people below him
you really dont seem to understand this basic management principle
and the...
your totally missing the point
but in short ill ad that i too would like some explanations but also understand the importance of why the coach of the national team isnt going to justify his decisions to me or anyone whos not the pulverisor
engaging the supporter base in the decision making process is just about the worst possible thing to do> ask the tahs how well the fan forum worked out for them
mckenzie is best served by ignoring faults (in public) and showcasing our strengths> giving the perception of being bullet proof even...
i totally agree that id like explanations on a lot of things too
but you gotta be realistic- hes in a position of power and the moment he starts justifying his decisions to average joe it brings him down to average joes level
people wont repect him and he loses all his authority
think about the...
i can honestly see the logic (even though i dont agree with all of it, for example picking backrows to cover second row deficiencies who are picked to cover front row deficiencies) in almost all his decisions except the front row
the worst thing is sooner or later we are going to fluke a good...
mowen@8- we need him in the team for the lineout to cover timani who cant jump whos covering the props who cant push (makes sense huh)
simmons@6- see above and while we have him and mowen playing this is the best way to fit them in
cummins>tomane- superior defense and considering the amount of...
the fact is we have superior scrumaging props on the bench
anyone (refs) and any country (everyone else in the top ten) who takes scrumaging seriously sees this as a slap in the face
we all bitch and moan when england play for penalties because "its against the spirit of the game" and yet we...
sorry man i dont mean to bag on the force i just hate it when teams dont try
*im a waratahs supporter man so ive watch them not try for years before last year and it hurts
foley will improve your team but he'll never take them above mid table and it will be boring as bat shit the whole time
has anyone considered a point system for the shute shield whereby if a player changes clubs, comes from another state/ country they are assigned points and clubs are only allowed a certain amount of points per team or are penalised for having over X points in their starting team?
its something...